Spontaneous symmetry breaking without ground state degeneracy in generalized N-state clock model

Spontaneous symmetry breaking is a ubiquitous phenomenon in nature. One of the defining features of symmetry-broken phases is that the large system size limit and the vanishing external field limit do not commute. In this work, we study a family of extensions of the N-state clock model. We find that the exact symmetry and the ground state degeneracy under the periodic boundary condition heavily depend on the system size, although the model has the manifest translation symmetry. In particular, the ground state can be unique and all excitations are gapped even when the phase exhibits noncommutativity of the two limits. Our model hence poses a question on the standard understanding of spontaneous symmetry breaking.