An International Expert Delphi Consensus on Defining Textbook Outcome in Liver Surgery (TOLS)

被引：37

作者：

Gorgec, Burak ^{[1
,2
,3
,4
]}

Cacciaguerra, Andrea Benedetti ^{[1
,4
,5
]}

Pawlik, Timothy M. ^{[6
,7
]}

Aldrighetti, Luca A. ^{[8
]}

Alseidi, Adnan A. ^{[9
]}

Cillo, Umberto ^{[10
]}

Kokudo, Norihiro ^{[11
]}

Geller, David A. ^{[12
]}

Wakabayashi, Go ^{[13
]}

Asbun, Horacio J. ^{[14
]}

Besselink, Marc G. ^{[2
,3
]}

Cherqui, Daniel ^{[15
]}

Cheung, Tan To ^{[16
]}

Clavien, Pierre-Alain ^{[17
]}

Conrad, Claudius ^{[18
]}

D'Hondt, Mathieu ^{[19
]}

Dagher, Ibrahim ^{[20
]}

Dervenis, Christos ^{[21
]}

Devar, John ^{[22
,23
]}

Dixon, Elijah ^{[24
]}

Edwin, Bjorn ^{[25
,26
,27
]}

Efanov, Mikhail ^{[28
]}

Ettore, Giuseppe M. ^{[29
]}

Ferrero, Alessandro ^{[30
]}

Fondevilla, Constantino ^{[31
]}

Fuks, David ^{[32
]}

Giuliante, Felice ^{[33
]}

Han, Ho-Seong ^{[34
]}

Honda, Goro ^{[35
]}

Imventarza, Oscar ^{[36
,37
]}

Kooby, David A. ^{[38
]}

Lodge, Peter ^{[39
]}

Lopez-Ben, Santiago ^{[40
]}

Machado, Marcel A. ^{[41
]}

Marques, Hugo P. ^{[42
]}

O'Rourke, Nick ^{[43
]}

Pekolj, Juan ^{[44
]}

Pinna, Antonio D. ^{[45
]}

Portolani, Nazario ^{[46
]}

Primrose, John ^{[4
]}

Rotellar, Fernando ^{[47
]}

Ruzzenente, Andrea ^{[48
]}

Schadde, Erik ^{[49
,50
,51
]}

Siriwardena, Ajith K. ^{[52
]}

Smadi, Sameer ^{[53
]}

Soubrane, Olivier ^{[54
]}

Tanabe, Kenneth K. ^{[55
]}

Teh, Catherine S. C. ^{[56
]}

Torzilli, Guido ^{[57
]}

Van Gulik, Thomas M. ^{[2
,3
]}

机构：

[1] Poliambulanza Fdn Hosp, Dept Surg, Brescia, Italy

[2] Univ Amsterdam, AmsterdamUMC, Dept Surg, Amsterdam, Netherlands

[3] Canc Ctr Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands

[4] Univ Hosp Southampton NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Surg, Southampton, England

[5] Polytech Univ Marche, Riuniti Hosp, Dept Expt & Clin Med, Hepatobiliary & Abdominal Transplantat Surg, Ancona, Italy

[6] Ohio State Univ, Wexner Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Div Surg Oncol, Columbus, OH USA

[7] James Comprehens Canc Ctr, Columbus, OH USA

[8] IRCCS San Raffaele Hosp, Hepatobiliary Surg Div, Milan, Italy

[9] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Surg, San Francisco, CA USA

[10] Padova Univ Hosp, Dept Surg Oncol & Gastroenterol, Hepatobiliary Surg & Liver Transplantat Unit, Padua, Italy

[11] Natl Ctr Global Hlth & Med, Dept Surg, Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg Div, Tokyo, Japan

[12] Univ Pittsburgh, Dept Surg, Med Ctr, Pittsburgh, PA USA

[13] Ageo Cent Gen Hosp, Ctr Adv Treatment Hepatobiliary & Pancreat Dis, Saitama, Japan

