Effects of mirror therapy with electrical stimulation for upper limb recovery in people with stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:2
作者
Pan, Hong [1 ]
Liu, Tai Wa [2 ]
Ng, Shamay S. M. [1 ]
Chen, Pei Ming [1 ]
Chung, Raymond C. K. [1 ]
Lam, Stefanie S. L. [3 ]
Li, Carol S. K. [3 ]
Chan, Charles C. C. [3 ]
Lai, Charles W. K. [1 ]
Ng, Winnie W. L. [4 ]
Tang, Maria W. S. [5 ]
Hui, Elsie [5 ]
Woo, Jean [6 ]
机构
[1] Hong Kong Polytech Univ, Dept Rehabil Sci, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[2] Hong Kong Metropolitan Univ, Sch Nursing & Hlth Studies, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[3] Shatin Hosp, Dept Physiotherapy, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[4] Tseung Kwan O Hosp, Dept Med, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[5] Shatin Hosp, Dept Med & Geriatr, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[6] Chinese Univ Hong Kong, Fac Med, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
关键词
Synergistic effect; mirror therapy; electrical stimulation; priming methods; stroke rehabilitation; upper extremity; review; COMBINING AFFERENT STIMULATION; UPPER-EXTREMITY; MOTOR RECOVERY; HAND MOVEMENT; RELIABILITY; MECHANISMS; VALIDITY; REORGANIZATION; SENSORIMOTOR; DISABILITY;
D O I
10.1080/09638288.2024.2310757
中图分类号
R49 [康复医学];
学科分类号
100215 ;
摘要
Purpose: To provide updated evidence about the effects of MT with ES for recovering upper extremities motor function in people with stroke. Methods: Systematic review and meta-analysis were completed. Methodological quality was assessed using the version 2 of the Cochrane risk-of-bias tool. The GRADE approach was employed to assess the certainty of evidence. Results: A total of 16 trials with 773 participants were included in this review. The results demonstrated that MT with ES was more effective than sham (standardized mean difference [SMD], 1.89 [1.52-2.26]) and ES alone (SMD, 0.42 [0.11-0.73]) with low quality of evidence, or MT alone (SMD, 0.47[0.04-0.89]) with low quality of evidence for improving upper extremity motor control assessed using Fugl-Meyer Assessment. MT with ES had significant improvement of (MD, 6.47 [1.92-11.01]) the upper extremity gross gripping function assessed using the Action Research Arm Test compared with MT alone with low quality of evidence. MT combined with ES was more effective than sham group (SMD, 1.17 [0.42-1.93) for improving the ability to perform activities of daily living with low quality of evidence assessed using Motor Activity Log. Conclusion: MT with ES may be effective in improving upper limb motor recovery in people with stroke. IMPLICATION FOR REHABILITATION center dot Combining Mirror Therapy (MT) and Electrical Stimulation (ES) modality could improve upper limb motor control, gross gripping function, and performance in ADLs based on ICF for people with stroke. center dot Those individuals with subacute stroke are recommended as the optimal target group for the combined MT and ES.
引用
收藏
页码:5660 / 5675
页数:16
相关论文
共 73 条
[61]   A Longitudinal Study of Hand Motor Recovery after Sub-Acute Stroke: A Study Combined fMRI with Diffusion Tensor Imaging [J].
Wei, Wenjuan ;
Bai, Lijun ;
Wang, Jun ;
Dai, Ruwei ;
Tong, Raymond Kai-yu ;
Zhang, Yumei ;
Song, Zheng ;
Jiang, Wen ;
Shi, Chuanying ;
Li, Mengyuan ;
Ai, Lin ;
Tian, Jie .
PLOS ONE, 2013, 8 (05)
[62]   Toward an epidemiology of poststroke spasticity [J].
Wissel, Joerg ;
Manack, Aubrey ;
Brainin, Michael .
NEUROLOGY, 2013, 80 :S13-S19
[63]   Enduring representational plasticity after somatosensory stimulation [J].
Wu, CWH ;
van Gelderen, P ;
Hanakawa, T ;
Yaseen, Z ;
Cohen, LG .
NEUROIMAGE, 2005, 27 (04) :872-884
[64]  
Xu S., 2020, PRACT J CARD CEREB P, V28, P89
[65]   Efficacy of Controlled Whole-Body Vibration Training on Improving Fall Risk Factors in Stroke Survivors: A Meta-analysis [J].
Yang, Feng ;
Butler, Andrew J. .
NEUROREHABILITATION AND NEURAL REPAIR, 2020, 34 (04) :275-288
[66]   Effectiveness of electrical stimulation therapy in improving arm function after stroke: a systematic review and a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials [J].
Yang, Jheng-Dao ;
Liao, Chun-De ;
Huang, Shih-Wei ;
Tam, Ka-Wai ;
Liou, Tsan-Hon ;
Lee, Yu-Hao ;
Lin, Chia-Yun ;
Chen, Hung-Chou .
CLINICAL REHABILITATION, 2019, 33 (08) :1286-1297
[67]   Effect of Mirror Therapy on Recovery of Stroke Survivors: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis [J].
Yang, Yue ;
Zhao, Qingchun ;
Zhang, Yingshi ;
Wu, Qiong ;
Jiang, Xiaowen ;
Cheng, Gang .
NEUROSCIENCE, 2018, 390 :318-336
[68]  
姚淑珍, 2016, [中华物理医学与康复杂志, Chinese Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation], V38, P746
[69]   A standardized approach to performing the action research arm test [J].
Yozbatiran, Nuray ;
Der-Yeghiaian, Lucy ;
Cramer, Steven C. .
NEUROREHABILITATION AND NEURAL REPAIR, 2008, 22 (01) :78-90
[70]   The Synergic Effects of Mirror Therapy and Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation for Hand Function in Stroke Patients [J].
Yun, Gi Jeong ;
Chun, Min Ho ;
Park, Ji Young ;
Kim, Bo Ryun .
ANNALS OF REHABILITATION MEDICINE-ARM, 2011, 35 (03) :316-321