Animal rights, animal research, and the need to reimagine science

被引:1
作者
Bobier, Christopher [1 ]
Reinhardt, Noah [2 ]
Pawlowski, Kate [3 ]
机构
[1] St Marys Univ Minnesota, Dept Theol & Philosophy, Winona, MN 55987 USA
[2] Univ Mary, Business Dept, Bismarck, ND USA
[3] St Marys Univ Minnesota, Publ Hlth, Winona, MN USA
来源
NEW BIOETHICS-A MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL OF BIOTECHNOLOGY AND THE BODY | 2024年 / 30卷 / 01期
关键词
Scientific research; Scientific education; Animals; Animal rights; VULNERABLE SUBJECTS; HUMANS;
D O I
10.1080/20502877.2023.2300232
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
What would it look like for researchers to take non-human animal rights seriously? Recent discussions foster the impression that scientific practice needs to be reformed to make animal research ethical: just as there is ethically rigorous human research, so there can be ethically rigorous animal research. We argue that practically little existing animal research would be ethical and that ethical animal research is not scalable. Since animal research is integral to the existing scientific paradigm, taking animal rights seriously requires a radical, wholesale reimagining of science.Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT05340426.
引用
收藏
页码:63 / 76
页数:14
相关论文
共 49 条
  • [31] Results of Two Cases of Pig-to-Human Kidney Xenotransplantation
    Montgomery, Robert A.
    Stern, Jeffrey M.
    Lonze, Bonnie E.
    Tatapudi, Vasishta S.
    Mangiola, Massimo
    Wu, Ming
    Weldon, Elaina
    Lawson, Nikki
    Deterville, Cecilia
    Dieter, Rebecca A.
    Sullivan, Brigitte
    Boulton, Gabriella
    Parent, Brendan
    Piper, Greta
    Sommer, Philip
    Cawthon, Samantha
    Duggan, Erin
    Ayares, David
    Dandro, Amy
    Fazio-Kroll, Ana
    Kokkinaki, Maria
    Burdorf, Lars
    Lorber, Marc
    Boeke, Jef D.
    Pass, Harvey
    Keating, Brendan
    Griesemer, Adam
    Ali, Nicole M.
    Mehta, Sapna A.
    Stewart, Zoe A.
    [J]. NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2022, 386 (20) : 1889 - 1898
  • [32] The Value of Mouse Models of Rare Diseases: A Spanish Experience
    Murillo-Cuesta, Silvia
    Artuch, Rafael
    Asensio, Fernando
    de la Villa, Pedro
    Dierssen, Mara
    Enriquez, Jose Antonio
    Fillat, Cristina
    Fourcade, Stephane
    Ibanez, Borja
    Montoliu, Lluis
    Oliver, Eduardo
    Pujol, Aurora
    Salido, Eduardo
    Vallejo, Mario
    Varela-Nieto, Isabel
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN GENETICS, 2020, 11
  • [33] Species selection for nonclinical safety assessment of drug candidates: Examples of current industry practice
    Namdari, Rostam
    Jones, Keith
    Chuang, Samuel S.
    Van Cruchten, Steven
    Dincer, Zuhal
    Downes, Noel
    Mikkelsen, Lars Friis
    Harding, Joanna
    Jaeckel, Sven
    Jacobsen, Bjoern
    Kinyamu-Akunda, Jacqueline
    Lortie, Andreanne
    Mhedhbi, Sofiene
    Mohr, Susanne
    Schmitt, Michael W.
    Prior, Helen
    [J]. REGULATORY TOXICOLOGY AND PHARMACOLOGY, 2021, 126
  • [34] National Association for Bioemedical Research, 2020, IMP AN RES
  • [35] National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, 1979, The Belmont report: Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research
  • [36] National Humane Education Society, 2023, AN RES ED
  • [37] National Research Council, 2004, COMMITTEE UPDATE SCI
  • [38] First clinical-grade porcine kidney xenotransplant using a human decedent model
    Porrett, Paige M.
    Orandi, Babak J.
    Kumar, Vineeta
    Houp, Julie
    Anderson, Douglas
    Killian, A. Cozette
    Hauptfeld-Dolejsek, Vera
    Martin, Dominque E.
    Macedon, Sara
    Budd, Natalie
    Stegner, Katherine L.
    Dandro, Amy
    Kokkinaki, Maria
    Kuravi, Kasinath, V
    Reed, Rhiannon D.
    Fatima, Huma
    Killian, John T., Jr.
    Baker, Gavin
    Perry, Jackson
    Wright, Emma D.
    Cheung, Matthew D.
    Erman, Elise N.
    Kraebber, Karl
    Gamblin, Tracy
    Guy, Linda
    George, James F.
    Ayares, David
    Locke, Jayme E.
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF TRANSPLANTATION, 2022, 22 (04) : 1037 - 1053
  • [39] Raj GM., 2022, Introduction to Basics of Pharmacology and Toxicology: Volume 3: Experimental Pharmacology: Research Methodology and Biostatistics, P649
  • [40] In vivo porcine training model for cranial neurosurgery
    Regelsberger, Jan
    Eicker, Sven
    Siasios, Ioannis
    Haenggi, Daniel
    Kirsch, Matthias
    Horn, Peter
    Winkler, Peter
    Signoretti, Stefano
    Fountas, Kostas
    Dufour, Henry
    Barcia, Juan A.
    Sakowitz, Oliver
    Westermaier, Thomas
    Sabel, Michael
    Heese, Oliver
    [J]. NEUROSURGICAL REVIEW, 2015, 38 (01) : 157 - 163