[14] Miami Canc Inst, Hepatobiliary & Pancreas Surg, Miami, FL USA

[15] Paul Brousse Univ Hosp, Dept Hepatobiliary Surg, Villejuif, France

[16] Univ Hong Kong, Dept Surg, Hong Kong, Peoples R China

[17] Univ Hosp Zurich, Dept Surg & Transplantat, Zurich, Switzerland

[18] Tufts Univ, Sch Med, St Elizabeths Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Boston, MA USA

[19] Groeninge Hosp, Dept Digest & Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg, Kortrijk, Belgium

[20] Antoine Beclere Hosp, Dept Minimally Invas Digest Surg, Clamart, France

[21] Konstantopouleio Gen Hosp, Dept Surg, Athens, Greece

[22] Univ Witwatersrand, Fac Hlth Sci, Sch Clin Med, Dept Surg, Johannesburg, South Africa

[23] Chris Hani Baragwanath Acad Hosp, Dept Gen Surg, Hepatopancreat Biliary Unit, Johannesburg, South Africa

[24] Univ Calgary, Dept Surg, Calgary, AB, Canada

[25] Oslo Univ Hosp Oslo, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Oslo, Norway

[26] Oslo Univ Hosp Oslo, Intervent Ctr, Oslo, Norway

[27] Univ Oslo, Med Fac, Inst Clin Med, Oslo, Norway

[28] Moscow Clin Res Ctr, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Moscow, Russia

[29] San Camillo Hosp, Gen Surg & Transplantat Unit, Rome, Italy

[30] Umberto I Mauriziano Hosp, Dept Gen & Oncol Surg, Turin, Italy

[31] Hosp Univ La Paz, IdiPAZ, Gen & Digest Surg, Madrid, Spain

[32] Univ Paris 05, Inst Mutualiste Montsouris, Dept Digest Oncol & Metab Surg, Paris, France

[33] Univ Cattolica Sacro Cuore, IRCCS, Chirurg Epatobiliare, Rome, Italy

[34] Seoul Natl Univ, Bundang Hosp, Coll Med, Dept Surg, Seongnam Si, Gyeonggi Do, South Korea

[35] Tokyo Womens Med Univ, Inst Gastroenterol, Dept Surg, Tokyo, Japan

[36] Hosp Argerich, Dept Surg, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[37] Hosp Garrahan, Dept Surg, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[38] Emory Univ, Sch Med, Winship Canc Inst, Dept Surg, Atlanta, GA USA

[39] St James Univ Hosp, HPB & Transplant Unit, Leeds, England

[40] Hosp Univ Girona Dr Josep Trueta, Dept Gen & Digest Surg, HPB Unit, Girona, Spain

[41] Univ Sao Paulo, Dept Surg, Sao Paulo, Brazil

[42] Curry Cabral Hosp, Dept Surg, Lisbon, Portugal

[43] Royal Brisbane & Womens Hosp, Dept HPB Surg, Brisbane, Qld, Australia

[44] Hosp Italiano Buenos Aires, Dept Gen Surg, Div HPB Surg & Liver Transplant Unit, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[45] Cleveland Clin Florida, Abdominal Transplant & HPB Ctr, Weston, FL USA

[46] Univ Brescia, Dept Clin & Expt Sci, Surg Clin, Brescia, Italy

[47] Clin Univ Navarra, Dept Gen & Digest Surg, Pamplona, Spain

[48] Univ Verona, Dept Surg, Verona, Italy

[49] Univ Zurich, Inst Physiol, Zurich, Switzerland

[50] Cantonal Hosp Winterthur, Dept Surg, Zurich, Switzerland

来源：

ANNALS OF SURGERY | 2023年 / 277卷 / 05期

关键词：

composite measure; laparoscopic liver surgery; liver surgery; minimally invasive liver surgery; patient outcome; quality of care; robotic liver surgery; textbook outcome; COMPOSITE MEASURES; QUALITY; MORTALITY; RESECTION; METASTASES; CARE; COMPLICATIONS; 30-DAY;

