Accuracy of Remote Examination for Detecting Potentially Malignant Oral Lesions: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

被引:3
作者
de Lima, Thayana Maria Navarro Ribeiro [1 ]
Moura, Ana Beatriz Rodrigues [1 ]
Bezerra, Paula Maria Maracaja [1 ]
Valenca, Ana Maria Gondim [1 ]
Vieira, Thiago Isidro [1 ]
Santiago, Bianca Marques [1 ]
Cavalcanti, Yuri Wanderley [1 ]
de Sousa, Simone Alves [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Fed Paraiba, Program Dent, BR-58051900 Joao Pessoa, PB, Brazil
关键词
diagnosis; neoplasms; teledentistry; systematic review; telemedicine; CANCER; QUALITY;
D O I
10.1089/tmj.2023.0096
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective: We aimed to investigate the accuracy of remote examination by photographs compared to in-person clinical examination for detecting potentially malignant oral lesions (PMOLs).Methods: The Reporting Guide and Guidelines for Writing Systematic Reviews (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis [PRISMA]) guided the reporting of findings. The search was conducted by two independent reviewers in six databases with no language restriction until November 2022. The Population, Test-Index, Reference Standard, Outcome and Study Design (PIROS) strategy guided the eligibility criteria, and studies with adult patients (P) examined remotely (I) and in-person (R) to verify the detection of PMOLs (O) were considered. The methodological quality was assessed by QUADAS-2, and the certainty of the evidence was measured by the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE).Results: A total of 769 files were identified. After removing duplicates and reading titles and abstracts, 16 were read in full, from which 6 articles then comprised the qualitative synthesis. The oral clinical examination was the reference standard in four studies. Five studies presented high risk of bias in at least one assessment domain. A high probability of detection of PMOL by remote examination (97.37%) was observed for the three studies included in the meta-analysis, which presented high heterogeneity among them. The certainty of evidence for the outcome was considered very low.Conclusions: Remote tools for detecting PMOLs may be feasible and assertive, but new studies are required to incorporate them into clinical practice.Clinical Relevance: Remote examination for the detection of PMOLs has the potential to favoring the early diagnosis of malignant lesions.
引用
收藏
页码:381 / 392
页数:12
相关论文
共 23 条
[1]  
Bergstrom A., 2015, UCL Briefing
[2]   Field validation of deep learning based Point-of-Care device for early detection of oral malignant and potentially malignant disorders [J].
Birur, Praveen N. ;
Song, Bofan ;
Sunny, Sumsum P. ;
Keerthi, G. ;
Mendonca, Pramila ;
Mukhia, Nirza ;
Li, Shaobai ;
Patrick, Sanjana ;
Shubha, G. ;
Subhashini, A. R. ;
Imchen, Tsusennaro ;
Leivon, Shirley T. ;
Kolur, Trupti ;
Shetty, Vivek ;
Bhushan, Vidya R. ;
Vaibhavi, Daksha ;
Rajeev, Surya ;
Pednekar, Sneha ;
Banik, Ankita Dutta ;
Ramesh, Rohan Michael ;
Pillai, Vijay ;
Kathryn, O. S. ;
Smith, Petra Wilder ;
Sigamani, Alben ;
Suresh, Amritha ;
Liang, Rongguang ;
Kuriakose, Moni A. .
SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2022, 12 (01)
[3]   Mobile health application for remote oral cancer surveillance [J].
Birur, Praveen N. ;
Sunny, Sumsum P. ;
Jena, Sidhant ;
Kandasarma, Uma ;
Raghavan, Shubhasini ;
Ramaswamy, Bhanushree ;
Shanmugam, Sunitha Perumal ;
Patrick, Sanjana ;
Kuriakose, Rohan ;
Mallaiah, Janhavi ;
Suresh, Amritha ;
Chigurupati, Radhika ;
Desai, Rani ;
Kuriakose, Moni Abraham .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN DENTAL ASSOCIATION, 2015, 146 (12) :886-894
[4]   Convolutional Neural Network-Based Clinical Predictors of Oral Dysplasia: Class Activation Map Analysis of Deep Learning Results [J].
