An International Expert Delphi Consensus on Defining Textbook Outcome in Liver Surgery (TOLS)

被引：37

作者：

Gorgec, Burak ^{[1
,2
,3
,4
]}

Cacciaguerra, Andrea Benedetti ^{[1
,4
,5
]}

Pawlik, Timothy M. ^{[6
,7
]}

Aldrighetti, Luca A. ^{[8
]}

Alseidi, Adnan A. ^{[9
]}

Cillo, Umberto ^{[10
]}

Kokudo, Norihiro ^{[11
]}

Geller, David A. ^{[12
]}

Wakabayashi, Go ^{[13
]}

Asbun, Horacio J. ^{[14
]}

Besselink, Marc G. ^{[2
,3
]}

Cherqui, Daniel ^{[15
]}

Cheung, Tan To ^{[16
]}

Clavien, Pierre-Alain ^{[17
]}

Conrad, Claudius ^{[18
]}

D'Hondt, Mathieu ^{[19
]}

Dagher, Ibrahim ^{[20
]}

Dervenis, Christos ^{[21
]}

Devar, John ^{[22
,23
]}

Dixon, Elijah ^{[24
]}

Edwin, Bjorn ^{[25
,26
,27
]}

Efanov, Mikhail ^{[28
]}

Ettore, Giuseppe M. ^{[29
]}

Ferrero, Alessandro ^{[30
]}

Fondevilla, Constantino ^{[31
]}

Fuks, David ^{[32
]}

Giuliante, Felice ^{[33
]}

Han, Ho-Seong ^{[34
]}

Honda, Goro ^{[35
]}

Imventarza, Oscar ^{[36
,37
]}

Kooby, David A. ^{[38
]}

Lodge, Peter ^{[39
]}

Lopez-Ben, Santiago ^{[40
]}

Machado, Marcel A. ^{[41
]}

Marques, Hugo P. ^{[42
]}

O'Rourke, Nick ^{[43
]}

Pekolj, Juan ^{[44
]}

Pinna, Antonio D. ^{[45
]}

Portolani, Nazario ^{[46
]}

Primrose, John ^{[4
]}

Rotellar, Fernando ^{[47
]}

Ruzzenente, Andrea ^{[48
]}

Schadde, Erik ^{[49
,50
,51
]}

Siriwardena, Ajith K. ^{[52
]}

Smadi, Sameer ^{[53
]}

Soubrane, Olivier ^{[54
]}

Tanabe, Kenneth K. ^{[55
]}

Teh, Catherine S. C. ^{[56
]}

Torzilli, Guido ^{[57
]}

Van Gulik, Thomas M. ^{[2
,3
]}

机构：

[1] Poliambulanza Fdn Hosp, Dept Surg, Brescia, Italy

[2] Univ Amsterdam, AmsterdamUMC, Dept Surg, Amsterdam, Netherlands

[3] Canc Ctr Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands

[4] Univ Hosp Southampton NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Surg, Southampton, England

[5] Polytech Univ Marche, Riuniti Hosp, Dept Expt & Clin Med, Hepatobiliary & Abdominal Transplantat Surg, Ancona, Italy

[6] Ohio State Univ, Wexner Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Div Surg Oncol, Columbus, OH USA

[7] James Comprehens Canc Ctr, Columbus, OH USA

[8] IRCCS San Raffaele Hosp, Hepatobiliary Surg Div, Milan, Italy

[9] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Surg, San Francisco, CA USA

[10] Padova Univ Hosp, Dept Surg Oncol & Gastroenterol, Hepatobiliary Surg & Liver Transplantat Unit, Padua, Italy

[11] Natl Ctr Global Hlth & Med, Dept Surg, Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg Div, Tokyo, Japan

[12] Univ Pittsburgh, Dept Surg, Med Ctr, Pittsburgh, PA USA

[13] Ageo Cent Gen Hosp, Ctr Adv Treatment Hepatobiliary & Pancreat Dis, Saitama, Japan

[14] Miami Canc Inst, Hepatobiliary & Pancreas Surg, Miami, FL USA

[15] Paul Brousse Univ Hosp, Dept Hepatobiliary Surg, Villejuif, France

[16] Univ Hong Kong, Dept Surg, Hong Kong, Peoples R China

[17] Univ Hosp Zurich, Dept Surg & Transplantat, Zurich, Switzerland

[18] Tufts Univ, Sch Med, St Elizabeths Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Boston, MA USA

[19] Groeninge Hosp, Dept Digest & Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg, Kortrijk, Belgium

[20] Antoine Beclere Hosp, Dept Minimally Invas Digest Surg, Clamart, France

[21] Konstantopouleio Gen Hosp, Dept Surg, Athens, Greece

[22] Univ Witwatersrand, Fac Hlth Sci, Sch Clin Med, Dept Surg, Johannesburg, South Africa

[23] Chris Hani Baragwanath Acad Hosp, Dept Gen Surg, Hepatopancreat Biliary Unit, Johannesburg, South Africa

[24] Univ Calgary, Dept Surg, Calgary, AB, Canada

[25] Oslo Univ Hosp Oslo, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Oslo, Norway