D O I：

10.1097/SLA.0000000000005668

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

摘要：

Objective: To reach global expert consensus on the definition of TOLS in minimally invasive and open liver resection among renowned international expert liver surgeons using a modified Delphi method. Background: Textbook outcome is a novel composite measure combining the most desirable postoperative outcomes into one single measure and representing the ideal postoperative course. Despite a recently developed international definition of Textbook Outcome in Liver Surgery (TOLS), a standardized and expert consensus-based definition is lacking. Methods: This international, consensus-based, qualitative study used a Delphi process to achieve consensus on the definition of TOLS. The survey comprised 6 surgical domains with a total of 26 questions on individual surgical outcome variables. The process included 4 rounds of online questionnaires. Consensus was achieved when a threshold of at least 80% agreement was reached. The results from the Delphi rounds were used to establish an international definition of TOLS. Results: In total, 44 expert liver surgeons from 22 countries and all 3 major international hepato-pancreato-biliary associations completed round 1. Forty-two (96%), 41 (98%), and 41 (98%) of the experts participated in round 2, 3, and 4, respectively. The TOLS definition derived from the consensus process included the absence of intraoperative grade = 2 incidents, postoperative bile leakage grade B/C, postoperative liver failure grade B/C, 90-day major postoperative complications, 90-day readmission due to surgery-related major complications, 90-day/in-hospital mortality, and the presence of R0 resection margin. Conclusions: This is the first study providing an international expert consensus-based definition of TOLS for minimally invasive and open liver resections by the use of a formal Delphi consensus approach. TOLS may be useful in assessing patient-level hospital performance and carrying out international comparisons between centers with different clinical practices to further improve patient outcomes.

