Comparison of hybrid data-driven and physical models for landslide susceptibility mapping at regional scales

Landslide susceptibility mapping (LSM) is essential for the spatial prediction of landslides and risk prevention. Physically based LSM models are confined by oversimplifications of physical processes and limited information about soil properties. Data-driven LSM models may give reliable results only when the training and the testing data have high similarity, and application in regions with different geological conditions is often inapplicable. This paper proposes four hybrid data-driven and physical models and compares these models in terms of cross-regional generalization ability and prediction uncertainty. The effects of physical module performance on the hybrid model are analyzed. For the physical modules of the four hybrid models, two-dimensional (2D) physically based models, TRIGRS and the infinite-slope stability models (ISSMs), and the three-dimensional (3D) physically based model, Scoops3D, are adopted. The data-driven modules all adopt the convolutional neural network (CNN) model. Two towns in the Three-Gorge Reservoir area of China are used as the training and testing areas. The results show that all hybrid models have better generalization ability than using the data-driven module exclusively. The prediction uncertainty is significantly reduced by pre-selecting training samples using the physical module. The optimal hybrid model is the one that integrates CNN and ISSM (under the saturated condition). It is then applied to a new region (Wushan County) to further validate the generalization ability. It can make accurate predictions without calibrating the trained model using new data from the validation area. Finally, the effectiveness of model averaging for improving the prediction performance is verified. Using model averaging, the AUC value in the validation area yields 0.834, which is even higher than the original realizations, with AUC values ranging from 0.683 to 0.817. Therefore, the optimal hybrid model can be directly used for LSM in the Three-Gorge Reservoir, and the findings can provide valuable guidance for generalization ability improvement and prediction uncertainty reduction of LSM models in other countries and regions.