Judicial Application of International Human Rights Treaties in China

被引:2
|
作者
戴瑞君 [1 ]
YIN Tao [1 ]
机构
[1] Institute of International Law, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences
关键词
court; human rights treaties; judicial application; international law; domestic law;
D O I
10.16696/j.cnki.11-4778/d.2020.01.006
中图分类号
D998.2 [人权的国际保护];
学科分类号
030109 ; 030206 ; 030609 ;
摘要
Since the Chinese Constitution does not stipulate the status of international treaties in the domestic legal system,the question of whether the domestic court can apply international human rights treaties keeps obscure all the time.China’s official statement and academic opinions generally believe that the domestic court couldn ’t resort to the human rights treaties.In recent years,however,several cases have come out involving direct reference to human rights treaties by the court.The following factors contribute together to the direct reference:the inward-looking nature of international human rights treaties,specific requirements of human rights treaties,and the possible institutional room in Chinas’ s current legal system.Take the view off ulfilling international human rights obligations,the practice of judicial application should be fully affirmed.Nevertheless,it should also be noted that relevant practice is still in its infancy,there are some problems such as inconsistent understanding and non-standard application.From the perspective of top-level design,it is necessary to provide a normative basis for the practice of the court,so as to make the international human rights treaties play their due role.
引用
收藏
页码:93 / 115
页数:23
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Is today's international human rights system a global governance regime?
    Nickel J.W.
    The Journal of Ethics, 2002, 6 (4) : 353 - 371
  • [42] Human rights begin at birth: International law and the claim of fetal rights
    Copelon, R
    Zampas, C
    Brusie, E
    deVore, J
    REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH MATTERS, 2005, 13 (26) : 120 - 129
  • [43] Capital Punishment, International Law, and Human Rights
    Robinson, Matthew
    Moody, Lauren
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE SCIENCES, 2019, 14 (02): : 298 - 319
  • [44] Intersectionality and disability in international human rights law
    de Beco, Gauthier
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN RIGHTS, 2020, 24 (05) : 593 - 614
  • [45] THE PROBLEM OF CAUSALITY IN INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS LAW
    McGrogan, David
    INTERNATIONAL & COMPARATIVE LAW QUARTERLY, 2016, 65 (03) : 615 - 644
  • [46] International law, human rights and HIV/AIDS
    Patterson, D
    London, L
    BULLETIN OF THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION, 2002, 80 (12) : 964 - 969
  • [47] Limits of international treaties to the constituent power? Analysis of the Chilean case
    Salgado, Constanza
    Lovera, Domingo
    Contreras, Pablo
    ICON-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAW, 2021, 19 (04): : 1351 - 1384
  • [49] International treaties have mostly failed to produce their intended effects
    Hoffman, Steven J.
    Baral, Prativa
    Van Katwyk, Susan Rogers
    Sritharan, Lathika
    Hughsam, Matthew
    Randhawa, Harkanwal
    Lin, Gigi
    Campbell, Sophie
    Campus, Brooke
    Dantas, Maria
    Foroughian, Neda
    Groux, Gaelle
    Gunn, Elliot
    Guyatt, Gordon
    Habibi, Roojin
    Karabit, Mina
    Karir, Aneesh
    Kruja, Krista
    Lavis, John N.
    Lee, Olivia
    Li, Binxi
    Nagi, Ranjana
    Naicker, Kiyuri
    Rottingen, John-Arne
    Sahar, Nicola
    Srivastava, Archita
    Tejpar, Ali
    Tran, Maxwell
    Zhang, Yu-Qing
    Zhou, Qi
    Poirier, Mathieu J. P.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2022, 119 (32)
  • [50] Who commits to regional human rights treaties? Reputational benefits, sovereignty costs, and regional dynamics
    Lohaus, Mathis
    Stapel, Soeren
    JOURNAL OF HUMAN RIGHTS, 2023, 22 (03) : 386 - 405