"So Lonely": Comparative Law and the Quest for Interdisciplinary Legal Education

被引:0
作者
Resta, Giorgio [1 ]
机构
[1] Roma Tre Univ, Dept Law, Rome, Italy
来源
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR THE SEMIOTICS OF LAW-REVUE INTERNATIONALE DE SEMIOTIQUE JURIDIQUE | 2024年 / 37卷 / 05期
关键词
Comparative Law; Interdisciplinarity; Legal Education; DISCIPLINE;
D O I
10.1007/s11196-024-10143-1
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
For various reasons, that will be recalled and analysed throughout this paper, interdisciplinarity has become the keyword for any debate on legal education reform. However, what is meant by interdisciplinarity and how it should be achieved is open for discussion. Paradigms of "scientificity" of the law vary dramatically among legal cultures. Whereas in the US the advent of a more 'substantial' legal thought after the New Deal went hand in hand with the rise of the interdisciplinary paradigm, in Europe the traditional assumption of law's autonomy has repeatedly been challenged, eroded and adapted, but it still represents the bulwark of the orthodox approach to law and legal scholarship. In the Continent, mainstream legal scholarship does not take as its object the social reality, but only the gamut of rules recognized as binding norms. Coherent with this approach is a model of legal education built around certain axioms, such as the statist and nationalist attitude, the extreme compartmentalization among the various branches of law, and the blindness to its surroundings. Comparative law is one of the few disciplines that provide a different role model for a legal scholar who is apt to confront the challenges of complex societies. Keeping at a reasonable distance the authority paradigm, embodying the spirit of enquiry and cherishing the values of pluralism (both in terms of legal pluralism and cognitive openness), comparativists may give specific content to the paradigm of the jurist as a social engineer. Comparative law may therefore offer an invaluable contribution to the debate on legal education reform.
引用
收藏
页码:1569 / 1586
页数:18
相关论文
共 94 条
  • [21] FEKETE Balazs, 2021, Paradigms in Modern European Comparative Law: A History
  • [22] FRANKENBERG G, 1985, HARVARD INT LAW J, V26, P411
  • [23] Frankenberg Gnter., 2016, COMP LAW CRITIQUE, DOI [10.4337/9781785363948, DOI 10.4337/9781785363948]
  • [24] Gambaro Antonio, 2013, VOCAZIONE CIVILE GIU, P323
  • [25] Gambaro Antonio, 2004, GLOBAL JURIST FRONTI, V1
  • [26] Garapon Antoine, 2021, Giustizia digitale, Determinismo tecnologico e liberta
  • [27] Giorgio Resta, 2017, MCGILL LAW J, V62, P1153
  • [28] Glenn Patrick H, 2014, METHOD CULTURE COMP, P17
  • [29] Glenn Patrick H., 2013, RDUS, V43, P23
  • [30] Glenn Patrick H., 2012, ELGAR ENCY COMP LAW, V67