Comparison of Two Printed Pseudoisochromatic Tests for Color Vision Assessment

SIGNIFICANCEThe Waggoner PIP24 is a pseudoisochromatic test with a pattern similar to the Ishihara test. This study determined that the W-PIP24 can be used clinically to yield screening results (or sensitivity and specificity) comparable with the Ishihara.PURPOSEThis study aimed to determine whether the W-PIP24 is equivalent to the Ishihara 38 edition pseudoisochromatic test in detecting red-green color vision defects. Also, the performance of each plate of the W-PIP24 in detecting the color vision defects relative to the Ishihara test was determined.METHODSSixty-three individuals with congenital red-green color vision defects and 57 with normal trichromacy were recruited. Participants were tested with both the Ishihara and W-PIP24. The first-order agreement coefficients were calculated for the Ishihara and W-PIP24. The results were also analyzed using specificity, sensitivity, efficiency, and predictive pass and fail values.RESULTSThe agreement between the W-PIP24 and Ishihara test using the recommended criterion of using all plates was perfect. The sensitivity, specificity, predictive pass, and predictive fail were 1.00 (95% confidence interval, 0.94 to 1.00).CONCLUSIONSThis study showed that the W-PIP24 using a failure criterion of three or more errors on screening plates 1 to 15 is equivalent to the Ishihara test while screening for red-green color vision deficiency using a failure criterion of three or more errors on screening plates 1 to 17 of the Ishihara 38 edition.