Biomechanics of hamstring tendon, quadriceps tendon, and bone-patellar tendon-bone grafts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a cadaveric study

Purpose The three most commonly used autografts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACL) are: bone-patellar tendon-bone (BTB), hamstring tendons (HT), and quadriceps tendon (QT). A cadaveric study was performed to determine if there were any differences in mechanical and structural properties under biomechanical testing. Methods Twenty-seven graft specimens were harvested from 9 human cadaveric legs. Mean donor age was 75.2 years (range 53-85 years). Twenty-two specimens (8 HT, 7 QT, and 7 BTB) completed cyclic preconditioning from 50 to 800 N for 200 cycles and a load to failure test at an extension rate of 1 mm/s. Structural and mechanical properties of BTB, HT, and QT grafts were compared using a one-way ANOVA and Tukey's honest significant difference. Results There was no difference in the ultimate load to failure (N) across all 3 graft types (p = 0.951). Quadriceps tendon demonstrated greater cross-sectional area (mm(2)) when compared to both HT and BTB (p = 0.001) and was significantly stiffer (N/mm) than HT but not BTB (p = 0.004). Stress (N/mm(2)) of the HT at ultimate load was greater than QT but not BTB (p = 0.036). Elastic modulus (MPa) of HT was greater than both QT and BTB (p = 0.016). Conclusion There was no difference in the ultimate load to failure of BTB, HT, and QT grafts harvested from the same specimens. All 3 grafts had similar loads to failure with a significant increase in stiffness when compared to the native ACL. Furthermore, QT demonstrated more favourable structural properties compared to HT and BTB with greater cross-sectional area to both HT and BTB and greater stiffness compared to HT.