Deep Learning for Detection of Periapical Radiolucent Lesions: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Diagnostic Test Accuracy

被引:39
作者
Sadr, Soroush [1 ]
Mohammad-Rahimi, Hossein [2 ,3 ]
Motamedian, Saeed Reza [2 ,4 ,5 ]
Motie, Parisa
Vinayahalingam, Shankeeth [6 ]
Dianat, Omid [7 ]
Nosrat, Ali [7 ,8 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Hamadan Univ Med Sci, Sch Dent, Dept Endodont, Hamadan, Iran
[2] Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci, Res Inst Dent Sci, Dentofacial Deform Res Ctr, Tehran, Iran
[3] Sharif Univ Technol, Dept Comp Engn, Tehran, Iran
[4] ITU WHO Focus Grp Hlth, Top Grp Dent Diagnost & Digital Dent, Berlin, Germany
[5] Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci, Sch Dent, Dept Orthodont, Tehran, Iran
[6] Radboud Univ Nijmegen, Dept Oral & Maxillofacial Surg, Nijmegen Med Ctr, Nijmegen, Netherlands
[7] Univ Maryland, Sch Dent, Dept Adv Oral Sci & Therapeut, Div Endodont, Baltimore, MD USA
[8] Centreville Endodont, Centreville, VA USA
[9] Univ Maryland, Dept Adv Oral Sci & Therapeut, Div Endodont, 650 West Baltimore St,4th Floor, Baltimore, MD 21201 USA
关键词
Artificial intelligence; deep learning; dental radiograph; periapical lesion; sensitivity; specificity; APICAL PERIODONTITIS; ARTIFICIAL-INTELLIGENCE; NEURAL-NETWORKS; PERFORMANCE; MEDICINE; CYST;
D O I
10.1016/j.joen.2022.12.007
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Introduction: The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to investigate the overall accuracy of deep learning models in detecting periapical (PA) radiolucent lesions in dental radiographs, when compared to expert clinicians. Methods: Electronic databases of Medline (via PubMed), Embase (via Ovid), Scopus, Google Scholar, and arXiv were searched. Quality of eligible studies was assessed by using Quality Assessment and Diagnostic Accuracy Tool-2. Quantitative analyses were conducted using hierarchical logistic regression for meta-analyses on diagnostic accuracy. Subgroup analyses on different image modalities (PA radiographs, panoramic radiographs, and cone beam computed tomographic images) and on different deep learning tasks (classification, segmentation, object detection) were conducted. Certainty of evidence was assessed by using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation system. Results: A total of 932 studies were screened. Eighteen studies were included in the systematic review, out of which 6 studies were selected for quantitative analyses. Six studies had low risk of bias. Twelve studies had risk of bias. Pooled sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio, and diagnostic odds ratio of included studies (all image modalities; all tasks) were 0.925 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.862-0.960), 0.852 (95% CI, 0.810-0.885), 6.261 (95% CI, 4.717- 8.311), 0.087 (95% CI, 0.045-0.168), and 71.692 (95% CI, 29.957-171.565), respectively. No publication bias was detected (Egger's test, P 5 .82). Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluationshowed a "high" certainty of evidence for the studies included in the meta-analyses. Conclusion: Compared to expert clinicians, deep learning showed highly accurate results in detecting PA radiolucent lesions in dental radiographs. Most studies had risk of bias. There was a lack of prospective studies. (J Endod 2023;49:248-261.)
引用
收藏
页码:248 / 261.e3
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Diagnostic Accuracy of Rapid Antigen Tests for COVID-19 Detection: A Systematic Review With Meta-analysis [J].
Arshadi, Maniya ;
Fardsanei, Fatemeh ;
Deihim, Behnaz ;
Farshadzadeh, Zahra ;
Nikkhahi, Farhad ;
Khalili, Farima ;
Sotgiu, Giovanni ;
Bonjar, Amir Hashem Shahidi ;
Centis, Rosella ;
Migliori, Giovanni Battista ;
Nasiri, Mohammad Javad ;
Mirsaeidi, Mehdi .
FRONTIERS IN MEDICINE, 2022, 9
[42]   Deep Learning-Based Detection of Periapical Lesions in Periapical Radiographs [J].
Liu, Jian ;
Hong, Yanqing ;
Shao, Yu ;
Gao, Yongzhen ;
Pan, Kexu ;
Jin, Chaoran ;
Du, Yi ;
Yu, Xijiao .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL AND BIOLOGICAL ENGINEERING, 2024, 44 (05) :676-684
[43]   Diagnostic accuracy of tests for leprosy: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Gurung, P. ;
Gomes, C. M. ;
Vernal, S. ;
Leeflang, M. M. G. .
CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2019, 25 (11) :1315-1327
[44]   Diagnostic accuracy of artificial intelligence for approximal caries on bitewing radiographs: A systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Carvalho, Bruna Katherine Guimaraes ;
Nolden, Elias-Leon ;
Wenning, Alexander Schulze ;
Kiss-Dala, Szilvia ;
Agocs, Gergely ;
Roth, Ivett ;
Keremi, Beata ;
Geczi, Zoltan ;
Hegyi, Peter ;
Kivovics, Marton .
JOURNAL OF DENTISTRY, 2024, 151
[45]   Accuracy of artificial intelligence in caries detection: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Luke, Alexander Maniangat ;
Rezallah, Nader Nabil Fouad .
HEAD & FACE MEDICINE, 2025, 21 (01)
[46]   Diagnostic Accuracy of Deep Learning Models in Predicting Glioma Molecular Markers: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis [J].
Farahani, Somayeh ;
Hejazi, Marjaneh ;
Moradizeyveh, Sahar ;
Di Ieva, Antonio ;
Fatemizadeh, Emad ;
Liu, Sidong .
DIAGNOSTICS, 2025, 15 (07)
[47]   Artificial intelligence for X-ray scaphoid fracture detection: a systematic review and diagnostic test accuracy meta-analysis [J].
Kraus, Matan ;
Anteby, Roi ;
Konen, Eli ;
Eshed, Iris ;
Klang, Eyal .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2024, 34 (07) :4341-4351
[48]   Diagnostic Performance of Artificial Intelligence in Rib Fracture Detection: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis [J].
van den Broek, Marnix C. L. ;
Buijs, Jorn H. ;
Schmitz, Liselotte F. M. ;
Wijffels, Mathieu M. E. .
SURGERIES, 2024, 5 (01) :24-36
[49]   Evaluating Rabies Test Accuracy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Human and Canine Diagnostic Methods [J].
Candia-Puma, Mayron Antonio ;
Pola-Romero, Leydi ;
Barazorda-Ccahuana, Haruna Luz ;
Goyzueta-Mamani, Luis Daniel ;
Galdino, Alexsandro Sobreira ;
Machado-de-avila, Ricardo Andrez ;
Giunchetti, Rodolfo Cordeiro ;
Coelho, Eduardo Antonio Ferraz ;
Chavez-Fumagalli, Miguel Angel .
DIAGNOSTICS, 2025, 15 (04)
[50]   Diagnostic performance of deep learning in infectious keratitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis protocol [J].
Ong, Zun Zheng ;
Sadek, Youssef ;
Liu, Xiaoxuan ;
Qureshi, Riaz ;
Liu, Su-Hsun ;
Li, Tianjing ;
Sounderajah, Viknesh ;
Ashrafian, Hutan ;
Ting, Daniel Shu Wei ;
Said, Dalia G. ;
Mehta, Jodhbir S. ;
Burton, Matthew J. ;
Dua, Harminder Singh ;
Ting, Darren Shu Jeng .
BMJ OPEN, 2023, 13 (05)