[26] Oslo Univ Hosp Oslo, Intervent Ctr, Oslo, Norway

[27] Univ Oslo, Med Fac, Inst Clin Med, Oslo, Norway

[28] Moscow Clin Res Ctr, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Moscow, Russia

[29] San Camillo Hosp, Gen Surg & Transplantat Unit, Rome, Italy

[30] Umberto I Mauriziano Hosp, Dept Gen & Oncol Surg, Turin, Italy

[31] Hosp Univ La Paz, IdiPAZ, Gen & Digest Surg, Madrid, Spain

[32] Univ Paris 05, Inst Mutualiste Montsouris, Dept Digest Oncol & Metab Surg, Paris, France

[33] Univ Cattolica Sacro Cuore, IRCCS, Chirurg Epatobiliare, Rome, Italy

[34] Seoul Natl Univ, Bundang Hosp, Coll Med, Dept Surg, Seongnam Si, Gyeonggi Do, South Korea

[35] Tokyo Womens Med Univ, Inst Gastroenterol, Dept Surg, Tokyo, Japan

[36] Hosp Argerich, Dept Surg, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[37] Hosp Garrahan, Dept Surg, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[38] Emory Univ, Sch Med, Winship Canc Inst, Dept Surg, Atlanta, GA USA

[39] St James Univ Hosp, HPB & Transplant Unit, Leeds, England

[40] Hosp Univ Girona Dr Josep Trueta, Dept Gen & Digest Surg, HPB Unit, Girona, Spain

[41] Univ Sao Paulo, Dept Surg, Sao Paulo, Brazil

[42] Curry Cabral Hosp, Dept Surg, Lisbon, Portugal

[43] Royal Brisbane & Womens Hosp, Dept HPB Surg, Brisbane, Qld, Australia

[44] Hosp Italiano Buenos Aires, Dept Gen Surg, Div HPB Surg & Liver Transplant Unit, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[45] Cleveland Clin Florida, Abdominal Transplant & HPB Ctr, Weston, FL USA

[46] Univ Brescia, Dept Clin & Expt Sci, Surg Clin, Brescia, Italy

[47] Clin Univ Navarra, Dept Gen & Digest Surg, Pamplona, Spain

[48] Univ Verona, Dept Surg, Verona, Italy

[49] Univ Zurich, Inst Physiol, Zurich, Switzerland

[50] Cantonal Hosp Winterthur, Dept Surg, Zurich, Switzerland

来源：

ANNALS OF SURGERY | 2023年 / 277卷 / 05期

关键词：

composite measure; laparoscopic liver surgery; liver surgery; minimally invasive liver surgery; patient outcome; quality of care; robotic liver surgery; textbook outcome; COMPOSITE MEASURES; QUALITY; MORTALITY; RESECTION; METASTASES; CARE; COMPLICATIONS; 30-DAY;

D O I：

10.1097/SLA.0000000000005668

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

摘要：

Objective: To reach global expert consensus on the definition of TOLS in minimally invasive and open liver resection among renowned international expert liver surgeons using a modified Delphi method. Background: Textbook outcome is a novel composite measure combining the most desirable postoperative outcomes into one single measure and representing the ideal postoperative course. Despite a recently developed international definition of Textbook Outcome in Liver Surgery (TOLS), a standardized and expert consensus-based definition is lacking. Methods: This international, consensus-based, qualitative study used a Delphi process to achieve consensus on the definition of TOLS. The survey comprised 6 surgical domains with a total of 26 questions on individual surgical outcome variables. The process included 4 rounds of online questionnaires. Consensus was achieved when a threshold of at least 80% agreement was reached. The results from the Delphi rounds were used to establish an international definition of TOLS. Results: In total, 44 expert liver surgeons from 22 countries and all 3 major international hepato-pancreato-biliary associations completed round 1. Forty-two (96%), 41 (98%), and 41 (98%) of the experts participated in round 2, 3, and 4, respectively. The TOLS definition derived from the consensus process included the absence of intraoperative grade = 2 incidents, postoperative bile leakage grade B/C, postoperative liver failure grade B/C, 90-day major postoperative complications, 90-day readmission due to surgery-related major complications, 90-day/in-hospital mortality, and the presence of R0 resection margin. Conclusions: This is the first study providing an international expert consensus-based definition of TOLS for minimally invasive and open liver resections by the use of a formal Delphi consensus approach. TOLS may be useful in assessing patient-level hospital performance and carrying out international comparisons between centers with different clinical practices to further improve patient outcomes.

