Artificial intelligence for oral and dental healthcare: Core education curriculum

被引:35
作者
Schwendicke, Falk [1 ,2 ]
Chaurasia, Akhilanand [2 ,3 ]
Wiegand, Thomas [2 ,4 ]
Uribe, Sergio E. [2 ,5 ,6 ,7 ]
Fontana, Margherita [8 ]
Akota, Ilze [9 ]
Tryfonos, Olga [2 ,10 ,11 ]
Krois, Joachim [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Charite Univ Med Berlin, Dept Oral Diagnost Digital Hlth & Hlth Serv Res, Berlin, Germany
[2] ITU WHO Focus Grp AI Hlth, Top Grp Dent, Geneva, Switzerland
[3] King Georges Med Univ, Dept Oral Med & Radiol, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India
[4] Tech Univ Berlin, Berlin, Germany
[5] Riga Stradins Univ, Bioinformat Lab, Riga, Latvia
[6] Riga Stradins Univ, Dept Conservat Dent & Oral Hlth, Riga, Latvia
[7] Univ Austral Chile, Sch Dent, Valdivia, Chile
[8] Univ Michigan, Cariol Restorat Sci & Endodont, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[9] Riga Stradins Univ, Dept Oral & Maxillofacial Surg, Riga, Latvia
[10] Univ Amsterdam, Acad Ctr Dent Amsterdam ACTA, Dept Periodontol & Oral Biochem, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[11] Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
关键词
Artificial intelligence; Curriculum; Deep learning; Dental; Education; Machine learning; Teeth; PERCEPTIONS; KNOWLEDGE;
D O I
10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104363
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Objectives: Artificial intelligence (AI) is swiftly entering oral health services and dentistry, while most providers show limited knowledge and skills to appraise dental AI applications. We aimed to define a core curriculum for both undergraduate and postgraduate education, establishing a minimum set of outcomes learners should acquire when taught about oral and dental AI.Methods: Existing curricula and other documents focusing on literacy of medical professionals around AI were screened and relevant items extracted. Items were scoped and adapted using expert interviews with members of the IADR's e-oral health group, the ITU/WHO's Focus Group AI for Health and the Association for Dental Education in Europe. Learning outcome levels were defined and each item assigned to a level. Items were systematized into domains and a curricular structure defined. The resulting curriculum was consented using an online Delphi process.Results: Four domains of learning outcomes emerged, with most outcomes being on the "knowledge" level: (1) Basic definitions and terms, the reasoning behind AI and the principle of machine learning, the idea of training, validating and testing models, the definition of reference tests, the contrast between dynamic and static AI, and the problem of AI being a black box and requiring explainability should be known. (2) Use cases, the required types of AI to address them, and the typical setup of AI software for dental purposes should be taught. (3) Evaluation metrics, their interpretation, the relevant impact of AI on patient or societal health outcomes and associated examples should be considered. (4) Issues around generalizability and representativeness, explainability, autonomy and accountability and the need for governance should be highlighted.Conclusion: Both educators and learners should consider this core curriculum during planning, conducting and evaluating oral and dental AI education.Clinical significance: A core curriculum on oral and dental AI may help to increase oral and dental healthcare providers' literacy around AI, allowing them to critically appraise AI applications and to use them consciously and on an informed basis.
引用
收藏
页数:5
相关论文
共 18 条
[1]   An extensive survey of radiographers from the Middle East and India on artificial intelligence integration in radiology practice [J].
Abuzaid, Mohamed M. ;
Elshami, Wiam ;
McConnell, Jonathan ;
Tekin, H. O. .
HEALTH AND TECHNOLOGY, 2021, 11 (05) :1045-1050
[2]  
[Anonymous], 2022, Collins Dictionary
[3]   Global, Regional, and National Levels and Trends in Burden of Oral Conditions from 1990 to 2017: A Systematic Analysis for the Global Burden of Disease 2017 Study [J].
