Comparison of Needle Knife versus Scissors Forceps for Colorectal Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection: A Prospective Randomized Study

被引:4
作者
Yachida, Tatsuo [1 ,2 ]
Kobara, Hideki [1 ]
Kozuka, Kazuhiro [1 ]
Nakatani, Kaho [1 ]
Tada, Naoya [1 ]
Matsui, Takanori [1 ]
Chiyo, Taiga [1 ]
Kobayashi, Nobuya [1 ]
Fujihara, Shintaro [1 ]
Nishiyama, Noriko [1 ]
Kondo, Akihiro [3 ]
Ando, Yasuhisa [3 ]
Okano, Keiichi [3 ]
Nonaka, Wakako [2 ]
Ishikawa, Kaori [2 ]
Masugata, Hisashi [2 ]
Masaki, Tsutomu [1 ]
机构
[1] Kagawa Univ, Fac Med, Dept Gastroenterol & Neurol, Kita, Miki, Kagawa 7610793, Japan
[2] Kagawa Univ, Fac Med, Dept Gen Internal Med, Kita, Miki, Kagawa 7610793, Japan
[3] Kagawa Univ, Fac Med, Dept Gastroenterol Surg, Kita, Miki, Kagawa 7610793, Japan
关键词
endoscopic knife; colorectal endoscopic submucosal dissection; EARLY GASTRIC-CANCER; NEOPLASIA; TUMORS; RESECTION; OUTCOMES;
D O I
10.3390/jcm12062329
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background and Aim: To evaluate the efficacy and safety of a grasping-type knife, called Clutch Cutter (CC), for colorectal endoscopic submucosal dissection (C-ESD). Methods: This was a randomized prospective study. Patients who underwent C-ESD for colorectal neoplasms >20 mm and <50 mm in size were enrolled, dividing into two groups: ESD using needle type of dual knife alone (D-group) and circumferential incision using dual knife followed by submucosal dissection using CC (CC-group). The primary outcome was the self-completion rate. The secondary outcomes were intraoperative complication rate, procedure time, and en bloc resection rate. Results: A total of 45 patients were allocated to the D-group and 43 to the CC-group were allocated. The self-completion rate was higher in the CC-group (87% [39/45] vs. 98% [42/43]). All of the six patients with an incomplete procedure in the D-group were completely resected with CC use. The intraoperative complication rate was not significant in either group (D vs. CC: 2% vs. 0%). The mean procedure time was significantly shorter in the D-group than that in the CC-group (62.0 vs. 81.1 min; p = 0.0036). The en bloc resection rate was 100% in the D-group and 98% in the CC-group. Conclusions: While dual knife use is superior to CC in terms of time efficiency, the use of CC may be a safe and efficacious option for achieving complete C-ESD.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 27 条
[1]   Endoscopic submucosal dissection using a novel grasping type scissors forceps [J].
Akahoshi, K. ;
Akahane, H. ;
Murata, A. ;
Akiba, H. ;
Oya, M. .
ENDOSCOPY, 2007, 39 (12) :1103-1105
[2]   Endoscopic submucosal dissection of early colorectal tumors using a grasping-type scissors forceps: a preliminary clinical study [J].
Akahoshi, K. ;
Okamoto, R. ;
Akahane, H. ;
Motomura, Y. ;
Kubokawa, M. ;
Osoegawa, T. ;
Nakama, N. ;
Chaen, T. ;
Oya, M. ;
Nakamura, K. .
ENDOSCOPY, 2010, 42 (05) :419-422
[3]  
Akahoshi K, 2017, WORLD J GASTRO ENDOS, V9, P334, DOI 10.4253/wjge.v9.i7.334
[4]   Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection for Early Gastric Cancer using the Clutch Cutter: a large single-center experience [J].
Akahoshi, Kazuya ;
Motomura, Yasuaki ;
Kubokawa, Masaru ;
Gibo, Junya ;
Kinoshita, Nobukatsu ;
Osada, Shigeki ;
Tokumaru, Kayo ;
Hosokawa, Taizou ;
Tomoeda, Naru ;
Otsuka, Yoshihiro ;
Matsuo, Mie ;
Oya, Masafumi ;
Koga, Hidenobu ;
Nakamura, Kazuhiko .
ENDOSCOPY INTERNATIONAL OPEN, 2015, 3 (05) :E432-E438
[5]   A New Approach: Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection Using the Clutch Cutter® for Early Stage Digestive Tract Tumors [J].
Akahoshi, Kazuya ;
Akahane, Hidefumi ;
Motomura, Yasuaki ;
Kubokawa, Masaru ;
Itaba, Syouichi ;
Komori, Keishi ;
Nakama, Naotaka ;
Oya, Masafumi ;
Nakamura, Kazuhiko .
DIGESTION, 2012, 85 (02) :80-84
[6]   A new breakthrough: ESD using a newly developed grasping type scissor forceps for early gastrointestinal tract neoplasms [J].
Akahoshi, Kazuya ;
Akahane, Hidefumi .
WORLD JOURNAL OF GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2010, 2 (03) :90-96
[7]   Efficacy of Clutch Cutter for Standardizing Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection for Early Gastric Cancer: A Propensity Score-Matched Analysis [J].
Dohi, Osamu ;
Yoshida, Naohisa ;
Terasaki, Kei ;
Azuma, Yuka ;
Ishida, Tsugitaka ;
Kitae, Hiroaki ;
Matsumura, Shinya ;
Ogita, Kazuyuki ;
Takayama, Shun ;
Mizuno, Naoki ;
Nakano, Takahiro ;
Hirose, Ryohei ;
Inoue, Ken ;
Kamada, Kazuhiro ;
Uchiyama, Kazuhiko ;
Ishikawa, Takeshi ;
Takagi, Tomohisa ;
Kishimoto, Mitsuo ;
Konishi, Hideyuki ;
Naito, Yuji ;
Itoh, Yoshito .
DIGESTION, 2019, 100 (03) :201-209
[8]   Clinical outcomes after endoscopic submucosal dissection for colorectal neoplasia: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Fuccio, Lorenzo ;
Hassan, Cesare ;
Ponchon, Thierry ;
Mandolesi, Daniele ;
Farioli, Andrea ;
Cucchetti, Alessandro ;
Frazzoni, Leonardo ;
Bhandari, Pradeep ;
Bellisario, Cristina ;
Bazzoli, Franco ;
Repici, Alessandro .
GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2017, 86 (01) :74-+
[9]   Outcomes of endoscopic submucosal dissection for colorectal epithelial neoplasms in 200 consecutive cases [J].
Fujishiro, Mitsuhiro ;
Yahagi, Naohisa ;
Kakushima, Naomi ;
Kodashima, Shinya ;
Muraki, Yosuke ;
Ono, Satoshi ;
Yamamichi, Nobutake ;
Tateishi, Ayako ;
Oka, Masashi ;
Ogura, Keiji ;
Kawabe, Takao ;
Ichinose, Masao ;
Omata, Masao .
CLINICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY, 2007, 5 (06) :678-683
[10]   ENDOSCOPIC SUBMUCOSAL DISSECTION FOR COLORECTAL NEOPLASIA [J].
Honma, Kiyoaki ;
Kobayashi, Makoto ;
Watanabe, Hidetaka ;
Suga, Toshihiro ;
Tominaga, Keiichi ;
Yamagata, Michiko ;
Hiraishi, Hideyuki .
DIGESTIVE ENDOSCOPY, 2010, 22 (04) :307-311