Presence and participation in a virtual court

被引:15
作者
Rossner, Meredith [1 ]
Tait, David [2 ]
机构
[1] Australian Natl Univ, Ctr Social Res & Methods, Criminol, Canberra, ACT, Australia
[2] Western Sydney Univ, Sch Humanities & Commun Arts, Justice Studies, Penrith, NSW, Australia
关键词
Co-presence; courtroom design; courtroom technology; distributed courts; participation; virtual courts; VIDEO COMMUNICATION; LINKS; DESIGN; IMPACT; JUSTICE;
D O I
10.1177/17488958211017372
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to an increase in the use of video-mediated justice practices. However, such developments have already been transforming justice over the course of the previous 20 years. Scholars and legal professinals have expressed concerns over how remote appearance in court impacts perceptions of the accused. In this article, we consider some of these concerns and explore the concept of the 'distributed court' as a potential remedy. Unlike traditional video appearance in court, where a defendant participates remotely while all other players are co-located in the same courtroom, in a distributed court all participants meet in a shared virtual space. Such a configuration is similar to the virtual courts developed worldwide during the COVID-19 pandemic. We draw on a reimagining of co-presence from scholars in the sociology of technology to elaborate the concept of the distributed court. We then present the results of a mock jury study that examines how jurors respond to variations in court technology configurations. We find that appearing by video does not impact the likelihood of a guilty verdict. Rather, a defendant appearing alone in a dock seems to be the most prejudicial location. We find that a distributed court can communicate equality and produce a shared experience of remote participation. We conclude with a discussion of how this research can inform best practice in a future where a significant number of criminal hearings are likely to continue in a virtual format.
引用
收藏
页码:135 / 157
页数:23
相关论文
共 67 条
  • [1] Ash J., 2020, FLORIDA BAR NEW 0811
  • [2] Bail Observation Project, 2019, SYST FAIL IMM BAIL H
  • [3] Bail Observation Project, 2013, OBSERVATIONS PUBLIC
  • [4] Bellone E. T., 2013, J INT COMMERCIAL LAW, V8, P24
  • [5] Judging in Place: Architecture, Design, and the Operation of Courts
    Bybee, Keith J.
    [J]. LAW AND SOCIAL INQUIRY-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN BAR FOUNDATION, 2012, 37 (04): : 1014 - 1028
  • [6] Copresence: Revisiting a Building Block for Social Interaction Theories
    Campos-Castillo, Celeste
    Hitlin, Steven
    [J]. SOCIOLOGICAL THEORY, 2013, 31 (02) : 168 - 192
  • [7] STAGING OF MAGISTRATES JUSTICE
    CARLEN, P
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY, 1976, 16 (01) : 48 - 55
  • [8] Collins R., 2004, Interaction Ritual Chains, DOI 10.1515/9781400851744
  • [9] Cooley C.H., 1956, The two major works of C.H. Cooley: Social organization and human nature and the social order
  • [10] Davis Robin, 2015, Research on Videoconferencing at Post-Arraignment Release Hearings: Phase I Final Report