Clinical practice guidelines for neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy: A systematic review using the appraisal of guidelines for research and evaluation (AGREE) II instrument

被引:7
作者
Amer, Yasser S. [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ,5 ]
Anabrees, Jasim [6 ,7 ]
Abdelmawla, Mohamed [8 ]
Abdalgader, Ayman [9 ]
Almazroei, Asmaa [8 ]
Alhifzi, Ibrahim [10 ]
AlOnazi, Abdullah Hawash [11 ]
Sabr, Yasser [12 ]
Hneiny, Layal [13 ]
El-Malky, Ahmed [14 ,15 ]
Alshalawi, Ayesha [16 ]
Alayoubi, Ahmed [17 ]
Chaudhry, Iftikhar A. [18 ]
Elkhateeb, Omar [11 ]
机构
[1] King Khalid Univ Hosp, King Saud Univ Med City, Pediat Dept, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[2] King Saud Univ Med City, Qual Management Dept, Clin Practice Guidelines & Qual Res Unit, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[3] King Saud Univ, Res Chair Evidence Based Hlth Care & Knowledge Tra, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[4] Alexandria Univ, Alexandria Ctr Evidence Based Clin Practice Guidel, Alexandria, Egypt
[5] Guidelines Int Network, Adaptat Working Grp, Perth, Scotland
[6] King Saud Univ, Coll Med, Pediat Dept, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[7] Saudi Neonatol Soc SNS, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[8] King Fahad Armed Forces Hosp, Pediat Dept, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
[9] King Saud Med City, Pediat Hosp, Neonatol Dept, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[10] Specialist Hosp Abha, Abha, Saudi Arabia
[11] MOH, King Fahad Med City, Crit Care Serv, Neonatal Intens Care Unit, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[12] King Saud Univ, Coll Med, Obstet & Gynecol Dept, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[13] Univ South Dakota, Wegner Hlth Sci Lib, Sioux Falls, SD USA
[14] King Saud Univ, King Saud Univ Med City, Morbid & Mortal Unit, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[15] Acad Sci Res, Theodor Bilharz Res Inst TBRI, Publ Hlth & Community Med Dept, Cairo, Egypt
[16] Minist Hlth, Nursing Dept, King Saud Med City, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
[17] Umm Al Qura Univ, Pediat Dept, Mecca, Saudi Arabia
[18] Minist Hlth, Al Yamamah Hosp, Obstet & Gynecol Dept, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
来源
FRONTIERS IN PEDIATRICS | 2023年 / 11卷
关键词
hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy; HIE; pediatrics; neonatology; clinical practice guidelines; systematic review; AGREE II instrument; quality assessment; HYPOTHERMIA;
D O I
10.3389/fped.2023.1092578
中图分类号
R72 [儿科学];
学科分类号
100202 ;
摘要
Background and Objective: To systematically review, critically appraise the quality of recent clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for neonatal hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), and map their recommendations. Data Sources: CPG databases (GIN, ECRI, NICE, SIGN, DynaMed), Bibliographic databases (PubMed, Embase, CINAHL), and related specialized professional societies (e.g., AAP, CPS, BAPM, RCPCH, and SNS). Study Selection: Original de-novo developed evidence-based CPGs for HIE, group authorship, Arabic or English languages, and international or national scope. The systematic review was drafted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement and Johnston et al methodological guide. Data Extraction: Quality assessment of the included HIE CPGs by the Appraisal of Guidelines for REsearch & Evaluation II (AGREE II) Instrument and report their characteristics, AGREE II ratings, and recommendations Data Synthesis: Our search retrieved 2,489 citations, of which two recent HIE CPGs were eligible and appraised: Canadian Paediatric Society (CPS) and Queensland Maternity and Neonatal Services (QMN). The overall assessment of the QMN CPG was superior (83%). Domain 1 (Scope & Purpose) scored (47%, 63%), Domain 2 (Stakeholder Involvement) (72%, 39%), Domain 3 (Rigour of Development) (48%, 43%), Domain 4 (Clarity & Presentation) (100%, 96%), Domain 5 (Applicability) (59%, 9%), and Domain 6 (Editorial Independence) (67%, 17%) for the QMN and CPS CPGs respectively. All appraisers recommended the QMN CPG for use in practice. Conclusion: The methodological quality of the QMN CPG was superior with the relevant recommendations for its use in neonatal practice. Limitations: limited to Arabic and English languages.
