Quality and Content Concordance of International Clinical Guidelines on Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy Using the AGREE II Instrument: An Updated Systematic Review

被引:0
|
作者
Bazzano, Alessandra N. N. [1 ]
Keenan, Alexandra [2 ]
Woltz, Sara [1 ]
Subramanian, Advaith [3 ]
Akpogheneta, Onome [1 ,4 ]
Coronado Daza, Jorge [5 ]
Bazzano, Lydia A. L. [2 ]
机构
[1] Tulane Univ, Dept Social Behav & Populat Sci, Sch Publ Hlth & Trop Med, New Orleans, LA 70112 USA
[2] Tulane Univ, Dept Epidemiol, Sch Publ Hlth & Trop Med, 1440 Canal St, New Orleans, LA 70112 USA
[3] Tulane Univ, Murphy Inst, Sch Liberal Arts, New Orleans, LA 70118 USA
[4] London Sch Hyg & Trop Med, Infect Dis Program, London WC1E 7HT, England
[5] Univ Cartagena, Dept Med, Cartagena 130014, Colombia
关键词
hypertension; women's health; pregnancy-induced hypertension; vascular diseases; MATERNAL PREECLAMPSIA; RISK; MANAGEMENT; DIAGNOSIS; INFANT; ASSOCIATION; PREVENTION; EPILEPSY; STROKE; TRENDS;
D O I
10.3390/jcdd10070295
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Utilization of high-quality clinical practice guidelines has the potential to positively impact health outcomes. This study aimed to assess the quality and content concordance of national and international recommendations on hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDPs). Searches were conducted of the MEDLINE database and reference lists generated from national and international agencies. Covidence software was used for the management of the systematic review process, the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) tool was used to assess guidelines for quality, and three reviewers independently screened records. The research team identified and screened a total of 399 records of which 10 were deemed high quality. Guidelines were assessed and compared regarding the treatment, prevention, and categorization of disorders. The quality of guidelines varied across different domains, with significant variation in domain scores even within individual guidelines. Not all recommendations showed a high level of methodologic rigor, and the highest-rated guidelines were from the American Heart Association, the World Health Organization, and South Africa national guidelines. Classification of hypertension differed among the guidelines, particularly in defining chronic hypertension, severe hypertension, and preeclampsia. Prevention modalities varied across guidelines, with recommendations for aspirin, calcium supplementation, and against the use of certain approaches. Treatment modalities highlighted the importance of delivery as the definitive way to terminate hypertensive disorders of pregnancy, with other management strategies provided for symptom control. The variability in guidelines and consensus statements across different contexts may reflect regional differences in healthcare practices, available resources, and research evidence. There is potential to harmonize guidelines for HDP globally while considering the unique needs of individual countries. Where guidelines may be synthesized and condensed into an accessible format, doing so could improve their use in clinical decision-making.
引用
收藏
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Clinical practice guidelines for the nutritional risk screening and assessment of cancer patients: a systematic quality appraisal using the AGREE II instrument
    Zhou, Hong-Juan
    Deng, Li-Jin
    Wang, Tao
    Chen, Jin-Xiu
    Jiang, Su-Zhen
    Yang, Liu
    Liu, Fang
    Weng, Mei-Hua
    Hu, Jing-Wen
    Tan, Jing-Yu
    SUPPORTIVE CARE IN CANCER, 2021, 29 (06) : 2885 - 2893
  • [42] Appraisal of clinical practice guidelines for the management of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) using the AGREE II Instrument: A systematic review
    Amer, Yasser Sami
    Al-Joudi, Haya Faisal
    Varnham, Jeremy L.
    Bashiri, Fahad A.
    Hamad, Muddathir Hamad
    Al Salehi, Saleh M.
    Daghash, Hadeel Fakhri
    Albatti, Turki Homod
    PLOS ONE, 2019, 14 (07):
  • [43] Quality assessment of conventional and traditional oriental medicine clinical practice guidelines for knee osteoarthritis using AGREE II instrument
    Kim, Jun-Yeon
    Kim, Jung-Hyun
    Goo, Bon-Hyuk
    Park, Yeon-Cheol
    Seo, Byung-Kwan
    Baek, Yong-Hyeon
    MEDICINE, 2021, 100 (51)
  • [44] Quality assessment of clinical practice guidelines on psychological distress of cancer patients using the AGREE II instrument
    Hao, Ran
    Jin, Haoyu
    Zuo, Jinfan
    Zhao, Rumeng
    Hu, Jie
    Qi, Yixin
    FRONTIERS IN ONCOLOGY, 2022, 12
  • [45] Evaluation of guidelines regarding surgical treatment of breast cancer using the AGREE Instrument: a systematic review
    Lei, Xin
    Liu, Fengtao
    Luo, Shuying
    Sun, Ya
    Zhu, Liling
    Su, Fengxi
    Chen, Kai
    Li, Shunrong
    BMJ OPEN, 2017, 7 (11):
  • [46] A critical appraisal of urolithiasis clinical practice guidelines using the AGREE II instrument
    Zou, Bangyu
    Zhou, Yuhao
    He, Zhiqing
    Zhou, Xiaofeng
    Dong, Sicheng
    Zheng, Xiaopeng
    Xu, Ran
    Duan, Xiaolu
    Zeng, Guohua
    TRANSLATIONAL ANDROLOGY AND UROLOGY, 2023, 12 (06) : 977 - 988
  • [47] A critical appraisal of clinical practice guidelines on insomnia using the RIGHT statement and AGREE II instrument
    Zhu, Hongfei
    Li, Mengting
    Pan, Bei
    Yang, Qiuyu
    Cao, Xiao
    Wang, Qi
    Chen, Yaolong
    Ding, Guowu
    Tian, Jinhui
    Ge, Long
    SLEEP MEDICINE, 2022, 100 : 244 - 253
  • [48] A Systematic Critical Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines in Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis Using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) Instrument
    Smith, Christine A. M.
    Toupin-April, Karine
    Jutai, Jeffrey W.
    Duffy, Ciaran M.
    Rahman, Prinon
    Cavallo, Sabrina
    Brosseau, Lucie
    PLOS ONE, 2015, 10 (09):
  • [49] A systematic review of paediatric neurogenic lower urinary tract dysfunction guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines and Research Evaluation (AGREE) II instrument
    Yadav, Priyank
    Alsabban, Abdulrahman
    de los Reyes, Thomas
    Varghese, Abby
    Ming, Jessica M.
    Milford, Karen
    Yang, Stephen S.
    Silangcruz, Jan M.
    Dos Santos, Joana
    Bagli, Darius J.
    Rickard, Mandy
    Lorenzo, Armando J.
    Church, Paige
    Chua, Michael E.
    BJU INTERNATIONAL, 2023, 131 (05) : 520 - 529
  • [50] Quality evaluation of clinical practice guidelines for thromboprophylaxis in orthopaedic trauma based on AGREE II and AGREE-REX: a systematic review protocol
    He, Ling-Xiao
    Xie, Jing-Ying
    Lv, Juan
    Liu, Huan
    Liao, Deng-Bin
    Wang, Guang-Lin
    Ning, Ning
    Zhou, Zong-Ke
    BMJ OPEN, 2022, 12 (11):