Functional diversity and identity influence the self-thinning process in young forest communities

There is increasing evidence that the strength of tree diversity effects on productivity varies considerably over the course of forest development. Evidence points to canopy closure and the subsequent self-thinning as key phases of forest development during which positive diversity effects emerge. A number of studies have shown that self-thinning can differ among species, and also in mixtures compared with monocultures. Yet, how diversity influences the process of canopy closure and self-thinning remains poorly understood. In this study, using 11 years of growth and mortality records from a large diversity experiment, we fitted self-thinning trajectories for 37 tree communities with equal initial densities and explored whether and how functional diversity and identity may affect these trajectories. We then examined whether the diversity effects on self-thinning were influenced by differences in growth or in mortality. We found that tree communities' functional diversity and identity strongly influence the self-thinning process. First, we observed that tree communities dominated by early successional species, and slow-growing evergreens begin self-thinning at a larger mean tree size. Second, we found that mixing species with contrasting resource-use strategies, and the dominance of deciduous, fast-growing species, reduce tree mortality rate in relation to mean tree size during self-thinning (i.e. shallower self-thinning slope). The lower rates of self-thinning in these functionally diverse communities seem to be explained by both an increase in tree growth and a reduction in density-related mortality simultaneously over time. Synthesis. Overall, this study highlights that increasing tree diversity has the potential to enhance forest productivity in the long term through a better performance during the self-thinning process when competition for resources is most intense.