The Principle of Explosion in the Stoic Logic

被引:0
作者
Tkaczyk, Marcin [1 ]
机构
[1] John Paul II Catholic Univ Lublin, Fac Philosophy, Lublin, Poland
关键词
ancient; Stoic logic; syllogistic; explosive;
D O I
10.12775/LLP.2024.012
中图分类号
B81 [逻辑学(论理学)];
学科分类号
010104 ; 010105 ;
摘要
I argue that the Stoic logic is explosive. The claim applies to the Stoics' syllogistic in the strictest sense, because there is a provable syllogism which qualifies as a principle of explosion. It applies also to the general consequence operation, in the sense that every sentence is derivable from any pair containing both a sentence and the negation of the sentence. Finally, it applies to the connective of implication (conditional), in the sense that any conditional is derivable, providing its antecedent is a conjunction of a sentence and the negation of the sentence. All three claims allow weakening, i.e., additions of extra premises to an inference or extra conjuncts to the antecedent of an implication, respectively. Consequently, no concept of relevance, let alone paraconsistency or connexivity is applicable to the Stoic logic; in particular, the Stoics' connective of implication is either material (Boolean) or formal (strict).
引用
收藏
页码:325 / 345
页数:21
相关论文
共 13 条
[1]  
Apuleius Platonicus Madaurensis, 1991, PHILOSOPHIA LIBRI
[2]  
Bobzien S., 1996, OXFORD STUDIES ANCIE, P133, DOI DOI 10.1093/OSO/9780198236702.003.0004
[3]  
Bury RobertGregg., 1933, SEXTUS EMPIRICUS OUT
[4]  
Empiricus Sextus., 1935, Against the Logicians
[5]  
Heiberg JohannL., 1894, SIMPLICII ARISTOTELI
[6]  
Laertius Diogenes., 1925, LIVES EMINENT PHILOS, VI
[7]  
Lukasiewicz Jan, 1927, PRZEGLADFILOZOFICNY, V30, P278
[8]  
Mates Benson, 1953, STOIC LOGIC, DOI [10.1525/9780520349070, DOI 10.1525/9780520349070]
[9]  
Nasieniewski Marek, 1998, LOG LOG PHILOS, V6, P55, DOI [10.12775/LLP.1998.003, DOI 10.12775/LLP.1998.003]
[10]   What is so bad about contradictions? (Approaches to paraconsistency) [J].
Priest, G .
JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1998, 95 (08) :410-426