Do risk factors differentiate DSM-5 and drive for thinness severity groups for anorexia nervosa?

BackgroundThe current study examined whether risk factors for anorexia nervosa (AN) were related to different levels of severity based on (a) the DSM-5/body mass index (BMI) and (b) drive for thinness (DT) severity ratings.MethodsThe sample comprised 153 pairs of individuals with a lifetime diagnosis AN per DSM-IV criteria and their non-ED sisters (N = 306, mean age = 26.53; mean current BMI = 20.42 kg/m2). The Oxford risk factor interview was used to establish AN-related risk factors. Individuals were categorised into the DSM-5 severity groups based on their lowest BMI, while the DT subscale from the eating disorder inventory-2 was used to classify individuals with AN into low and high DT groups.ResultsMultinominal regression models showed similar risk factors (e.g., perfectionism, having a history of being teased about weight and shape) contributed to the development of AN using the DSM-5 and DT severity ratings. Follow-up analyses across the severity groups for both indices revealed that only childhood perfectionism was found to be more common in the extreme severe DSM-5 BMI severity group compared to the severe DSM-5 group.ConclusionOverall, this study found little evidence for AN risk factors being related to the DSM-5 and DT severity ratings. However, given the novelty of this study, replication of the current results is warranted. Several risk factors, such as childhood obesity, have been found to contribute to the development of Anorexia Nervosa (AN). Yet, we are unsure if there is a set of risk factors that influence different levels of AN severity. While the DSM-5 suggests using BMI to measure severity, recent support favour the usage of drive for thinness (DT) as an alternative severity measure. Therefore, this study aimed to explore risk factors specifically associated with the development of different AN severity levels using both the DSM-5 BMI and DT severity classification systems. We recruited 153 pairs of individuals with a lifetime diagnosis AN per DSM-IV criteria and their non-ED sisters. The Oxford risk factor interview was used to establish AN-related risk factors. We found childhood perfectionism, weight/shape teasing, childhood obesity, and breast-related embarrassment to be significant risk factors for AN. Additionally, childhood perfectionism was more common in the extreme severe DSM-5 group compared to the severe DSM-5 group. This suggests that adding perfectionism-related aspects to prevention and early intervention programs for AN may be beneficial. Considering the novelty of this study, replication of the current results is needed.