ULTRASOUND ELASTOGRAPHY FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF ENDOMETRIOSIS AND ADENOMYOSIS: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW WITH META-ANALYSIS

被引:9
作者
Brunelli, Ana Claudia [1 ]
Brito, Luiz Gustavo Oliveira [1 ]
Moro, Flavia Assad Salum [1 ]
Jales, Rodrigo Menezes [1 ]
Yela, Daniela Angerame [1 ]
Benetti-Pinto, Cristina Laguna [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Estadual Campinas, Sch Med Sci, Dept Obstet & Gynecol, Campinas, Brazil
[2] Univ Campinas UNICAMP, Sch Med Sci, Dept Obstet & Gynecol, Alexander Fleming St 101, BR-13083881 Campinas, SP, Brazil
关键词
Strain elastography; Shear wave elastography; Ultrasound; Endometriosis; Adenomyosis; Endome-trioma; Accuracy; Systematic review; SHEAR-WAVE ELASTOGRAPHY; TRANSVAGINAL ULTRASOUND; PELVIC ENDOMETRIOSIS; EFSUMB GUIDELINES; CLINICAL-USE; ELASTOSONOGRAPHY; RECOMMENDATIONS; PRINCIPLES; OVARIAN;
D O I
10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2022.11.006
中图分类号
O42 [声学];
学科分类号
070206 ; 082403 ;
摘要
Elastography is capable of measuring tissue mechanical properties and elasticity. It is used to help diagnose various diseases, although its use in pelvic endometriosis remains to be established. A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted to assess transvaginal ultrasound elastography for the diagnosis of different manifestations of endometriosis and adenomyosis. PRISMA guidelines were used for a Medline, PubMed, Embase, BVS/Bireme, Scopus, Cochrane Library and Escudos database search. Studies indexed until March 2021 that evaluated elastography compared with histopathological results (gold standard), ultrasound or mag-netic resonance imaging for diagnosis of pelvic endometriosis and adenomyosis were eligible. The Rayyan plat-form was used to select studies. Sensitivity (S), specificity (Ps), positive and negative predictive values and receiver operating characteristic curves were calculated for elastographic diagnosis of endometriosis. A meta -analysis using Review Manager 5 and Open Meta Analyst was performed. Bias risk in the studies was analyzed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS)-2 tool. This systematic review was pro-spectively registered in the PROSPERO database: CRD42021244555. Among the 163 identified citations, 10 stud-ies were eligible for review (5 for diagnosis of adenomyosis, 2 for endometrioma, 3 for deep intestinal endometriosis and rectovaginal septum [deep pelvic endometriosis], N = 744 women). In deep pelvic endometri-osis, lesions diagnosed by elastography were found to correlate with histopathology results. Increased "stiffness" (elastography) was associated with a higher fibrotic component, with S = 78%-100% and Ps = 100%, according to the authors. On elastography, endometriomas were stiffer than hemorrhagic cysts (S = 82%, Ps = 79%) and malignant tumors (S = 86%, Ps = 100%). For these lesions, a meta-analysis could not be performed because the small number of studies and insufficient data. In adenomyosis, meta-analysis and receiver operating characteris-tic curve analysis revealed that elastography had good sensitivity and specificity. Studies indicated a low bias risk by QUADAS-2. Elastography had high sensitivity and specificity for deep pelvic endometriosis diagnosis, and its findings correlated with histopathology results. For adenomyosis, the meta-analysis confirmed the sensitivity and specificity results of the studies. Given these results, elastography may be a promising imaging test, contributing to non-invasive diagnosis of endometriosis and adenomyosis. (E-mail: laguna.unicamp@gmail.com) (c) 2022 World Federation for Ultrasound in Medicine & Biology. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:699 / 709
页数:11
相关论文
共 45 条
[1]   Value of ultrasound shear wave elastography in the diagnosis of adenomyosis [J].
Acar, S. ;
Millar, E. ;
Mitkova, M. ;
Mitkov, V. .
