Medial meniscal repair in stable knees: Survival rate and risk factors for failure at a minimum of 5 years

Introduction: The menisci play a major role in the protection of the knee against osteoarthritis. A medial meniscus (MM) tear occurring in a stable knee is more at risk of repair failure than a suture concomitant with reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. Hypothesis: The survival of MM sutures in stable knees depends on the type of lesion. Materials and methods: This retrospective study was carried out as part of the 2022 Francophone Arthroscopy Society's symposium, across 10 centers (Bordeaux-Merignac, Caen, Lille, Lille Louviere, Lyon, Marseille, Toulouse, Saint-Etienne, Strasbourg and Versailles) including medial meniscus sutures in stable knees performed before the end of 2017 (minimum 5 years of follow-up) with a collection of demographic, imaging, suture and postoperative protocol data, and a functional evaluation using the Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome score (KOOS). The aim of this study was to analyze the medial meniscus suturesin stable knees and to evaluate their survival and their risk factors for failure according to the type oflesion; failure being defined by the use of a meniscectomy. Results: Three-hundred and sixty-seven MM sutures, including 122 bucket-handle tears, were included. The KOOS score was improved by the meniscal suture by an average of 22.2 points for each sub-score (p < 0.05), with an improvement, which was more marked for the bucket-handle tears. The failure rate, defined by revision surgery by meniscectomy, was 33% on average (42% for bucket-handles tears, 26% for others). The probability of survival was reduced for bucket-handle tears (62% at 5 years versus 77% forthe other types). For all lesions, the main risk factor identified for failure was immediate weight-bearing [OR = 3.6 (1.62; 7.98), p = 0.0016]. Smoking was a failure risk factor for bucket-handle tears [OR = 5.76 (1.81; 18.35), p = 0.003]. Conclusion: MM sutures in stable knees improve knee function but present a different risk of failure depending on the type of lesion treated with a higher risk of failure for bucket-handle tears with the need for caution to be applied with regards to weight-bearing and smoking. Level of evidence: IV; retrospective series. (c) 2023 Published by Elsevier Masson SAS.