A core outcome set for best care for the dying person: Results of an international Delphi study and consensus meeting

被引:2
|
作者
Zambrano, Sofia C. [1 ,2 ]
Egloff, Martina [2 ]
Gonzalez-Jaramillo, Valentina [2 ]
Christen-Cevallos Rosero, Andri [2 ]
Allan, Simon [3 ]
Barnestein-Fonseca, Pilar [4 ]
Ellershaw, John [5 ]
Fischer, Claudia [6 ]
Haugen, Dagny Faksvag [7 ,8 ]
Lunder, Urska [9 ]
Martin-Rosello, Marisa [4 ]
Mason, Stephen [5 ]
Rasmussen, Birgit [10 ,11 ]
Sigurdardottir, Valgerdur [12 ]
Simon, Judt [6 ]
Tripodoro, Vilma A. [13 ,14 ]
van der Heide, Agnes [15 ]
van Zuylen, Lia [16 ]
Voltz, Raymond [17 ]
Furst, Carl Johan [10 ]
Williamson, Paula R. [18 ]
Eychmueller, Steffen [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bern, Inst Social & Prevent Med, ISPM, Bern, Switzerland
[2] Bern Univ Hosp, Inselspital, Univ Ctr Palliat Care, Bern, Switzerland
[3] Arohanui Hosp, Palmerston North, New Zealand
[4] CUDECA Hosp Fdn, CUDECA Inst Training & Res Palliat Care, Malaga, Spain
[5] Univ Liverpool, Palliat Care Unit, Liverpool, England
[6] Med Univ Vienna, Ctr Publ Hlth, Dept Hlth Econ, A-1090 Vienna, Austria
[7] Univ Bergen, Dept Clin Med K1, Bergen, Norway
[8] Western Norway, Haukeland Univ Hosp, Bergen, Western Norway, Norway
[9] Univ Clin Pulm & Allerg Dis Golnik, Golnik, Slovenia
[10] Lund Univ, Inst Palliat Care, Lund, Sweden
[11] Lund Univ, Dept Hlth Sci, Lund, Sweden
[12] Landspitali Natl Univ Hosp, Palliat Care Unit, Reykjavik, Iceland
[13] Inst Pallium Latinoamer, Buenos Aires, Argentina
[14] Univ Navarra, ATLANTES Global Observ Palliat Care, Pamplona, Spain
[15] Erasmus MC, Univ Med Ctr Rotterdam, Dept Publ Hlth, Rotterdam, Netherlands
[16] Univ Amsterdam, Med Ctr, Dept Med Oncol, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[17] Univ Klinikum Koln AoR, Dept Palliat Care, Cologne, Germany
[18] Univ Liverpool, Dept Hlth Data Sci, Liverpool, England
基金
欧盟地平线“2020”; 瑞士国家科学基金会;
关键词
terminal care; palliative care; quality of care; core outcome set; Delphi method; PALLIATIVE CARE; QUALITY INDICATORS; END;
D O I
10.1177/02692163241300867
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: Outcome measurement is essential to progress clinical practice and improve patient care.Aim: To develop a Core Outcome Set for best care for the dying person.Design: We followed the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) Initiative guidelines, which involved identifying potential outcomes via a systematic literature review (n = 619 papers) and from participants in the "iLIVE" project (10 countries: 101 patients, 37 family members, 63 clinicians), followed by a two-round Delphi study, and a consensus meeting.Setting/participants: Clinicians, researchers, family members, and patient representatives from 20 countries participated in the Delphi Rounds 1 (n = 462) and 2 (n = 355). Thirty-two participants attended the consensus meeting.Results: From the systematic review and the cohort study we identified 256 and 238 outcomes respectively, from which we extracted a 52-outcome list covering areas related to the patients' physical, psychosocial, and spiritual dimensions, family support, place of care and care delivery, relational aspects of care, and general concepts. A preliminary 13-outcome list reached consensus during the Delphi. At the consensus meeting, a 14-item Core Outcome Set was ratified by the participants.Conclusions: This study involved a large and diverse sample of key stakeholders in defining the core outcome set for best care for the dying person, focusing on the last days of life. By actively integrating the perspectives of family carers and patient representatives from various cultural backgrounds this Core Outcome Set enriches our understanding of essential elements of care for the dying and provides a solid foundation for advancing quality of end-of-life care.
引用
收藏
页码:163 / 175
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Core Outcome Set for IgE-mediated food allergy clinical trials and observational studies of interventions: International Delphi consensus study 'COMFA'
    Demidova, Anastasia
    Drewitz, Karl Philipp
    Kimkool, Parisut
    Banjanin, Nikolina
    Barzylovich, Vladyslava
    Botjes, Erna
    Capper, India
    Castor, Mary Anne R.
    Comberiati, Pasquale
    Cook, Emma E.
    Costa, Joana
    Chu, Derek K.
    Epstein, Michelle M.
    Galvin, Audrey Dunn
    Giovannini, Mattia
    Girard, Frederic
    Golding, Michael A.
    Greenhawt, Matthew
    Ierodiakonou, Despo
    Jones, Christina J.
    Khaleva, Ekaterina
    Knibb, Rebecca C.
    Macit-celebi, Melahat Sedanur
    Mack, Douglas P.
    Mafra, Isabel
    Marchisotto, Mary Jane
    Mijakoski, Dragan
    Nekliudov, Nikita
    Ozdemir, Cevdet
    Patel, Nandinee
    Pazukhina, Ekaterina
    Protudjer, Jennifer L. P.
