Comment on "Kawahara, H., Yoshida, H., Yamamoto, K., Katsuta, N., Nishimoto, S., Umemura, A., Kuma, R., 2022. Hydrothermal formation of Fe-oxide bands in zebra rocks from northern Western Australia. Chemical Geology 590 (2022), 120699"

This comment questions an hypothesis for formation of the ornamental stone "zebra rock" from Ediacaran red shales of northwestern Australia as hydrothermal alteration zones. The hypothesis is falsified by absence of Eu anomalies in REE arrays, lack of associated carbonate, low degree of chemical weathering, associated soluble gypsum, strata concordance in narrow bands, low thermal stability of magnetization, modest diagenetic alteration, and patterns unlike liesegang banding. Rather than Cambrian hydrothermal veins, zebra rocks were gleyed paleosols with redox banding, from acid sulfate weathering at low temperature during the Ediacaran.