ALARP in Engineering: Risk Based Design and CBA

被引:1
作者
Alakbarli, Emin [1 ]
Hamedanian, Mohammad Mehdi [1 ]
Guarascio, Massimo [1 ]
机构
[1] Sapienza Univ, Dept Civil Construct & Environm Engn, Rome, Italy
来源
PROCEEDINGS OF THE 8TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON COMPLEXITY, FUTURE INFORMATION SYSTEMS AND RISK, COMPLEXIS 2023 | 2023年
关键词
ALARP; CBA; Risk; Acceptability; Tolerability; Practicality; Reasonability;
D O I
10.5220/0011947600003485
中图分类号
TP39 [计算机的应用];
学科分类号
081203 ; 0835 ;
摘要
It has not been far, over a century, since humankind conceived that hazardous incidents should be substantially managed to procrastinate the future could-be hazards. In the middle of the twentieth century, nonetheless, safety measures were passed by officials and introduced to authorities, and private sectors, so as to reduce risks, environmental impacts of the hazards and to evaluate probable outcomes. Therefore, the concept of ALARP, meaning 'as low as reasonably practicable' presented back then, has been implemented in risk reduction management to make decisions upon acceptability and tolerability of risks. In order to do so, a few so-called tools, such as Cost-Benefit Analysis, are specified to societal and other types of risks so that we could weigh the balance of the amount of capital to be invested on safety on the one hand, and the extracted benefit attained out of the investment on the other. This implementation opaquely carries on several social, socio-economic, political and even environmental implications. Nevertheless, it has brought up some concerns into proponents' mindset, ranging from practicality and political reality to calling into question whether ALARP is mainly theoretical. The aim of this study is to figure out whether Cost-Benefit Analysis can be an appropriate tool to analyse the true outcome(s) of ALARP. This paper will offer a critical point of view over the risk-evaluating concept to discern how much it has been practically efficient.
引用
收藏
页码:61 / 68
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Enhanced CBA algorithm Based on Apriori Optimization and Statistical Ranking Measure
    Alwidian, Jaber
    Hammo, Bassam H.
    Obeid, Nadim
    VISION 2020: INNOVATION MANAGEMENT, DEVELOPMENT SUSTAINABILITY, AND COMPETITIVE ECONOMIC GROWTH, 2016, VOLS I - VII, 2016, : 4291 - 4306
  • [32] Formalizing process-based risk with Value-Focused Process Engineering
    Kristian Rotaru
    Carla Wilkin
    Leonid Churilov
    Dina Neiger
    Andrzej Ceglowski
    Information Systems and e-Business Management, 2011, 9 : 447 - 474
  • [33] Decision & risk based design structures: Decision support needs for conceptual, concurrent design
    Meshkat, L
    Feather, MS
    INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON SYSTEMS, MAN AND CYBERNETICS, VOL 1-4, PROCEEDINGS, 2005, : 2408 - 2412
  • [34] Resource-constrained scheduling of design changes based on simulation of change propagation process in the complex engineering design
    Li, Yuliang
    Zhao, Wei
    Zhang, Jie
    RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING DESIGN, 2019, 30 (01) : 21 - 40
  • [35] Risk management of tunnel engineering
    Jia, JP
    Wang, HT
    Hu, GZ
    Jin, XG
    Liu, JM
    PROGRESS IN SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, VOL V, PTS A AND B, 2005, 5 : 768 - 774
  • [36] SAFEDOR - the implementation of risk-based ship design and approval
    Breinholt, Christian
    Ehrke, Karl-Christian
    Papanikolaou, Apostolos
    Sames, Pierre C.
    Skjong, Rolf
    Strang, Tom
    Vassalos, Dracos
    Witolla, Thomas
    TRANSPORT RESEARCH ARENA 2012, 2012, 48 : 753 - 764
  • [37] Reverse-Engineering Risk
    O'Sullivan, Angela
    Mace, Lilith
    ERKENNTNIS, 2024, 90 (5) : 2021 - 2046
  • [38] Design and Application of Natural Disasters Risk Database Based on PostgreSQL
    Chen, Ke
    Wen, Jiahong
    Yu, Lizhong
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE FIRST SYMPOSIUM ON DISASTER RISK ANALYSIS AND MANAGEMENT IN CHINESE LITTORAL REGIONS, 2011, 18 : 453 - +
  • [39] Risk-Based Design of Transmission Lines for Hurricane Winds
    Malhotra, Praveen K.
    STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL, 2014, 24 (02) : 275 - 280
  • [40] A new method for applying choosing by advantages (CBA) multicriteria decision to a large number of design alternatives
    Arroyo, Paz
    Mourgues, Claudio
    Flager, Forest
    Correa, Maria Gabriela
    ENERGY AND BUILDINGS, 2018, 167 : 30 - 37