    Rodriguez del Rio, Pablo
    Roomet, Jelena
    Sammut, Patrick
    Schoos, Ann-Marie Malby
    Schopfer, Anita Fossaluzza
    Schultz, Fallon
    Seylanova, Nina
    Skypala, Isabel
    Sorensen, Martin
    Stoleski, Sasho
    Stylianou, Eva
    Upton, Julia
    van de Veen, Willem
    Genuneit, Jon
    Boyle, Robert J.
    Apfelbacher, Christian
    Munblit, Daniel
    ALLERGY, 2024, 79 (04) : 977 - 989
  • [32] A Core Outcome Set for Research Evaluating Interventions to Enable Communication in Patients With an Artificial Airway: An International Delphi Consensus Study (Comm-COS)
    Freeman-Sanderson, Amy
    Brodsky, Martin B.
    Dale, Craig
    Gupta, Anushua
    Haines, Kimberley
    Happ, Mary Beth
    Hart, Nicholas
    Hemsley, Bronwyn
    Istanboulian, Laura
    Spronk, Peter
    Sullivan, Rebecca
    Sutt, Anna-Liisa
    Rose, Louise
    CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE, 2024, 52 (09) : e450 - e462
  • [33] Delphi procedure in core outcome set development: rating scale and consensus criteria determined outcome selection
    De Meyer, Dorien
    Kottner, Jan
    Beele, Hilde
    Schmitt, Jochen
    Lange, Toni
    Van Hecke, Ann
    Verhaeghe, Sofie
    Beeckman, Dimitri
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2019, 111 : 23 - 31
  • [34] International Core Outcome Set for Acute Simple Appendicitis in Children Results of a Systematic Review, Delphi Study, and Focus Croups With Young People
    Knaapen, Max
    Hall, Nigel J.
    Moulin, Darcy
    van der Lee, Johanna H.
    Butcher, Nancy J.
    Minneci, Peter C.
    Svensson, Jan F.
    St Peter, Shawn D.
    Adams, Susan
    Nah, Shireen A.
    Skarsgard, Erik D.
    Zani, Augusto
    Emil, Sherif
    Suominen, Janne S.
    Aziz, Dayang A.
    Rai, Rambha
    Offringa, Martin
    van Heurn, Ernst W.
    Bakx, Roel
    Gorter, Ramon R.
    Pediatric Appendicitis COS Dev Grp
    ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2022, 276 (06) : 1047 - 1055
  • [35] Systematic review of international Delphi surveys for core outcome set development: representation of international patients
    Lee, Alice
    Davies, Anna
    Young, Amber E.
    BMJ OPEN, 2020, 10 (11):
  • [36] The NeoPACE study: study protocol for the development of a core outcome set for neonatal palliative care
    Gallagher, Katie
    Chant, Kathy
    Mancini, Alex
    Bluebond-Langner, Myra
    Marlow, Neil
    BMC PALLIATIVE CARE, 2023, 22 (01)
  • [37] Development of a core outcome set for informed consent for therapy: An international key stakeholder consensus study
    Liam J. Convie
    Joshua M. Clements
    Scott McCain
    Jeffrey Campbell
    Stephen J. Kirk
    Mike Clarke
    BMC Medical Ethics, 23
  • [38] Protocol for developing a core outcome set for male infertility research: an international consensus development study
    Rimmer, Michael P.
    Howie, Ruth A.
    Anderson, Richard A.
    Barratt, Christopher L. R.
    Barnhart, Kurt T.
    Beebeejaun, Yusuf
    Bertolla, Ricardo Pimenta
    Bhattacharya, Siladitya
    Bjorndahl, Lars
    Bortoletto, Pietro
    Brannigan, Robert E.
    Cantineau, Astrid E. P.
    Caroppo, Ettore
    Collura, Barbara L.
    Coward, Kevin
    Eisenberg, Michael L.
    De Geyter, Christian
    Goulis, Dimitrios G.
    Henkel, Ralf R.
    Ho, Vu N. A.
    Hussein, Alayman F.
    Huyser, Carin
    Kadijk, Jozef H.
    Kamath, Mohan S.
    Khashaba, Shadi
    Kobori, Yoshitomo
    Kopeika, Julia
    Kucuk, Tansu
    Lujan, Saturnino
    Matsaseng, Thabo Christopher
    Mathur, Raj S.
    McEleny, Kevin
    Mitchell, Rod T.
    Mol, Ben W.
    Murage, Alfred M.
    Ng, Ernest H. Y.
    Pacey, Allan
    Perheentupa, Antti H.
    Du Plessis, Stefan
    Rives, Nathalie
    Sarris, Ippokratis
    Schlegel, Peter N.
    Shabbir, Majid
    Smiechowski, Maciej
    Subramanian, Venkatesh
    Sunkara, Sesh K.
    Tarlarzis, Basil C.
    Tuttelmann, Frank
    Vail, Andy
    van Wely, Madelon
    HUMAN REPRODUCTION OPEN, 2022, 2022 (02)
  • [39] Development of a core outcome set for informed consent for therapy: An international key stakeholder consensus study
    Convie, Liam J.
    Clements, Joshua M.
    McCain, Scott
    Campbell, Jeffrey
    Kirk, Stephen J.
    Clarke, Mike
    BMC MEDICAL ETHICS, 2022, 23 (01)
  • [40] Developing a set of consensus indicators to support maternity service quality improvement: using Core Outcome Set methodology including a Delphi process
    Bunch, K. J.
    Allin, B.
    Jolly, M.
    Hardie, T.
    Knight, M.
    BJOG-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNAECOLOGY, 2018, 125 (12) : 1612 - 1618