On efficient posterior inference in normalized power prior Bayesian analysis

The power prior has been widely used to discount the amount of information borrowed from historical data in the design and analysis of clinical trials. It is realized by raising the likelihood function of the historical data to a power parameter delta is an element of[0,1]$\delta \in [0, 1]$, which quantifies the heterogeneity between the historical and the new study. In a fully Bayesian approach, a natural extension is to assign a hyperprior to delta such that the posterior of delta can reflect the degree of similarity between the historical and current data. To comply with the likelihood principle, an extra normalizing factor needs to be calculated and such prior is known as the normalized power prior. However, the normalizing factor involves an integral of a prior multiplied by a fractional likelihood and needs to be computed repeatedly over different delta during the posterior sampling. This makes its use prohibitive in practice for most elaborate models. This work provides an efficient framework to implement the normalized power prior in clinical studies. It bypasses the aforementioned efforts by sampling from the power prior with delta=0$\delta = 0$ and delta=1$\delta = 1$ only. Such a posterior sampling procedure can facilitate the use of a random delta with adaptive borrowing capability in general models. The numerical efficiency of the proposed method is illustrated via extensive simulation studies, a toxicological study, and an oncology study.