Gatekeeping and factors underlying decisions not to refer to mental health services after self-harm: Triangulating video-recordings of consultations, interviews, medical records and discharge letters

被引:6
作者
Bergen, Clara [1 ,2 ]
Lomas, Matthew [3 ]
Ryan, Mary [4 ]
McCabe, Rose [1 ]
机构
[1] City Univ London, Sch Hlth Sci, Div Hlth Serv Res & Management, 1 Myddelton St, London EC1R 1UB, England
[2] Didi Hirsch Mental Hlth Serv, Hlth & Innovat Div, 4760 Sepulveda Blvd, Culver City, CA 90230 USA
[3] Univ Exeter, Dept Biosci, Stocker Rd, Exeter EX4 4QD, England
[4] London South Bank Univ, Hlth Syst Innovat Lab, 103 Borough Rd, London SE1 0AA, England
来源
SSM-QUALITATIVE RESEARCH IN HEALTH | 2023年 / 4卷
关键词
Suicide prevention; Self-harm; Crisis intervention; Mental health care; Alcohol; Medical sociology; Qualitative methods;
D O I
10.1016/j.ssmqr.2023.100249
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
When a person attends a UK Emergency Department (ED) for self-harm or suicidal ideation, practitioners may refer to mental health services. While some people ask for and receive support, others ask but do not receive support. We explored requests for support followed by decisions not to refer to mental health services. We analyzed and triangulated evidence from 46 video-recorded psychosocial assessments, one-week and threemonth follow-up interviews with patients and carers, medical records, documentation of the referral proces, and ED discharge letters. We present three detailed cases, revealing four factors underlying these decisions: (1) self-control, self-help, social support, and current treatment as valid treatment plans ("Continue to use my coping strategies and deep breathing. But that ain't working."), (2) narrow referral criteria for services, including exclusion of those 'not ill enough' or 'too risky' ("It's about gathering evidence ... She would monitor you over a period of weeks and then refer."), (3) accessing mental health care while using alcohol ("I'm being told that they can't deal with her mental health issues until she's not an alcoholic."), and (4) accessing more than one service ("Common with most therapeutic services, we would not work in tandem with another therapeutic provider."). These factors lead to people in crisis being excluded from additional professional support, with serious adverse outcomes including suicide attempts. Patients are pressured to align with these decisions as reasonable. Practitioners are required to act as gatekeepers, rationing under-resourced mental health services. This significantly undermines early intervention and patient recovery.Content warning: Detailed descriptions of self-harming thoughts and behaviors including suicide, self-inflicted injuries and disordered eating. Discussions of sexual, physical and psychological abuse. Depictions of discriminatory attitudes and actions.
引用
收藏
页数:14
相关论文
共 54 条
  • [21] It Does Take Two to Tango: An Applied Conversation Analysis of Interactions between a Psychiatrist and Service-Users Discussing Medication
    Kaminskiy, Emma
    Finlay, Mick
    [J]. HEALTH COMMUNICATION, 2019, 34 (13) : 1628 - 1636
  • [22] Recommending no further treatment: Gatekeeping work of generalists at a Japanese university hospital
    Kushida, Shuya
    Kawashima, Michie
    Abe, Tetsuya
    [J]. SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2021, 290
  • [23] Eliciting patient preferences in shared decision-making (SDM): Comparing conversation analysis and SDM measurements
    Landmark, Anne Marie Dalby
    Ofstad, Eirik Hugaas
    Svennevig, Jan
    [J]. PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING, 2017, 100 (11) : 2081 - 2087
  • [24] Langan J., 2004, Living with Risk: Mental Health Service User Involvement in Risk Assessment and Management
  • [25] Qualitative study of candidacy and access to secondary mental health services during the COVID-19 pandemic
    Liberati, Elisa
    Richards, Natalie
    Parker, Jennie
    Willars, Janet
    Scott, David
    Boydell, Nicola
    Pinfold, Vanessa
    Martin, Graham
    Jones, Peter B.
    Dixon-Woods, Mary
    [J]. SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2022, 296
  • [26] When patients and clinician (dis)agree about the nature of the problem: The role of displays of shared understanding in acceptance of treatment
    McCabe, Rose
    [J]. SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2021, 290
  • [27] Training to enhance psychiatrist communication with patients with psychosis (TEMPO): cluster randomised controlled trial
    McCabe, Rose
    John, Paula
    Dooley, Jemima
    Healey, Patrick
    Cushing, Annie
    Kingdon, David
    Bremner, Stephen
    Priebe, Stefan
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2016, 209 (06) : 517 - 524
  • [28] Prevalence of non-suicidal self-harm and service contact in England, 2000-14: repeated cross-sectional surveys of the general population
    McManus, Sally
    Gunnell, David
    Cooper, Claudia
    Bebbington, Paul E.
    Howard, Louise M.
    Brugha, Traolach
    Jenkins, Rachel
    Hassiotis, Angela
    Weich, Scott
    Appleby, Louis
    [J]. LANCET PSYCHIATRY, 2019, 6 (07): : 573 - 581
  • [29] Mental Health Taskforce, 2016, Five year forward review for mental health
  • [30] National Health Service (NHS), 2020, Next steps on the NHS five year forward review: Mental health