How to Know That You're Not a Zombie

被引:0
|
作者
Ramm, Brentyn J. [1 ]
机构
[1] Witten Herdecke Univ, Dept Psychol & Psychotherapy, Alfred Herrhausen Str 50, D-58448 Witten, Germany
关键词
SELF-AWARENESS; CONSCIOUSNESS; TRANSPARENCY; REPRESENTATIONALISM; ILLUSIONISM;
D O I
10.1007/s10670-023-00769-1
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
I am aware of the tree and its leaves, but am I aware of my awareness of these things? When I try to introspect my awareness, I just find myself attending to objects and their properties. This observation is known as the 'transparency of experience'. On the other hand, I seem to directly know that I am aware. Given the first observation, it is not clear how I know that I am aware. Fred Dretske thought that the problem was so acute that he issued the challenge of answering 'How do you know that you are not a zombie?' I propose that a view found in the Advaita Vedanta, that awareness is self-luminous, reconciles these two observations. I understand self-luminosity as the thesis that: (1) I am implicitly aware of my awareness and (2) I am phenomenally aware of a distinct phenomenal character of my awareness. In support of the first claim, that I apparently only attend to objects in the world when introspecting perceptual experience, suggests that I do not know my awareness explicitly, but rather that I must know it implicitly. In support of the second claim, I argue that the mere fact that I am perceptually conscious is not sufficient to allow me to know that I am perceptually conscious. In particular, the qualities I am perceptually aware of do not tell me that I aware of them, rather they just seem to be properties of objects. I also assess whether strategies for responding to Cartesian sceptical scenarios can be employed against Dretske's consciousness scepticism. I argue that these strategies either fail to distinguish me from a zombie or they do not adequately describe my epistemic situation. By contrast to other accounts, if awareness has its own distinct phenomenal character, then it cannot be considered to be a prima facie property of the world, hence the self-luminosity of awareness provides a plausible account of how I know that I'm not a zombie.
引用
收藏
页码:1561 / 1582
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Awareness of the saccade goal in oculomotor selection: Your eyes go before you know
    van Zoest, Wieske
    Donk, Mieke
    CONSCIOUSNESS AND COGNITION, 2010, 19 (04) : 861 - 871
  • [22] The eyes know what you are thinking: Eye movements as an objective measure of mind wandering
    Uzzaman, Sarah
    Joordens, Steve
    CONSCIOUSNESS AND COGNITION, 2011, 20 (04) : 1882 - 1886
  • [23] The Wandering Mind: What the Brain Does When You're Not Looking
    Broadway, James M.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2017, 130 (03): : 389 - 397
  • [24] Dear Robot, What Do You Know About Me? Enhancing Transparency in Presence of Robots
    Reinke, Sebastian
    2024 IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON PERVASIVE COMPUTING AND COMMUNICATIONS WORKSHOPS AND OTHER AFFILIATED EVENTS, PERCOM WORKSHOPS, 2024, : 362 - 363
  • [25] Tracing You: How transparent surveillance reveals a desire for visibility
    Grosser, Benjamin
    BIG DATA & SOCIETY, 2017, 4 (01):
  • [26] Recovery after moderate to severe TBI and factors influencing functional outcome: What you need to know
    Golden, Katherine
    Borsi, Lydia
    Sterling, Ally
    Giacino, Joseph T.
    JOURNAL OF TRAUMA AND ACUTE CARE SURGERY, 2024, 97 (03): : 343 - 355
  • [27] How do admission committees select? Do applicants know how they select? Selection criteria and transparency at a Dutch University
    Anastasia Kurysheva
    Harold V. M. van Rijen
    Gönül Dilaver
    Tertiary Education and Management, 2019, 25 : 367 - 388
  • [28] How do admission committees select? Do applicants know how they select? Selection criteria and transparency at a Dutch University
    Kurysheva, Anastasia
    van Rijen, Harold V. M.
    Dilaver, Gonul
    TERTIARY EDUCATION AND MANAGEMENT, 2019, 25 (04) : 367 - 388
  • [29] Tell Me What You Know: GDPR Implications on Designing Transparency and Accountability for News Recommender Systems
    Krebs, Luciana Monteiro
    Rodriguez, Oscar Luis Alvarado
    Dewitte, Pierre
    Ausloos, Jef
    Geerts, David
    Naudts, Laurens
    Verbert, Katrien
    CHI EA '19 EXTENDED ABSTRACTS: EXTENDED ABSTRACTS OF THE 2019 CHI CONFERENCE ON HUMAN FACTORS IN COMPUTING SYSTEMS, 2019,
  • [30] Does feeling what you eat change how you eat? Implications of an intervention to promote consciousness of eating experiences
    Palazzo, Carina Carlucci
    Leghi, Barbara Esteves
    Diez-Garcia, Rosa Wanda
    FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2024, 14