Male youth's self-narrative and the discourse of meritocracy in South Korea

被引:2
作者
Park, Jayoung [1 ]
机构
[1] Hyupsung Univ, Dept Chinese Language & Culture, Hwaseong, South Korea
关键词
Meritocracy; fairness; justice; the weak-victim narrative; authoritarianism; South Korea;
D O I
10.1080/09502386.2023.2261967
中图分类号
Q98 [人类学];
学科分类号
030303 ;
摘要
In South Korea, which has seen a drastic power transfer from a progressive to an authoritarian government, a new form of the 'weak-victim' narrative has emerged in recent years, and changes and ruptures in the discourse on the weak have occurred. Young men in South Korea claim that they have been excluded from institutions, policies and systems and denied equal opportunities compared to women. It is brought to the fore the discourse of fairness.This article notes that a sense of faith in meritocracy is one of the contributors that generated the discourse of fairness. It examines how seemingly progressive policies conflicted with and were left stranded by the logic of fairness and meritocracy and takes a close look at why this happened. In addition, it reconstructs the social conditions that brought up the issue of fairness, investigating how the discourse of fairness emerged and how the significance of 'fairness' was shifted and re-conceptualized. Meanwhile, as the idea of meritocracy has become prevalent in society, a critical analysis of it was also conducted from multilateral angles. This article analyzes various aspects of the criticisms of meritocracy, discussing how we should view these criticisms and we can find possibilities to overcome the problematics of meritocracy.
引用
收藏
页码:91 / 104
页数:14
相关论文
共 19 条
[1]   We will be great again: Historical victimhood in populist discourse [J].
Al-Ghazzi, Omar .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CULTURAL STUDIES, 2021, 24 (01) :45-59
[2]  
Baek S.W., 2022, HWANGHAE REV, V115, P203
[3]  
Cheon G.Y., 2019, MEN 20S BIRTH SELF A
[4]  
Fraser Nancy., 2013, FORTUNES OF FEMINISM
[5]  
Fraser Nancy., 2019, OLD IS DYING NEW CAN
[6]  
Jeong Taeseok, 2021, [Economy and Society, 경제와 사회], V132, P12, DOI 10.18207/criso.2021..132.12
[7]  
Jihyun Choo,, 2020, Journal of Asian Sociology, V49, P477
[8]  
Keun Cho Hyung, 2022, [Critical Review of History, 역사비평], V140, P8
[9]  
Kim D.C., 2022, TEST MERITOCRACY KOR
[10]  
Kim Jeong H.W., 2022, WORLD FAIRNESS