Nonoperative Versus Operative Treatment of Type IIA Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: A Prospective Evaluation of 99 Patients

Background:Although current clinical practice guidelines from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons suggest that Type II and III supracondylar humerus (SCH) fractures be treated by closed reduction and pin fixation, controversy remains as to whether type IIa fractures with no rotation or angular deformity require surgery. The purpose of our study was to prospectively compare radiographic and functional outcomes of type IIa SCH fractures treated with or without surgery. Methods:Between 2017 and 2019, 105 patients between 2 and 12 years of age presenting with type IIa SCH fractures and without prior elbow trauma, neuromuscular or metabolic conditions, were prospectively enrolled. Ten orthopaedic surgeons managed the patients with 5 preferring surgical treatment and 5 preferring an initial attempt at nonoperative treatment. Patients in the nonoperative cohort were managed with a long-arm cast and close radiographic follow-up. Patients underwent a standardized protocol, including 3 to 4 weeks of casting, bilateral radiographic follow-up 6 months postinjury, and telephone follow-up at 6, 12, and 24 months. Results:Ninety-nine patients met the inclusion criteria (45 nonoperative and 54 operatives). Of the nonoperative patients, 4 (9%) were converted to surgery up to their first clinical follow-up. No differences were identified between the cohorts with respect to demographic data, but patients undergoing surgery had on average 6 degrees more posterior angulation at the fracture site preoperatively (P<0.05). At the final clinical follow-up (mean=6 mo), the nonoperative group had more radiographic extension (176.9 vs 174.4 degrees, P=0.04) as measured by the hourglass angle, but no other clinical or radiographic differences were appreciated. Complications were similar between the nonoperative and operative groups: refracture (4.4 vs 5.6%), avascular necrosis (2.2 vs 1.9%) and infection (0 vs 1.9%) (P>0.05). Patient-reported outcomes at a mean of 24 months showed no differences between groups. Conclusion:Contrary to American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons guidelines, about 90% of patients with type IIa supracondylar fractures can be treated nonoperatively and will achieve good radiographic and functional outcomes with mild residual deformity improving over time. Patients treated nonoperatively must be monitored closely to assess for early loss of reduction and the need for surgical intervention.