Is Medical Tourism Transcultural Hypogamy?

被引:0
作者
Naraindas, Harish [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Jawaharlal Nehru Univ, Ctr Study Social Syst, Sch Social Sci, New Delhi, Delhi, India
[2] Jawaharlal Nehru Univ, Ctr Study Social Syst, Sch Social Sci, New Mehrauli Rd,JNU Ring Rd, New Delhi, Delhi, India
关键词
Medical tourism; therapeutic travel; ayurveda; Kur; spa; cryogenics; HEALTH; TECHNOLOGIES;
D O I
10.1177/02576430231184534
中图分类号
K [历史、地理];
学科分类号
06 ;
摘要
This article attempts to make a set of interrelated arguments. It claims that the epithet 'medical tourism', which is of recent provenance, tacitly subscribes to a particular and narrow understanding of 'medicine', namely, the Anglo-American variant of biomedicine. This variant, unlike its Continental European counterpart, does not countenance the spa (Kur, Kuur, Termas, etc.) as 'medical' therapy, a therapy that is part of orthodox biomedicine on the continent, albeit on its fringe and one where pleasure and therapy often coexist. The Anglo-American variant leads to an exclusive focus on what may be called organ-based therapy with an emphasis on surgical and technological intervention, where uninsured and under-insured 'middle-class' patients travel from the White world to wog-land. This is a reversal of older forms of medical travel where rich wogs travelled from wog-land to the White world for medical treatment. The reversal results in a binary of White vampires and wog victims and is responsible, in part, for the moral tension of the oxymoron called 'medical tourism', with the other part of the oxymoron being constituted by the contradiction between pleasure and therapy. The vampire-victim binary in turn often mutes the mediating virtuosos- doctors, hospitals, medical travel operators, firms, companies, websites and most importantly, medical expertise and technology-in the analytical and explanatory canvas. In light of this, the article not only suggests that the epithet 'medical tourism' requires careful scrutiny and needs to be situated as part of a longer genealogy and larger canvas to include all kinds of transnational, transcultural and transregional medical travel, but it also makes a plea for re-examining the kind of morality play that the epithet engenders by asking, among other things, if vampires could also be victims, and what happens to this binary when the biomedical fringe (the Continental spa/Kur/Kuur/Termas) and alternative systems of medicine (e.g., Ayurveda and host of other therapies) are brought into play, or when doctors and therapists undertake travel for medical/therapeutic expertise.
引用
收藏
页码:109 / 124
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Medical Tourism: The Asian opportunities
    Banerjee, Dilip K.
    PROCEEDINGS OF 2010 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON BUSINESS, ECONOMICS AND TOURISM MANAGEMENT, 2010, : 278 - 282
  • [32] A Plea to Control Medical Tourism
    Niechajev, Igor
    Frame, James
    AESTHETIC PLASTIC SURGERY, 2012, 36 (01) : 202 - 206
  • [33] A Plea to Control Medical Tourism
    Igor Niechajev
    James Frame
    Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2012, 36 : 202 - 206
  • [34] A bibliometric study of medical tourism
    Habibi, Alireza
    Mousavi, Maryamossadat
    Jamali, Seyedh Mahboobeh
    Ale Ebrahim, Nader
    ANATOLIA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TOURISM AND HOSPITALITY RESEARCH, 2022, 33 (03): : 415 - 425
  • [35] Medical tourism in bariatric surgery
    Birch, Daniel W.
    Vu, Lan
    Karmali, Shahzeer
    Stoklossa, Carlene Johnson
    Sharma, Arya M.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2010, 199 (05) : 604 - 608
  • [36] MEDICAL TOURISM IN GLOBAL MARKET
    Matus, Jozef
    Martovic, Matej
    GLOBALIZATION AND ITS SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES, PTS I - VI, 2017, : 1518 - 1524
  • [37] THE MARKETING PROCESS OF MEDICAL TOURISM
    Rydback, Michelle
    Hyder, Akmal
    Borg, Erik
    Osarenkhoe, Aihie
    INNOVATION, ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND SUSTAINABLE VALUE CHAIN IN A DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENT, 2015, : 2720 - 2722
  • [38] An Exploratory Study of Factors Influencing Chinese Outbound Medical Tourism
    Chia, Kei Wei
    Liao, Yi Ming
    JOURNAL OF CHINA TOURISM RESEARCH, 2021, 17 (03) : 376 - 394
  • [39] "World Friendly Argentina". Medical Tourism and Provision of Health Mobility
    Basualdo, Lourdes
    SI SOMOS AMERICANOS-REVISTA DE ESTUDIOS TRANSFRONTERIZOS, 2020, 20 (02) : 67 - 90
  • [40] Assessment of Medical Tourism Development in Korea for the Achievement of Competitive Advantages
    Kim, Seongseop
    Lee, Jinsoo
    Jung, Jishim
    ASIA PACIFIC JOURNAL OF TOURISM RESEARCH, 2013, 18 (05) : 421 - 445