Using vignettes to explore policy tools for a self-driving transport future

被引:2
作者
Almlof, Erik [1 ]
机构
[1] KTH Royal Inst Technol, Integrated Transport Res Lab, Drottning Kristinas Vag 40, S-11428 Stockholm, Sweden
关键词
Self-driving vehicles; Automated driving; Urban planning; Mixed methods; Vignettes; AUTOMATED VEHICLES; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; RESPONSES;
D O I
10.1016/j.trip.2023.100922
中图分类号
U [交通运输];
学科分类号
08 ; 0823 ;
摘要
Researchers struggle to create simple yet nuanced diagrams or short abstracts that are easily comprehendible by non-experts. Research articles may be our primary communication method, but they are generally difficult to understand, making them unsuitable for general communication.This paper investigates a rarely used method in transport research - vignettes - to convey research results and elicit implications for public planners. Historically, these vignettes have been designed using qualitative methods, e.g., the Delphi method or by researchers' review of trends. However, this paper uses two vignettes originating from quantitative results from a simulation model paper (Almlo center dot f et al., 2022), investigating the impacts of self-driving technology. Rewriting the results into two short stories - vignettes - these stories then served as the starting point for semi-structured interviews and a workshop with six public officials in Stockholm, Sweden. The vignettes were used to understand what these results would mean to the participants and how they would combat potential problems connected to sustainability, given the vignettes. Finally, the interviews and the workshop were qualitatively analysed, and policy tools were identified that can steer the transport system towards societal goals.The vignettes were a powerful tool to help the participants envision a future with self-driving transport options and promote critical thinking regarding how each participant would be affected, given such a future. As such, vignettes should be further explored to help researchers investigate abstract subjects which participants may have difficulties understanding.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 52 条
[1]   USE OF VIGNETTES IN SURVEY-RESEARCH [J].
ALEXANDER, CS ;
BECKER, HJ .
PUBLIC OPINION QUARTERLY, 1978, 42 (01) :93-104
[2]  
Almlof E, 2022, Exploring societal impacts of self-driving public transport using four- step transport models
[3]   Will leisure trips be more affected than work trips by autonomous technology? Modelling self-driving public transport and cars in Stockholm, Sweden [J].
Almlof, Erik ;
Nybacka, Mikael ;
Pernestal, Anna ;
Jenelius, Erik .
TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE, 2022, 165 :1-19
[4]   Meta-analyses of fifteen determinants of public opinion about climate change taxes and laws [J].
Bergquist, Magnus ;
Nilsson, Andreas ;
Harring, Niklas ;
Jagers, Sverker C. .
NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE, 2022, 12 (03) :235-+
[5]  
Beser M, 2002, NATIONAL TRANSPORT MODELS: RECENT DEVELOPMENTS AND PROSPECTS, P101
[6]   The current state of scenario development: an overview of techniques [J].
Bishop, Peter ;
Hines, Andy ;
Collins, Terry .
FORESIGHT, 2007, 9 (01) :5-+
[7]  
Bloor M., 2006, Vignettes. Keywords in Qualitative Methods, Electronic Version
[8]   Scenario types and techniques:: Towards a user's guide [J].
Borjeson, Lena ;
Hojer, Mattlas ;
Dreborg, Karl-Henrik ;
Ekvall, Tomas ;
Finnveden, Goran .
FUTURES, 2006, 38 (07) :723-739
[9]  
Brown B. B, 1968, Delphi process: A methodology usedfor the elicitation of opinions of experts
[10]   The clock is ticking: The role of uncertainty, regulatory focus, and level of risk on supply chain disruption decision making behavior [J].
Cantor, David E. ;
Blackhurst, Jennifer V. ;
Cortes, Juan David .
TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART E-LOGISTICS AND TRANSPORTATION REVIEW, 2014, 72 :159-172