Bernabe, E. ;
Marcenes, W. ;
Hernandez, C. R. ;
Bailey, J. ;
Abreu, L. G. ;
Alipour, V ;
Amini, S. ;
Arabloo, J. ;
Arefi, Z. ;
Arora, A. ;
Ayanore, M. A. ;
Baernighausen, T. W. ;
Chan, T. H. ;
Bijani, A. ;
Cho, D. Y. ;
Chu, D. T. ;
Crowe, C. S. ;
Demoz, G. T. ;
Demsie, D. G. ;
Forooshani, Z. S. Dibaji ;
Du, M. ;
El Tantawi, M. ;
Fischer, F. ;
Folayan, M. O. ;
Futran, N. D. ;
Geramo, Y. C. D. ;
Haj-Mirzaian, A. ;
Hariyani, N. ;
Hasanzadeh, A. ;
Hassanipour, S. ;
Hay, S., I ;
Hole, M. K. ;
Hostiuc, S. ;
Ilic, M. D. ;
James, S. L. ;
Kalhor, R. ;
Kemmer, L. ;
Keramati, M. ;
Khader, Y. S. ;
Kisa, S. ;
Kisa, A. ;
Koyanagi, A. ;
Lalloo, R. ;
Le Nguyen, Q. ;
London, S. D. ;
Manohar, N. D. ;
Massenburg, B. B. ;
Mathur, M. R. ;
Meles, H. G. ;
Mestrovic, T. .
JOURNAL OF DENTAL RESEARCH, 2020, 99 (04) :362-373
[4]   Knowledge, attitude, and practice of artificial intelligence in emergency and trauma surgery, the ARIES project: an international web-based survey [J].
De Simone, Belinda ;
Abu-Zidan, Fikri M. ;
Gumbs, Andrew A. ;
Chouillard, Elie ;
Di Saverio, Salomone ;
Sartelli, Massimo ;
Coccolini, Federico ;
Ansaloni, Luca ;
Collins, Toby ;
Kluger, Yoram ;
Moore, Ernest E. ;
Litvin, Andrej ;
Leppaniemi, Ari ;
Mascagni, Pietro ;
Milone, Luca ;
Piccoli, Micaela ;
Abu-Hilal, Mohamed ;
Sugrue, Michael ;
Biffl, Walter L. ;
Catena, Fausto .
WORLD JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY SURGERY, 2022, 17 (01)
[5]   The current state of knowledge on imaging informatics: a survey among Spanish radiologists [J].
Eiroa, Daniel ;
Antolin, Andreu ;
del Castillo Ascanio, Monica Fernandez ;
Pantoja Ortiz, Violeta ;
Escobar, Manuel ;
Roson, Nuria .
INSIGHTS INTO IMAGING, 2022, 13 (01)
[6]  
European Parliament and the Council of the European Union, REC EUR PARL COUNC 2
[7]   The Graduating European Dentist: A New Undergraduate Curriculum Framework INTRODUCTION [J].
Field, J. C. ;
Cowpe, J. G. ;
Walmsley, A. D. .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF DENTAL EDUCATION, 2017, 21 :2-10
[8]  
Giovagnoli M.R., 2021, HEALTHCARE-BASEL, V9
[9]   Guidance on Conducting and REporting DElphi Studies (CREDES) in palliative care: Recommendations based on a methodological systematic review [J].
Juenger, Saskia ;
Payne, Sheila A. ;
Brine, Jenny ;
Radbruch, Lukas ;
Brearley, Sarah G. .
PALLIATIVE MEDICINE, 2017, 31 (08) :684-706
[10]   Attitudes Toward Artificial Intelligence Within Dermatopathology: An International Online Survey [J].
Polesie, Sam ;
McKee, Phillip H. ;
Gardner, Jerad M. ;
Gillstedt, Martin ;
Siarov, Jan ;
Neittaanmaki, Noora ;
Paoli, John .
FRONTIERS IN MEDICINE, 2020, 7