Camalan, Seda ;
Mahmood, Hanya ;
Binol, Hamidullah ;
Araujo, Anna Luiza Damaceno ;
Santos-Silva, Alan Roger ;
Vargas, Pablo Agustin ;
Lopes, Marcio Ajudarte ;
Khurram, Syed Ali ;
Gurcan, Metin N. .
CANCERS, 2021, 13 (06) :1-18
[5]   Teledentistry in the diagnosis of oral lesions: A systematic review of the literature [J].
da Costa Flores, Anaclaudia Pereira ;
Lazaro, Samara Andreolla ;
Molina-Bastos, Cynthia Goulart ;
de Oliveira Guattini, Veronica Lucas ;
Umpierre, Roberto Nunes ;
Goncalves, Marcelo Rodrigues ;
Carrard, Vinicius Coelho .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL INFORMATICS ASSOCIATION, 2020, 27 (07) :1166-1172
[6]   Development of a mobile application for oral cancer screening [J].
Gomes, Mayra Sousa ;
Ferreti Bonan, Paulo Rogerio ;
Nicolau Ferreira, Vitor Yuri ;
Pereira, Laudenice de Lucena ;
Cruz Correia, Ricardo Joao ;
da Silva Teixeira, Helder Bruno ;
Pereira, Daniel Claudio ;
Bonan, Paulo .
TECHNOLOGY AND HEALTH CARE, 2017, 25 (02) :187-195
[7]   GRADE:: an emerging consensus on rating quality of evidence and strength of recommendations [J].
Guyatt, Gordon H. ;
Oxman, Andrew D. ;
Vist, Gunn E. ;
Kunz, Regina ;
Falck-Ytter, Yngve ;
Alonso-Coello, Pablo ;
Schuenemann, Holger J. .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2008, 336 (7650) :924-926
[8]   High referral accuracy for oral cancers and oral potentially malignant disorders using telemedicine [J].
Haron, Nabihah ;
Rajendran, Senthilmani ;
Kallarakkal, Thomas George ;
Zain, Rosnah Binti ;
Ramanathan, Anand ;
Abraham, Mannil Thomas ;
Lau, Shin Hin ;
Cheng, Lai Choo ;
Chong, Sherrie Mei Yee ;
Mohamed Azahar, Farah Aliya ;
Mohamad Zaini, Zuraiza ;
Chan, Siew Wui ;
Goh, Yet Ching ;
Lim, Daniel ;
Khairi, Juliana ;
Abidin, Marzuki Zainal ;
Abdul Rahman, Zainal Ariff ;
Liew, Chee Sun ;
Fong, Siew Chinn ;
Yang, Yi-Hsin ;
Ismail, Siti Mazlipah ;
Cheong, Sok Ching .
ORAL DISEASES, 2023, 29 (02) :380-389
[9]   Mobile Phone Imaging in Low Resource Settings for Early Detection of Oral Cancer and Concordance with Clinical Oral Examination [J].
Haron, Nabihah ;
Zain, Rosnah Binti ;
Nabillah, Wan Maria ;
Saleh, Amyza ;
Kallarakkal, Thomas George ;
Ramanathan, Anand ;
Sinon, Suraya Hani Mohd ;
Dent, DClin ;
Razak, Ishak Abdul ;
Cheong, Sok Ching .
TELEMEDICINE AND E-HEALTH, 2017, 23 (03) :192-199
[10]   Malignant transformation of oral potentially malignant disorders in males: a retrospective cohort study [J].
Ho, Pei-Shan ;
Chen, Pai-Li ;
Warnakulasuriya, Saman ;
Shieh, Tien-Yu ;
Chen, Yun-Kwan ;
Huang, I-Yueh .
BMC CANCER, 2009, 9