Virtual reality and the problem of illusion

被引:0
|
作者
Dokuchayev, I. I. [1 ]
Golokhvast, K. S. [2 ]
Sokolov, A. M. [1 ]
机构
[1] St Petersburg State Univ, 7-9 Univ Skaya Nab, St Petersburg 199034, Russia
[2] Russian Acad Sci, Siberian Fed Sci Ctr Agrobiotechnol, 26 Ul Centralnaya, Krasnoobsk 630501, Novosibirsk Reg, Russia
来源
VESTNIK SANKT-PETERBURGSKOGO UNIVERSITETA-FILOSOFIYA I KONFLIKTOLOGIYA | 2023年 / 39卷 / 01期
关键词
original reality; virtual reality; simulated reality; illusionary reality; problem of the Matrix; problem of evidence; effect of presence; immersion;
D O I
10.21638/spbu17.2023.102
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The paper touches upon the problem of differentiating between virtual reality and original reality. The article makes a contribution to the modern ontology, as it discusses the problem of the status of virtual reality, which is formed by modern technical and mathematical means using cognitive technologies. The work is based on the concepts of E. Husserl and H. Putnam, as well as theories of psychophysiology and cognitive sciences. Arguments are provided for the following opposing statements: that it is possible to differentiate between them and that it is not. To specify the distinctive features of virtual reality, the latter is described as a system of perceived existing things and in comparison to other forms of such systems: subjective and objective, individual and social, natural and cultural, material and ideal, original and fictional, abstract and transcendental, evident and illusionary, true and false, erroneous and imitative, deceitful and mistaken, performative and simulating, conditional and unconditional ones. This part of the article qualifies virtual reality as illusion created via imitation. It is further revealed that the key distinctive feature of original reality, which is defined in the modern phenomenology as the maximal level of evidence, is applicable to virtual reality as well. The major argument in favor of the provable difference between virtual and original reality, which the contemporary analytic philosophy offers, can be confuted by means of a thought experi-ment based on the doubling of virtual reality. The final part of the article discusses psychologi-cal (experiment-based cognitive) arguments in favor of differentiating between virtual and original reality successfully: effect of presence and immersion. Both effects are typical of the reality types under comparison, as well as of experiencing these realities. The paper concludes that neither philosophy nor cognitive sciences can offer a compelling argument to differentiate between original reality and virtual reality.
引用
收藏
页码:18 / 29
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Immersion and the illusion of presence in virtual reality
    Slater, Mel
    BRITISH JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2018, 109 (03) : 431 - 433
  • [2] Virtual reality documentaries and the illusion of presence
    Studt SJ, Eric
    STUDIES IN DOCUMENTARY FILM, 2021, 15 (02) : 175 - 185
  • [3] A Separate Reality: An Update on Place Illusion and Plausibility in Virtual Reality
    Slater, Mel
    Banakou, Domna
    Beacco, Alejandro
    Gallego, Jaime
    Macia-Varela, Francisco
    Oliva, Ramon
    FRONTIERS IN VIRTUAL REALITY, 2022, 3
  • [4] Virtual World of Computer Games: Reality or Illusion?
    Samoylova, Elena
    LUMEN 2014 - FROM THEORY TO INQUIRY IN SOCIAL SCIENCES, 2014, 149 : 842 - 845
  • [5] The Rubber Hand Illusion in Virtual Reality and the RealWorld Comparable but Different
    Kocur, Martin
    Kalus, Alexander
    Bogon, Johanna
    Henze, Niels
    Christian, Wolff
    Schwind, Valentin
    28TH ACM SYMPOSIUM ON VIRTUAL REALITY SOFTWARE AND TECHNOLOGY, VRST 2022, 2022,
  • [6] Towards an objective measurement of presence, place illusion, and plausibility illusion in virtual reality using electroencephalography
    Bahavan, Thiru Thillai Nadarasar
    Navaratnarajah, Suman
    Owinda, Dulindu
    Akalanka, Inoj
    Peiris, Roshan
    Silva, Anjula De
    VIRTUAL REALITY, 2023, 27 (03) : 2649 - 2664
  • [7] Towards an objective measurement of presence, place illusion, and plausibility illusion in virtual reality using electroencephalography
    Thiru Thillai Nadarasar Bahavan
    Suman Navaratnarajah
    Dulindu Owinda
    Inoj Akalanka
    Roshan Peiris
    Anjula De Silva
    Virtual Reality, 2023, 27 : 2649 - 2664
  • [8] The Illusion of Animal Body Ownership and Its Potential for Virtual Reality Games
    Krekhov, Andrey
    Cmentowski, Sebastian
    Krueger, Jens
    2019 IEEE CONFERENCE ON GAMES (COG), 2019,
  • [9] Does affective touch influence the virtual reality full body illusion?
    de Jong, Jutta R.
    Keizer, Anouk
    Engel, Manja M.
    Dijkerman, H. Chris
    EXPERIMENTAL BRAIN RESEARCH, 2017, 235 (06) : 1781 - 1791
  • [10] Does affective touch influence the virtual reality full body illusion?
    Jutta R. de Jong
    Anouk Keizer
    Manja M. Engel
    H. Chris Dijkerman
    Experimental Brain Research, 2017, 235 : 1781 - 1791