Trustworthy evidence-based versus untrustworthy guidelines: detecting the difference

被引：5
作者：
Lima, Joao Pedro [1 ]
Tangamornsuksan, Wimonchat [1 ]
Guyatt, Gordon H. [1 ]
机构：
[1] McMaster Univ, Dept Hlth Res Methods Evidence & Impact, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada
来源：
FAMILY MEDICINE AND COMMUNITY HEALTH | 2023年 / 11卷 / 04期
关键词：
Guidelines as Topic; Practice Guidelines as Topic; CLINICAL-PRACTICE GUIDELINES; COORDINATING EFFORTS; USERS GUIDES; OF-INTEREST; GRADE; DEVELOPMENT; RECOMMENDATIONS; QUALITY; CARE;
D O I：
10.1136/fmch-2023-002437
中图分类号：
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号：
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要：
Guidelines are essential tools in healthcare decision-making. Trustworthy guidelines inform clinicians not only on the direction (against or in favour) and strength (strong or weak/conditional) of recommendations but also on the certainty of the underlying evidence. Developing trustworthy guidelines requires panellists with clinical and methodological expertise who consider patients' values and preferences. Adherence to trustworthiness standards remains variable; clinicians should, therefore, be able to distinguish trustworthy from untrustworthy guidelines. In this paper, we offer eight domains of disparities between trustworthy evidence-based guidelines and less trustworthy guidelines.
引用
收藏
页数：6
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   National Prehospital Evidence-Based Guidelines Strategy: A Summary for EMS Stakeholders [J].
Martin-Gill, Christian ;
Gaither, Joshua B. ;
Bigham, Blair L. ;
Myers, J. Brent ;
Kupas, Douglas F. ;
Spaite, Daniel W. .
PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE, 2016, 20 (02) :175-183
[42]   Guidelines and evidence-based recommendations in anaesthesia: where do we stand? [J].
Rong, Lisa Q. ;
Audisio, Katia ;
O'Shaughnessy, Sinead M. .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 2022, 128 (06) :903-908
[43]   Evidence-based nutrition guidelines for cancer survivors in Europe: a call for action [J].
Keaver, Laura ;
Houlihan, Christine ;
O'Callaghan, Niamh ;
LaVertu, Amy E. ;
Ding, Xinge ;
Zhang, Fang Fang .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION, 2022, 76 (06) :819-826
[44]   A review of grading systems for evidence-based guidelines produced by medical specialties [J].
Baker, Adrian ;
Young, Katharine ;
Potter, Jonathan ;
Madan, Ira .
CLINICAL MEDICINE, 2010, 10 (04) :358-363
[45]   The role of evidence-based guidelines in the diagnosis and treatment of functional neurological disorder [J].
Tolchin, Benjamin ;
Baslet, Gaston ;
Carson, Alan ;
Dworetzky, Barbara A. ;
Goldstein, Laura H. ;
LaFrance, W. Curt ;
Martino, Steve ;
Perez, David L. ;
Reuber, Markus ;
Stone, Jon ;
Szaflarski, Jerzy P. .
EPILEPSY & BEHAVIOR REPORTS, 2021, 16
[46]   Quality of evidence-based guidelines for platelet transfusion and use: A systematic review [J].
Al-Riyami, Arwa Z. ;
Jug, Rachel ;
La Rocca, Ursula ;
Keshavarz, Homa ;
Landry, Denise ;
Shehata, Nadine ;
Stanworth, Simon J. ;
Nahirniak, Susan .
TRANSFUSION, 2021, 61 (03) :948-958
[47]   The Minimal Clinically Important Difference in Allergen Immunotherapy: An Evidence-Based Approach [J].
Pfaar, Oliver ;
Moesges, Ralph ;
Blaiss, Michael S. ;
Becker, Sven ;
DuBuske, Lawrence ;
Bernstein, Jonathan A. ;
Berger, Uwe E. ;
Berger, Markus ;
Dramburg, Stephanie ;
Shamji, Mohamed H. ;
Graessel, Anke ;
Starchenka, Sviatlana ;
Birkholz, Katrin ;
Armfield, Oliver ;
Sellwood, Fiona ;
Kramer, Matthias F. ;
Skinner, Murray A. ;
de Kam, Pieter-Jan .
ALLERGY, 2025,
[48]   The importance of evidence-based supportive care practice guidelines in childhood cancer-a plea for their development and implementation [J].
Loeffen, E. A. H. ;
Kremer, L. C. M. ;
Mulder, R. L. ;
Font-Gonzalez, A. ;
Dupuis, L. L. ;
Sung, L. ;
Robinson, P. D. ;
van de Wetering, M. D. ;
Tissing, W. J. E. .
SUPPORTIVE CARE IN CANCER, 2017, 25 (04) :1121-1125
[49]   Evidence-poor medicine: just how evidence-based are Australian clinical practice guidelines? [J].
Venus, Cameron ;
Jamrozik, Euzebiusz .
INTERNAL MEDICINE JOURNAL, 2020, 50 (01) :30-37
[50]   Current Guidelines Have Limited Applicability to Patients with Comorbid Conditions: A Systematic Analysis of Evidence-Based Guidelines [J].
Lugtenberg, Marjolein ;
Burgers, Jako S. ;
Clancy, Carolyn ;
Westert, Gert P. ;
Schneider, Eric C. .
PLOS ONE, 2011, 6 (10)
12345