NIETZSCHE CONTRA MANU Ambedkar's Nietzsche Moment and the Politics of Dalit Rage

被引:0
作者
Das, Kalyan Kumar [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
机构
[1] Presidency Univ, English, Kolkata, India
[2] Univ Delhi, Ctr Dalit Studies, Dept English, Delhi, India
[3] Cooch Behar Panchanan Barma Univ, Dept English, Cooch Behar, W Bengal, India
[4] Univ Calcutta, Dept Comparat Indian Language & Literature, Kolkata, W Bengal, India
关键词
rage; ressentiment; Dalit; Nietzsche; Ambedkar;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
C95 [民族学、文化人类学];
学科分类号
0304 ; 030401 ;
摘要
Echoing bell hook ' s by juxtaposing some instances of projections of Dalits as an '' angry,'' '' illiberal,'' and '' intolerant '' constituency with examples of anger from Dalit literature. While these projections in '' mainstream '' media and caste Hindu-dominated civil society narratives often represent them as engulfed in the emotive states marked by anger, intolerance, and impatience, the instances from Dalit literature archive a '' Dalit rage '' that demands to be dissociated from the Nietzschean category of ressentiment. Through B. R. Ambedkar ' s readings of Nietzsche in Philosophy of Hinduism and Nietzsche ' s readings of Manu ' s Manavadharmashastra in Twilight of the Idols, this article draws a fine line of differentiation between Nietzsche ' s contempt for ressentiment and Manu ' s disdain for anger. '' Dalit rage '' occupies a distinctly different thymotic space and articulates a Dalit predicament that exploits rage as a marker of protest, resistance, and caste-ridden social conflicts. This article shows why we cannot bracket Nietzsche ' s contempt for ressentiment with Manu ' s demands of the sudras (and, in extension, other '' lower castes ''/ Dalits) to be '' meek '' by exploring Manu ' s perpetuation and legitimization of the varna order through a '' morality of breeding '' and Nietzsche ' s more wholesale rejection of morality as he deems it a pia fraus (moral fraud). Thus this '' Dalit rage '' offers us a repository of the limits of a liberal democracy and enables an Ambedkarite reading of Nietzsche whose project of constructing ubermensch is markedly different from Manu ' s '' morality of taming '' through a '' morality of breeding.''
引用
收藏
页码:68 / 93
页数:26
相关论文
共 34 条
  • [1] Ambedkar B. R., 2014, B AMBEDKAR WRITINGS, V3, P3
  • [2] Ambedkar B.R., 2014, Annihilation of Caste
  • [3] Anand S., 2013, OUTLOOK 0211
  • [4] [Anonymous], 2013, HINDU BUSINESS LINE
  • [5] [Anonymous], 2015, HATRED BELLY POLITIC, VFirst
  • [6] [Anonymous], 2012, INDIA TODAY
  • [7] Bagchi Suvojit, 2018, HINDU BUSINESS LINE
  • [8] Bagul Baburao, 2009, POISONED BREAD TRANS, P209
  • [9] Bandyopadhyay Sibaji, 2009, PRABANDHA SANGKALAN, P111
  • [10] Bayly ChristopherA., 2011, RECOVERING LIBERTIES