Workplace Age Stereotypes Across Gender Groups and Gender Stereotypes Across Age Groups: Similarities and Discrepancies

被引:0
作者
Imose, Ruth A. [1 ]
Martinez, Jasmin [2 ]
Finkelstein, Lisa M. [3 ]
Brooks, Vyctoria N. [4 ,5 ]
机构
[1] Johnson & Johnson, New Brunswick, NJ USA
[2] Vantage Leadership Consulting, Chicago, IL USA
[3] Northern Illinois Univ, Psychol, De Kalb, IL USA
[4] Northern Illinois Univ, Ind Org Psychol, De Kalb, IL USA
[5] Northern Illinois Univ, De Kalb, IL USA
关键词
Age; gender; stereotypes; workplace; UNIVERSAL DIMENSIONS; DOUBLE JEOPARDY; CONTENT MODEL; DISCRIMINATION; COMPETENCE; WARMTH; INTERSECTIONALITY; BIAS; MEN;
D O I
10.1177/00332941251352407
中图分类号
B84 [心理学];
学科分类号
04 ; 0402 ;
摘要
Although the content of workplace age and gender stereotypes have been examined extensively, each is rarely considered in light of the other. This leaves us with limited knowledge of whether age stereotypes are similar across genders and whether gender stereotypes are consistent across the lifespan. In the present paper, the content of stereotypes at the intersection of age and gender is explored. Across two qualitative studies, 374 early-career participants provided their beliefs of a target, prompted with either age (Study 1) or gender (Study 2). Open-ended questions and qualitative coding were utilized to explore whether common older worker stereotypes were consistent with stereotypes about older men workers and older women workers and whether common stereotypes about men and women held in equal measure for older and younger targets. Further, comparisons were made across studies to see if two of the same targets (older man worker and older woman worker) would be ascribed different traits depending on which type of stereotype was prompted, i.e., gender or age. Some of the emergent patterns pointed toward a closer similarity of older worker stereotypes to older man stereotypes, gender stereotypes more closely aligned with younger workers, and more disparity in judgments of an older woman when age, rather than gender, was prompted. Also emerging was a tendency toward older men and younger women being viewed in a more positive light. Findings are considered in light of developments in stereotyping research and suggestions for extending this line of work and applying it to workplace practices are put forth.
引用
收藏
页数:28
相关论文
共 55 条
[1]   A Contextual Approach to Stereotype Content Model: Stereotype Contents in Context [J].
Aktan, Timucin .
WORLD CONFERENCE ON PSYCHOLOGY AND SOCIOLOGY 2012, 2013, 82 :440-444
[2]  
BARNUM P, 1995, ACAD MANAGE J, V38, P863, DOI 10.5465/256749
[3]   Work as a Masculinity Contest [J].
Berdahl, Jennifer L. ;
Cooper, Marianne ;
Glick, Peter ;
Livingston, Robert W. ;
Williams, Joan C. .
JOURNAL OF SOCIAL ISSUES, 2018, 74 (03) :422-448
[4]   Exploring midlife identity negotiations in the context of the gender career gap: an interdisciplinary conceptual framework [J].
Burke, Vanessa ;
Cheung, Ho Kwan ;
Finkelstein, Lisa M. .
WORK AGING AND RETIREMENT, 2025,
[5]   OLD AND FEMALE - TESTING THE DOUBLE JEOPARDY HYPOTHESIS [J].
CHAPPELL, NL ;
HAVENS, B .
SOCIOLOGICAL QUARTERLY, 1980, 21 (02) :157-171
[6]   Agentic but not warm: Age-gender interactions and the consequences of stereotype incongruity perceptions for middle-aged professional women [J].
Chatman, Jennifer A. ;
Sharps, Daron ;
Mishra, Sonya ;
Kray, Laura J. ;
North, Michael S. .
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR AND HUMAN DECISION PROCESSES, 2022, 173
[7]   Moving beyond social categories by incorporating context in social psychological theory [J].
Cikara, Mina ;
Martinez, Joel E. ;
Lewis Jr, Neil A. .
NATURE REVIEWS PSYCHOLOGY, 2022, 1 (09) :537-549
[8]  
Cleveland JN, 2017, ADV SER MANAG, V17, P119, DOI 10.1108/S1877-636120170000017007
[9]   Intersectionality and Research in Psychology [J].
Cole, Elizabeth R. .
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST, 2009, 64 (03) :170-180
[10]   Burned out by the binary: how misgendering of nonbinary employees contributes to workplace burnout [J].
Corby, Sky ;
Martinez, Larry R. ;
Smith, Nicholas A. ;
Hamilton, Kelly M. ;
Dullum, Mordeky C. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, 2025, 36 (07) :1129-1163