Objectives: Emerging evidence suggests that alexithymia, a psychological construct defined by the inability to describe emotion, differentiate feelings, and think in an internally oriented way, may be relevant in understanding engagement in nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI). However, there is a paucity of longitudinal work on alexithymia and NSSI, which is necessary to discern whether alexithymia may heighten risk for NSSI over time. Methods: In the present study, the association between alexithymia and NSSI was examined among 1125 emerging adults (Mage = 17.96, 72% female), who completed a survey at two time points 4 months apart. Results: Participants with a history of NSSI reported higher levels of alexithymia than those with no NSSI engagement. A zero-inflated negative binomial regression model revealed that higher alexithymia at Time 1 predicted greater diversity in NSSI methods (i.e., NSSI versatility), but not NSSI frequency, at Time 2, for those already engaging in NSSI (p < 0.01, controlling for NSSI history at Time 1, emotion regulation difficulties, age, and gender). Significant differences were found in NSSI functions based on alexithymia among individuals with a lifetime history of NSSI at both time points. Among participants with a history of NSSI, alexithymia was most strongly correlated with anti-dissociation, sensation seeking, self-punishment, toughness, and interpersonal boundaries NSSI functions. Conclusion: Findings underscore that alexithymia may be relevant to understanding NSSI severity.