How do you measure trust in social institutions and health professionals? A systematic review of the literature (2012-2021)

被引:9
作者
Aboueid, Stephanie E. [1 ]
Herati, Hoda [1 ]
Nascimento, Maria H. G. [1 ]
Ward, Paul R. [2 ]
Brown, Patrick R. [3 ,4 ]
Calnan, Michael [5 ]
Perlman, Christopher M. [1 ]
Meyer, Samantha B. [1 ,6 ]
机构
[1] Univ Waterloo, Sch Publ Hlth Sci, Waterloo, ON, Canada
[2] Torrens Univ, Ctr Publ Hlth Equ & Human Flourishing, Adelaide, SA, Australia
[3] Univ Amsterdam, Dept Sociol, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[4] Univ Amsterdam, Amsterdam Inst Social Sci Res, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[5] Univ Kent, Social Policy Sociol & Social Res, Canterbury, Kent, England
[6] 200 Univ Ave West, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada
来源
SOCIOLOGY COMPASS | 2023年 / 17卷 / 09期
基金
加拿大健康研究院;
关键词
healthcare; index; institutions; measures; providers; scale; trust; validation; PUBLIC TRUST; CARE;
D O I
10.1111/soc4.13101
中图分类号
C91 [社会学];
学科分类号
030301 ; 1204 ;
摘要
The importance of measuring trust in health systems has been accentuated due to its correlation with important health outcomes aimed at reducing COVID-19 transmission. A systematic review published almost a decade ago identified gaps in measures including the lack of focus on trust in systems, inconsistency regarding the dimensionality of trust and need for research to strengthen the validity of measures. Given developments in our understandings of trust since its publication, we sought to identify new scales developed, existing ones adapted in response to identified gaps, and agendas for future research. Using the PRISMA approach for systematic reviews, we conducted a search in four databases. A total of 26 articles were assessed. Twelve new scales were identified, while 14 were adapted for different settings and populations. Literature continues to focus on measuring trust in health professionals rather than systems. Various shortcomings were identified, including some articles not mentioning the dimensions included in the scale and suboptimal use of validity and reliability testing and/or reporting. Moreover, a variety of terms were used for dimensions. Future research is needed to address these gaps and consequently, to understand their correlation with health behaviors and outcomes more accurately.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]  
Anand T N, 2015, Indian J Med Ethics, V12, P149
[2]   Development and Validation of the Biomedical Research Trust Scale (BRTS) in English and Spanish [J].
Baik, Sharon H. ;
Arevalo, Mariana ;
Gwede, Clement ;
Meade, Cathy D. ;
Jacobsen, Paul B. ;
Quinn, Gwendolyn P. ;
Wells, Kristen J. .
JOURNAL OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH ON HUMAN RESEARCH ETHICS, 2016, 11 (04) :346-356
[3]   Validation of the Italian version of the full and abbreviated Trust in Oncologist Scale [J].
Bani, Marco ;
Rossi, Emanuela ;
Cortinovis, Diego ;
Russo, Selena ;
Gallina, Francesca ;
Hillen, Marij A. ;
Canova, Stefania ;
Cicchiello, Federica ;
Longarini, Raffaella ;
Cazzaniga, Marina Elena ;
Bidoli, Paolo ;
Valsecchi, Maria Grazia ;
Strepparava, Maria Grazia .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CANCER CARE, 2021, 30 (01)
[4]  
Barnes H. E., 1942, SOCIAL I ERA WORLD U
[5]   Aunties, WhatsApp, and "haldi da doodh": South Asian communities' perspectives on improving COVID-19 public health communication in Ontario, Canada [J].
Bhalla, Manvi ;
Boutros, Helana ;
Meyer, Samantha B. .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH-REVUE CANADIENNE DE SANTE PUBLIQUE, 2022, 113 (SUPPL 1) :46-53
[6]   Dependency, trust and choice? Examining agency and "forced options' within secondary-healthcare contexts [J].
Brown, Patrick R. ;
Meyer, Samantha B. .
CURRENT SOCIOLOGY, 2015, 63 (05) :729-745
[7]   Batman or Joker? A mixed-method approach to understanding children's perceptions of dentists [J].
Buldur, Burak .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ORAL SCIENCES, 2021, 129 (04)
[8]   Public trust in health care: the system or the doctor? [J].
Calnan, MW ;
Sanford, E .
QUALITY & SAFETY IN HEALTH CARE, 2004, 13 (02) :92-97
[9]  
Chatzea V. E., 2017, J PERIOPERATIVE PRAC, V27, P135, DOI [10.1177/175045891702700604, DOI 10.1177/175045891702700604]
[10]  
Davies H, 1999, J Health Serv Res Policy, V4, P193