Cascading effects of management and landscape on insect pollinators, pollination services and yield in apple orchards

Recent insect pollinator declines, mainly due to the expansion and intensification of agricultural land use, are jeopardizing ecosystem service provisioning in agroecosystems. Organic farming has been suggested as a biodiversity-friendly alternative to conventional farming, but additional insights evaluating its effectiveness in perennial cropping systems are needed. Here, we provide a comprehensive analysis of local and landscape effects on the provided pollination services and yield in apple crops. We first used mixed models to disentangle effects of agricultural management and landscape effects on both taxonomic and functional diversity of wild bees and hoverflies during bloom in both organic and integrated pest management (IPM) apple orchards in Belgium, and then compared these biodiversity indicators with semi-natural grasslands as a benchmark. Next, we applied piecewise structural equation modeling to quantify the direct and indirect effects of orchard management type and landscape on fruit set, seed set and ultimately on crop yield. Orchards, regardless of their type of man-agement, hosted lower taxonomic and functional pollinator diversity compared to the semi-natural benchmark. Yet, pollinator abundance and diversity were higher in orchard edges and increased with small-scale landscape diversity, which was positively associated with the presence of semi-natural habitat, as well as arable and urban land. Investigating the cascading effects on apple yield, we found that yield levels were not shaped by the observed pollinator diversity or by the measured pollination services, but were lower in organic orchards. Overall, we conclude that apple yield was likely not pollinator limited in our study system, but that conserving and restoring semi-natural habitats, maintaining and expanding orchard edges through reducing field sizes and promoting landscape diversity are the most promising avenues for pollinator conservation in orchard landscapes.