Behavioral scales variability in patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness

BackgroundThe principal conditions differentiating disorders of consciousness (DOC) patients are the unresponsive wakefulness syndrome/vegetative state (UWS/VS) and the minimally conscious state (MCS). Many individuals who suffer from sudden-onset severe brain injury move through stages of UWS/VS and MCS before regaining full awareness. In some patients, the DOC condition is protracted for years (PDOC). In this study, we observed PDOC patients for 6 months to assess possible changes in their level of consciousness.MethodsWe enrolled 40 PDOC patients, 23 UWS/VS and 17 MCS hosted in a dedicated unit for long-term brain injury care. The time from injury was 472 +/- 533 days for UWS/VS and 1090 +/- 1079 days for MCS. The Wessex Head Injury Matrix (WHIM), Coma Recovery Scale-R (CRS-R), and Nociception Coma Scale were administered monthly for 6 months.ResultsDuring the period of assessment, the percentage of UWS/VS shifted from 58 to 45%, while for the MCS, from 42 to 55%. A positive correlation was found for the UWS/VS patients between the months of observation with the CRS-R total score and WHIM total numbers of behaviors (TNB). In the UWS/VS group, the CRS-R auditive and visual subscales correlated positively with the observation time. During the whole period of observation, 8 patients had constant CRS-R total scores while the WHIM TNB changed in 7 of them.ConclusionOur findings demonstrated that the monthly assessment of PDOC by means of the CRS-R and WHIM was able to detect also subtle changes in consciousness level.