ULTRASOUND, 2016, 24 (04) :205-213
[2]   Time elapsed from onset of symptoms to diagnosis of endometriosis in a cohort study of Brazilian women [J].
Arruda, MS ;
Petta, CA ;
Abrao, MS ;
Benetti-Pinto, CL .
HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2003, 18 (04) :756-759
[3]   EFSUMB Guidelines and Recommendations on the Clinical Use of Ultrasound Elastography. Part 1: Basic Principles and Technology [J].
Bamber, J. ;
Cosgrove, D. ;
Dietrich, C. F. ;
Fromageau, J. ;
Bojunga, J. ;
Calliada, F. ;
Cantisani, V. ;
Correas, J. -M. ;
D'Onofrio, M. ;
Drakonaki, E. E. ;
Fink, M. ;
Friedrich-Rust, M. ;
Gilja, O. H. ;
Havre, R. F. ;
Jenssen, C. ;
Klauser, A. S. ;
Ohlinger, R. ;
Saftoiu, A. ;
Schaefer, F. ;
Sporea, I. ;
Piscaglia, F. .
ULTRASCHALL IN DER MEDIZIN, 2013, 34 (02) :169-184
[4]   The utility of ultrasound elastography in differentiation of endometriomas and hemorrhagic ovarian cysts [J].
Batur, Abdussamet ;
Yavuz, Alpaslan ;
Ozgokce, Mesut ;
Bora, Aydin ;
Bulut, Mehmet Deniz ;
Arslan, Harun ;
Alpaslan, Muhammed .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ULTRASONICS, 2016, 43 (03) :395-400
[5]   ESHRE guideline: endometriosis [J].
Becker, Christian M. ;
Bokor, Attila ;
Heikinheimo, Oskari ;
Horne, Andrew ;
Jansen, Femke ;
Kiesel, Ludwig ;
King, Kathleen ;
Kvaskoff, Marina ;
Nap, Annemiek ;
Petersen, Katrine ;
Saridogan, Ertan ;
Tomassetti, Carla ;
van Hanegem, Nehalennia ;
Vulliemoz, Nicolas ;
Vermeulen, Nathalie .
HUMAN REPRODUCTION OPEN, 2022, 2022 (02)
[6]  
Brubel R, 2020, MED SCI MONITOR, V56, P342
[7]   Endometriosis and infertility [J].
Bulletti, Carlo ;
Coccia, Maria Elisabetta ;
Battistoni, Silvia ;
Borini, Andrea .
JOURNAL OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTION AND GENETICS, 2010, 27 (08) :441-447
[8]   Rethinking mechanisms, diagnosis and management of endometriosis [J].
Chapron, Charles ;
Marcellin, Louis ;
Borghese, Bruno ;
Santulli, Pietro .
NATURE REVIEWS ENDOCRINOLOGY, 2019, 15 (11) :666-682
[9]   EFSUMB Guidelines and Recommendations on the Clinical Use of Ultrasound Elastography. Part 2: Clinical Applications [J].
Cosgrove, D. ;
Piscaglia, F. ;
Bamber, J. ;
Bojunga, J. ;
Correas, J. -M. ;
Gilja, O. H. ;
Klauser, A. S. ;
Sporea, I. ;
Calliada, F. ;
Cantisani, V. ;
D'Onofrio, M. ;
Drakonaki, E. E. ;
Fink, M. ;
Friedrich-Rust, M. ;
Fromageau, J. ;
Havre, R. F. ;
Jenssen, C. ;
Ohlinger, R. ;
Saftoiu, A. ;
Schaefer, F. ;
Dietrich, C. F. .
ULTRASCHALL IN DER MEDIZIN, 2013, 34 (03) :238-253
[10]   Diagnosing Deep Endometriosis Using Transvaginal Elastosonography [J].
Ding, Ding ;
Chen, Yishan ;
Liu, Xishi ;
Jiang, Zongqin ;
Cai, Xianjun ;
Guo, Sun-Wei .
REPRODUCTIVE SCIENCES, 2020, 27 (07) :1411-1422