Effect of leaflet laceration on transcatheter aortic valve replacement fluid mechanics and comparison with surgical aortic valve replacement

Background: Leaflet thrombosis after surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) and transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) may be caused by blood flow stagnation in the native and neosinus regions. To date, aortic leaflet laceration has been used to mitigate coronary obstruction following TAVR; however, its influence on the fluid mechanics of the native and neosinus regions is poorly under-stood. This in vitro study compared the flow velocities and flow patterns in the setting of SAVR vs TAVR with and without aortic leaflet lacerations.Methods: Two valves, (23-mm Perimount and 26-mm SAPIEN 3; Edwards Lifesciences) were studied in a validated mock flow loop under physiologic conditions. Neo -sinus and native sinus fluid mechanics were quantified using particle image velocimetry in the left and noncoronary cusp, with an increasing number of aortic leaflets lacerated or removed.Results: Across all conditions, SAVR had the highest average sinus and neosinus velocities, and this value was used as a reference to compare against the TAVR conditions. With an increasing number of leaflets lacerated or removed with TAVR, the average sinus and neosinus velocities increased from 25% to 70% of SAVR flow (100%). Diastolic velocities were substantially augmented by leaflet laceration. Also, the shorter frame of the SAVR led to higher flow velocities compared with the longer frame of the TAVR, even after complete leaflet removal.Conclusions: Leaflet laceration augmented TAVR native and neosinus flowfields, approaching that of SAVR. These findings may have potential clinical implications for the use of single or multiple leaflet lacerations to reduce leaflet thrombosis and thus potentially improve TAVR durability.