A multi-metric fish index to measure the ecological quality of tropical predominantly open estuaries along the western coast of India

Defining the ecological quality of estuaries is challenging because of the inadequacy of available methods and indices to characterise the ecosystem. In Indian estuaries, there are no scientific attempts to establish multi-metric fish index to determine the ecological status. A multi-metric fish index (EMFI) was customised for twelve predominantly open estuaries on India's western coast. The index was established at the individual estuary level to ensure uniformity and contrast from sixteen metrics that designate the fish community and diversity, composition and abundance, estuarine use and trophic integrity from 2016 to 2019. A sensitivity study was followed to measure the responses of the EMFI under different metric varying scenarios. There were seven metrics identified as the most prominent for the EMFI in metric alteration scenarios. We also deduced a composite pressure index (CPI) based on the anthropogenic pressures described for the estuaries. The ecological quality ratios (EQR) defined based on EMFI (EQR(E)) and the CPI (EQR(P)) for all the estuaries were positively correlated. The EQR(E) values calculated based on the regression relationship (EQR(E) on EQR(P)) showed the divisions from 0.43 (bad) to 0.71 (high) for the Indian west coast estuaries. Similarly, the standardised CPI (EQR(P)) values for different estuaries indicated that the values range from 0.37 to 0.61. Our results based on the EMFI suggest four estuarine systems (33%) as 'good', seven (58%) as 'moderate' and one (9%) as 'poor'. Generalised Linear Mixed Model for EQR(E) showed that EQR(P) and estuary influenced EQR(E); however, the effect of year was not significant. This comprehensive study based on the EMFI is the first record for predominantly open estuaries along the Indian coast. Therefore, the EMFI established in this study could be reliably advocated as a sound, effective and composite tool of ecological quality for tropical open transitional waters.