Chemical index components and quality control of Traditional Chinese Medicine: "Never change a winning team"? -A case study of volatile oil from Bupleuri radix

Chemical index components, especially those defined as quality control (QC) markers through spectrum-effect relationship approach, are commonly suggested and adopted as indicator for quality control of Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCMs). However, are chemical index components and quality control of TCMs "never change a winning team"? In this study, under the ponderation of the applicability of QC markers strategy, spectrumeffect relationship and OPLS-DA between GCxGC-MS fingerprint and inhibitory effect on the expression of extracellular secretory TNF-& alpha; of volatile oil from Bupleuri radix (BVO) was studied with the purpose of discovery of QC markers and establish a bioactive compounds-based QC method. 290 compounds of BVO were identified by GCxGC-MS. Besides, BVO had significant inhibitory effects on the expression of extracellular secretory TNF-& alpha; in a dose-dependent manner. The potency of different batches of BVOs could be distinguished with this bioassaybased method, which has been validated in terms of intermediate precision, repeatability, linearity, range and credibility tests. The QC markers of BVO were investigated by Spearman's correlation test and OPLS-DA. It is regrettable that there were no ideal QC markers of BVO could be found. In conclusion, quality control method relayed on chemical QC markers is not feasible for TCMs with complex composition but lack of ingredients that dominate in content, just like BVO. Alternatively, a bioassay-based method established in our study is suitable for quality control of BVO.