引用
收藏
页数:9
相关论文
共 29 条
[1]  
Amer Y., 2021, PROSPERO
[2]   Quality assessment of clinical practice guidelines for neonatal sepsis using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II Instrument: A systematic review of neonatal guidelines [J].
Amer, Yasser S. ;
Shaiba, Lana A. ;
Hadid, Adnan ;
Anabrees, Jasim ;
Almehery, Abdulrahman ;
AAssiri, Manal ;
Alnemri, Abdulrahman ;
Al Darwish, Amira R. ;
Baqawi, Badi ;
Aboshaiqah, Ahmad ;
Hneiny, Layal ;
Almaghrabi, Rana H. ;
El-Malky, Ahmed M. ;
Al-Dajani, Nawaf M. .
FRONTIERS IN PEDIATRICS, 2022, 10
[3]   Adapting evidence-based clinical practice guidelines at university teaching hospitals: A model for the Eastern Mediterranean Region [J].
Amer, Yasser S. ;
Wahabi, Hayfaa A. ;
Abou Elkheir, Manal M. ;
Bawazeer, Ghada A. ;
Iqbal, Shaikh M. ;
Titi, Maher A. ;
Ekhzaimy, Aishah ;
Alswat, Khalid A. ;
Alzeidan, Rasmieh A. ;
Al-Ansary, Lubna A. .
JOURNAL OF EVALUATION IN CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2019, 25 (04) :550-560
[4]   The 'Adapted ADAPTE': an approach to improve utilization of the ADAPTE guideline adaptation resource toolkit in the Alexandria Center for Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines [J].
Amer, Yasser Sami ;
Elzalabany, Mahmoud Munir ;
Omar, Tarek Ismael ;
Ibrahim, Afaf Gaber ;
Dowidar, Nabil Lotfy .
JOURNAL OF EVALUATION IN CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2015, 21 (06) :1095-1106
[5]   A Systematic Review of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Acute Procedural Pain on Neonates [J].
Balice-Bourgois, Colette ;
Zumstein-Shaha, Maya ;
Vanoni, Federica ;
Jaques, Cecile ;
Newman, Christopher J. ;
Simonetti, Giacomo D. .
CLINICAL JOURNAL OF PAIN, 2020, 36 (05) :390-398
[6]   Measurement error and correlation coefficients [J].
Bland, JM ;
Altman, DG .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 313 (7048) :41-42
[7]   The prognostic value of neonatal conventional-EEG monitoring in hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy during therapeutic hypothermia [J].
Bourel-Ponchel, Emilie ;
Querne, Laurent ;
Flamein, Florence ;
Ghostine-Ramadan, Ghida ;
Wallois, Fabrice ;
Lamblin, Marie Dominique .
DEVELOPMENTAL MEDICINE AND CHILD NEUROLOGY, 2023, 65 (01) :58-66
[8]   What to do with all the AGREEs? The AGREE portfolio of tools to support the guideline enterprise [J].
Brouwers, Melissa C. ;
Spithoff, Karen ;
Lavis, John ;
Kho, Michelle E. ;
Makarski, Julie ;
Florez, Ivan D. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2020, 125 :191-197
[9]   Clinical Practice Guidelines Registry: Toward Reducing Duplication, Improving Collaboration, and Increasing Transparency [J].
Chen, Yaolong ;
Guyatt, Gordon H. ;
Munn, Zachary ;
Florez, Ivan D. ;
Marusic, Ana ;
Norris, Susan L. ;
Kredo, Tamara ;
Qaseem, Amir .
ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2021, 174 (05) :705-+
[10]   Clinical practice guidelines on newborn hearing screening: A systematic quality appraisal using the AGREE II instrument [J].
Chorath, Kevin ;
Garza, Luis ;
Tarriela, Aina ;
Luu, Neil ;
Rajasekaran, Karthik ;
Moreira, Alvaro .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PEDIATRIC OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY, 2021, 141