Redistribution of fishery benefits among commercial and recreational fishers caused by offsetting

被引:3
作者
Ma, Deqiang [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Rhodes, Jonathan [1 ]
Klein, Carissa J. [1 ]
Maron, Martine [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Queensland, Ctr Biodivers & Conservat Sci, Sch Environm, Brisbane, Qld 4072, Australia
[2] Univ Queensland, Sch Environm, Brisbane 4072, Australia
[3] Univ Michigan, Inst Global Change Biol, Sch Environm & Sustainabil, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
关键词
Biodiversity offsets; Redistribution of ecosystem services; Commercial fishery; Recreational fishery; Fishery resources; Marine habitats; MARINE PROTECTED AREAS; NO NET LOSS; ECOSYSTEM SERVICES; SOCIAL EQUITY; GINI COEFFICIENT; MITIGATION; INCLUSION;
D O I
10.1016/j.marpol.2023.105881
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Biodiversity offsetting is widely used to offset negative impacts of development on biodiversity. However, offsets can affect the distribution of benefits among beneficiaries, due to the redistribution of ecosystem services caused by impacts and offsets. Here, we compared the distribution of fishery economic benefits and losses to commercial and recreational fishers under two different offset policy rules: offset locations in close proximity to impact sites, and spatially unrestricted offsetting. With a focus on mangrove and seagrass ecosystems in Queensland, Australia, we measured how the distribution of net outcomes would change using the Gini coefficient. Different offset policy rules had similar effects on the redistribution of fishery benefits among commercial and recreational fishers. However, both offset policy rules failed to fully compensate for losses of fishery benefits for most affected beneficiaries. Locating offsets in close proximity to impact sites achieved slightly more evenly-distributed benefits among recreational fishers and among most types of commercial fishers. The findings suggest that in this system, even though the distribution of net outcomes of impact-offset projects for fishers are somewhat evenly distributed, they tend to be uniformly negative for both recreational and commercial fishers.
引用
收藏
页数:11
相关论文
共 58 条
[31]   Equity trade-offs in conservation decision making [J].
Law, Elizabeth A. ;
Bennett, Nathan J. ;
Ives, Christopher D. ;
Friedman, Rachel ;
Davis, Katrina J. ;
Archibald, Carla ;
Wilson, Kerrie A. .
CONSERVATION BIOLOGY, 2018, 32 (02) :294-303
[32]   Ecological role and services of tropical mangrove ecosystems: a reassessment [J].
Lee, Shing Yip ;
Primavera, Jurgene H. ;
Dahdouh-Guebas, Farid ;
McKee, Karen ;
Bosire, Jared O. ;
Cannicci, Stefano ;
Diele, Karen ;
Fromard, Francois ;
Koedam, Nico ;
Marchand, Cyril ;
Mendelssohn, Irving ;
Mukherjee, Nibedita ;
Record, Sydne .
GLOBAL ECOLOGY AND BIOGEOGRAPHY, 2014, 23 (07) :726-743
[33]   Should We Be Wary of Mitigation Banking? Evidence Regarding the Risks Associated with this Wetland Offset Arrangement in Florida [J].
Levrel, Harold ;
Scemama, Pierre ;
Vaissiere, Anne -Charlotte .
ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS, 2017, 135 :136-149
[34]   Drivers and Socioeconomic Impacts of Tourism Participation in Protected Areas [J].
Liu, Wei ;
Vogt, Christine A. ;
Luo, Junyan ;
He, Guangming ;
Frank, Kenneth A. ;
Liu, Jianguo .
PLOS ONE, 2012, 7 (04)
[35]   The consequences of coastal offsets for fisheries [J].
Ma, Deqiang ;
Rhodes, Jonathan R. ;
Maron, Martine .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY, 2022, 59 (04) :1157-1167
[36]   Who loses? Tracking ecosystem service redistribution from road development and mitigation in the Peruvian Amazon [J].
Mandle, Lisa ;
Tallis, Heather ;
Sotomayor, Leonardo ;
Vogl, Adrian L. .
FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT, 2015, 13 (06) :309-315
[37]   Taming a Wicked Problem: Resolving Controversies in Biodiversity Offsetting [J].
Maron, Martine ;
Ives, Christopher D. ;
Kujala, Heini ;
Bull, Joseph W. ;
Maseyk, Fleur J. F. ;
Bekessy, Sarah ;
Gordon, Ascelin ;
Watson, James E. M. ;
Lentini, Pia E. ;
Gibbons, Philip ;
Possingham, Hugh P. ;
Hobbs, Richard J. ;
Keith, David A. ;
Wintle, Brendan A. ;
Evans, Megan C. .
BIOSCIENCE, 2016, 66 (06) :489-498
[38]   Policy Development for Biodiversity Offsets: A Review of Offset Frameworks [J].
McKenney, Bruce A. ;
Kiesecker, Joseph M. .
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2010, 45 (01) :165-176
[39]   Reframing landscape fragmentation's effects on ecosystem services [J].
Mitchell, Matthew G. E. ;
Suarez-Castro, Andres F. ;
Martinez-Harms, Maria ;
Maron, Martine ;
McAlpine, Clive ;
Gaston, Kevin J. ;
Johansen, Kasper ;
Rhodes, Jonathan R. .
TRENDS IN ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION, 2015, 30 (04) :190-198
[40]   Realising a vision of no net loss through marine biodiversity offsetting in Australia [J].
Niner, Holly J. ;
Milligan, Ben ;
Jones, Peter J. S. ;
Styan, Craig A. .
OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT, 2017, 148 :22-30