引用

页码：821 / 828

页数：8

共 49 条

[1] Defining Textbook Outcome in liver surgery and assessment of hospital variation: A nationwide population-based study
de Graaff, Michelle R.
Elfrink, Arthur K. E.
Buis, Carlijn, I
Swijnenburg, Rutger-Jan
Erdmann, Joris, I
Kazemier, Geert
Verhoef, Cornelis
Mieog, J. Sven D.
Derksen, Wouter J. M.
van den Boezem, Peter B.
Ayez, Ninos
Liem, Mike S. L.
Leclercq, Wouter K. G.
Kuhlmann, Koert F. D.
Marsman, Hendrik A.
van Duijvendijk, Peter
Kok, Niels F. M.
Klaase, Joost M.
Dejong, Cornelis H. C.
Grunhagen, Dirk J.
den Dulk, Marcel
EJSO, 2022, 48 (12): : 2414 - 2423
[2] Assessment of Textbook Outcome in Laparoscopic and Open Liver Surgery
Gorgec, Burak
Benedetti Cacciaguerra, Andrea
Lanari, Jacopo
Russolillo, Nadia
Cipriani, Federica
Aghayan, Davit
Zimmitti, Giuseppe
Efanov, Mikhail
Alseidi, Adnan
Mocchegiani, Federico
Giuliante, Felice
Ruzzenente, Andrea
Rotellar, Fernando
Fuks, David
D'Hondt, Mathieu
Vivarelli, Marco
Edwin, Bjorn
Aldrighetti, Luca A.
Ferrero, Alessandro
Cillo, Umberto
Besselink, Marc G.
Abu Hilal, Mohammed
JAMA SURGERY, 2021, 156 (08)
[3] Defining a textbook outcome for the resection of colorectal liver metastases
Neary, Colm
O'Brien, Lukas
McCormack, Emilie
Kelly, Michael
Bolger, Jarlath
McEntee, Gerard
Conneely, John
JOURNAL OF SURGICAL ONCOLOGY, 2023, 127 (04) : 616 - 624
[4] Defining textbook outcome for selective internal radiation therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma: an international expert study
Gregory, Jules
Tselikas, Lambros
Allimant, Caroline
de Baere, Thierry
Bargellini, Irene
Bell, Jon
Bilbao, Jose Ignacio
Bouvier, Antoine
Chapiro, Julius
Chiesa, Carlo
Decaens, Thomas
Denys, Alban
Duran, Rafael
Edeline, Julien
Garin, Etienne
Ghelfi, Julien
Helmberger, Thomas
Irani, Farah
Lam, Marnix
Lewandowski, Robert
Liu, David
Loffroy, Romaric
Madoff, David C.
Mastier, Charles
Salem, Riad
Sangro, Bruno
Sze, Daniel
Vilgrain, Valerie
Vouche, Michael
Guiu, Boris
Ronot, Maxime
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE AND MOLECULAR IMAGING, 2023, 50 (03) : 921 - 928
[5] International Expert Consensus on Defining Textbook Oncologic Outcomes in Cytoreductive Surgery and Hyperthermic Intraperitoneal Chemotherapy for Colorectal Peritoneal Metastasis
Zohar, Nitzan
Nevler, Avinoam
Esquivel, Jesus
Yeo, Charles J.
Benvenisti, Haggai
Elbaz, Nadav
Assaf, Dan
Mor, Eyal
Bowne, Wilbur B.
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SURGEONS, 2024, 238 (04) : 387 - 401
[6] Textbook outcome for esophageal cancer surgery: an international consensus-based update of a quality measure
Kalff, Marianne C.
Henegouwen, Mark I. van Berge
Gisbertz, Suzanne S.
DISEASES OF THE ESOPHAGUS, 2021, 34 (07)
[7] Defining textbook outcome for selective internal radiation therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma: an international expert study
Jules Gregory
Lambros Tselikas
Caroline Allimant
Thierry de Baere
Irene Bargellini
Jon Bell
José Ignacio Bilbao
Antoine Bouvier
Julius Chapiro
Carlo Chiesa
Thomas Decaens
Alban Denys
Rafael Duran
Julien Edeline
Etienne Garin
Julien Ghelfi
Thomas Helmberger
Farah Irani
Marnix Lam
Robert Lewandowski
David Liu
Romaric Loffroy
David C. Madoff
Charles Mastier
Riad Salem
Bruno Sangro
Daniel Sze
Valérie Vilgrain
Michael Vouche
Boris Guiu
Maxime Ronot
European Journal of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, 2023, 50 : 921 - 928
[8] Textbook outcome in oncological gastric surgery: a systematic review and call for an international consensus
Silvia Carbonell-Morote
Han-Kwang Yang
Javier Lacueva
Juan Jesús Rubio-García
Lucia Alacan-Friedrich
Lea Fierley
Celia Villodre
Jose M. Ramia
World Journal of Surgical Oncology, 21
[9] Textbook outcome in oncological gastric surgery: a systematic review and call for an international consensus
Carbonell-Morote, Silvia
Yang, Han-Kwang
Lacueva, Javier
Rubio-Garcia, Juan Jesus
Alacan-Friedrich, Lucia
Fierley, Lea
Villodre, Celia
Ramia, Jose M.
WORLD JOURNAL OF SURGICAL ONCOLOGY, 2023, 21 (01)
[10] How to Establish Benchmarks for Surgical Outcomes? A Checklist Based on an International Expert Delphi Consensus
Gero, Daniel
Muller, Xavier
Staiger, Roxane D.
Gutschow, Christian A.
Vonlanthen, Rene
Bueter, Marco
Clavien, Pierre-Alain
Puhan, Milo A.
ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2022, 275 (01) : 115 - 120

← 1 2 3 4 5 →