Replication of the bSTAR sequence and open-source implementation

Purpose: The reproducibility of scientific reports is crucial to advancing human knowledge. This paper is a summary of our experience in replicating a balanced SSFP half-radial dual-echo imaging technique (bSTAR) using open-source frameworks as a response to the 2023 ISMRM "repeat it with me" Challenge. Methods: We replicated the bSTAR technique for thoracic imaging at 0.55T. The bSTAR pulse sequence is implemented in Pulseq, a vendor neutral open-source rapid sequence prototyping environment. Image reconstruction is performed with the open-source Berkeley Advanced Reconstruction Toolbox (BART). The replication of bSTAR, termed open-source bSTAR, is tested by replicating several figures from the published literature. Original bSTAR, using the pulse sequence and image reconstruction developed by the original authors, and open-source bSTAR, with pulse sequence and image reconstruction developed in this work, were performed in healthy volunteers. Results: Both echo images obtained from open-source bSTAR contain no visible artifacts and show identical spatial resolution and image quality to those in the published literature. A direct head-to-head comparison between open-source bSTAR and original bSTAR on a healthy volunteer indicates that open-source bSTAR provides adequate SNR, spatial resolution, level of artifacts, and conspicuity of pulmonary vessels comparable to original bSTAR. Conclusion: We have successfully replicated bSTAR lung imaging at 0.55T using two open-source frameworks. Full replication of a research method solely relying on information on a research paper is unfortunately rare in research, but our success gives greater confidence that a research methodology can be indeed replicated as described.