引用

页码：821 / 828

页数：8

共 49 条

[41] Recommendations for radioembolisation after liver surgery using yttrium-90 resin microspheres based on a survey of an international expert panel
Samim, Morsal
van Veenendaal, Linde M.
Braat, Manon N. G. J. A.
van den Hoven, Andor F.
Van Hillegersberg, Richard
Sangro, Bruno
Kao, Yung Hsiang
Liu, Dave
Louie, John D.
Sze, Daniel Y.
Rose, Steven C.
Brown, Daniel B.
Ahmadzadehfar, Hojjat
Kim, Edward
van den Bosch, Maurice A. A. J.
Lam, Marnix G. E. H.
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2017, 27 (12) : 4923 - 4930
[42] Timing of referral to evaluate for epilepsy surgery: Expert Consensus Recommendations from the Surgical Therapies Commission of the International League Against Epilepsy
Jehi, Lara
Jette, Nathalie
Kwon, Churl-Su
Josephson, Colin B.
Burneo, Jorge G.
Cendes, Fernando
Sperling, Michael R.
Baxendale, Sallie
Busch, Robyn M.
Triki, Chahnez Charfi
Cross, J. Helen
Ekstein, Dana
Englot, Dario J.
Luan, Guoming
Palmini, Andre
Rios, Loreto
Wang, Xiongfei
Roessler, Karl
Rydenhag, Bertil
Ramantani, Georgia
Schuele, Stephan
Wilmshurst, Jo M.
Wilson, Sarah
Wiebe, Samuel
EPILEPSIA, 2022, 63 (10) : 2491 - 2506
[43] Core outcome measures for clinical effectiveness trials of nutritional and metabolic interventions in critical illness: an international modified Delphi consensus study evaluation (CONCISE)
Davies, T. W.
van Gassel, R. J. J.
van de Poll, M.
Gunst, J.
Casaer, M. P.
Christopher, K. B.
Preiser, J. C.
Hill, A.
Gundogan, K.
Reintam-Blaser, A.
Rousseau, A. F.
Hodgson, C.
Needham, D. M.
Castro, M.
Schaller, S.
McClelland, T.
Pilkington, J. J.
Sevin, C. M.
Wischmeyer, P. E.
Lee, Z. Y.
Govil, D.
Li, A.
Chapple, L.
Denehy, L.
Montejo-Gonzalez, J. C.
Taylor, B.
Bear, D. E.
Pearse, R.
McNelly, A.
Prowle, J.
Puthucheary, Z. A.
CRITICAL CARE, 2022, 26 (01)
[44] A snapshot of the 2020 conception of anatomic liver resections and their applicability on minimally invasive liver surgery. A preparatory survey for the Expert Consensus Meeting on Precision Anatomy for Minimally Invasive HBP Surgery
Ciria, Ruben
Berardi, Giammauro
Nishino, Hitoe
Chan, Albert C. Y.
Chanwat, Rawisak
Chen, Kuo-Hsin
Chen, Yajin
Cheung, Tan To
Fuks, David
Geller, David A.
Iwashita, Yukio
Liu, Rong
Lopez-Ben, Santiago
Yamamoto, Masakazu
Wakabayashi, Go
JOURNAL OF HEPATO-BILIARY-PANCREATIC SCIENCES, 2022, 29 (01) : 41 - 50
[45] Defining an International Standard Set of Outcome Measures for Patients With Hip or Knee Osteoarthritis: Consensus of the International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measurement Hip and Knee Osteoarthritis Working Group
Rolfson, Ola
Wissig, Stephanie
van Maasakkers, Lisa
Stowell, Caleb
Ackerman, Ilana
Ayers, David
Barber, Thomas
Benzakour, Thami
Bozic, Kevin
Budhiparama, Nicolaas
Caillouette, James
Conaghan, Philip G.
Dahlberg, Leif
Dunn, Jennifer
Grady-Benson, John
Ibrahim, Said A.
Lewis, Sally
Malchau, Henrik
Manzary, Mojieb
March, Lyn
Nassif, Nader
Nelissen, Rob
Smith, Noel
Franklin, Patricia D.
ARTHRITIS CARE & RESEARCH, 2016, 68 (11) : 1631 - 1639
[46] Delphi-Based Consensus to Determine Core Aspects of Post-Hip-Fracture Surgery Rehabilitation Based on the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health
Lin, Che-Li
Liao, Chun-De
Lee, Yu-Hao
Escorpizo, Reuben
Liou, Tsan-Hon
Huang, Shih-Wei
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH, 2022, 19 (23)
[47] Experts vs. machine - comparison of machine learning to expert-informed prediction of outcome after major liver surgery
Staiger, Roxane D.
Mehra, Tarun
Haile, Sarah R.
Domenghino, Anja
Kuemmerli, Christoph
Abbassi, Fariba
Kozbur, Damian
Dutkowski, Philipp
Puhan, Milo A.
Clavien, Pierre -Alain
HPB, 2024, 26 (05) : 674 - 681
[48] PRINciples of optimal antithrombotiC therapy and coagulation managEment during elective fenestrated and branched EndovaScular aortic repairS (PRINCE2SS): An International Expert Based Delphi Consensus Study
D'Oria, Mario
Bertoglio, Luca
Bignamini, Angelo Antonio
Mani, Kevin
Koelbel, Tilo
Oderich, Gustavo
Chiesa, Roberto
Lepidi, Sandro
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF VASCULAR AND ENDOVASCULAR SURGERY, 2022, 63 (06) : 838 - 850
[49] Expert Consensus Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Donor Hepatectomy for Living Donor Liver Transplantation From Innovation to Implementation A Joint Initiative From the International Laparoscopic Liver Society (ILLS) and the Asian-Pacific Hepato-Pancreato-Biliary Association (A-PHPBA)
Cherqui, Daniel
Ciria, Ruben
Kwon, Choon Hyuck David
Kim, Ki-Hun
Broering, Dieter
Wakabayashi, Go
Samstein, Benjamin
Troisi, Roberto I.
Han, Ho Seong
Rotellar, Fernando
Soubrane, Olivier
Briceno, Javier
Alconchel, Felipe
Ayllon, Maria Dolores
Berardi, Giammauro
Cauchy, Francois
Luque, Irene Gomez
Hong, Suk Kyun
Yoon, Young-Yin
Egawa, Hiroto
Lerut, Jan
Lo, Chung-Mau
Rela, Mohamed
Sapisochin, Gonzalo
Suh, Kyung-Suk
ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2021, 273 (01) : 96 - 108

← 1 2 3 4 5 →