From shared grievances to collective action: A multilevel study of economic adversity and protest

被引:0
作者
Azedi, Arman [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Irvine, 3151 Social Sci Plaza, Irvine, CA 92697 USA
关键词
Collective action; economics; grievances; protest; social change; action collective; aspects & eacute; conomiques; changement social; manifestation; revendications; acci & oacute; n colectiva; agravios; cambio social; econom & iacute; a; protesta; POLITICAL-PARTICIPATION; SOCIAL-MOVEMENTS; EUROPE; RESOURCES; CRISIS; OPPORTUNITIES; DETERMINANTS; DEPRIVATION; EMOTIONS; OCCUPY;
D O I
10.1177/02685809241292076
中图分类号
C91 [社会学];
学科分类号
030301 ; 1204 ;
摘要
Strongly felt grievances are the first, necessary condition for collective action to occur. While social movement studies have explored how activists frame grievances to attract recruits, this study assesses whether the pervasiveness of economic grievances in society affects individual decisions to join protests. Using data from nine rounds of the European Social Survey across 33 countries (2002-2019), multilevel models reveal that the population's average sense of economic difficulty significantly predicts individuals' willingness to participate in protests. The relationship holds when controlling for other objective economic indicators frequently used as substitutes for economic grievances in previous research, such as unemployment and GDP growth. Protesters also tend to be wealthier and financially comfortable when there is intense economic distress across society, while protest rates decline among the most aggrieved people. The findings suggest the importance of economic grievances lies on the contextual rather than the individual level: people are influenced to mobilize based on social assessments of others' economic suffering but are less responsive to their own economic problems. L'existence de griefs fortement ressentis est la condition premi & egrave;re n & eacute;cessaire pour que se produise une action collective. & Agrave; la diff & eacute;rence des & eacute;tudes consacr & eacute;es aux mouvements sociaux qui examinent la mani & egrave;re dont les activistes formulent leurs griefs pour attirer des recrues, cette & eacute;tude analyse si l'omnipr & eacute;sence des griefs & eacute;conomiques dans la soci & eacute;t & eacute; influe sur les d & eacute;cisions individuelles de participer & agrave; des manifestations. & Agrave; partir des donn & eacute;es issues de neuf & eacute;ditions de l'Enqu & ecirc;te sociale europ & eacute;enne dans 33 pays (2002-2019), les mod & egrave;les multiniveaux montrent que la perception moyenne qu'a la population des difficult & eacute;s & eacute;conomiques pr & eacute;dit de mani & egrave;re significative la pr & eacute;disposition des individus & agrave; participer & agrave; des manifestations. Cette relation reste valable lorsqu'on tient compte d'autres indicateurs & eacute;conomiques objectifs fr & eacute;quemment utilis & eacute;s dans des recherches ant & eacute;rieures comme substituts des griefs & eacute;conomiques, tels que le ch & ocirc;mage et la croissance du PIB. Les manifestants ont & eacute;galement tendance & agrave; & ecirc;tre plus riches et plus & agrave; l'aise financi & egrave;rement lorsque la d & eacute;tresse & eacute;conomique est intense dans l'ensemble de la soci & eacute;t & eacute;, tandis que les taux de contestation diminuent parmi les personnes les plus l & eacute;s & eacute;es. Les r & eacute;sultats semblent indiquer que l'importance des revendications & eacute;conomiques se situe au niveau contextuel plut & ocirc;t qu'au niveau individuel : les gens sont port & eacute;s & agrave; se mobiliser sur la base d'& eacute;valuations sociales de la souffrance & eacute;conomique des autres, mais tiennent moins compte de leurs propres probl & egrave;mes & eacute;conomiques. La primera condici & oacute;n necesaria para que se produzca una acci & oacute;n colectiva es la existencia de agravios que son sentidos profundamente. Mientras que los estudios sobre los movimientos sociales han explorado c & oacute;mo los activistas formulan sus agravios para atraer a nuevos participantes, este art & iacute;culo eval & uacute;a si la omnipresencia de los agravios econ & oacute;micos en la sociedad afecta a las decisiones individuales de sumarse a las protestas. Utilizando datos de nueve rondas de la Encuesta Social Europea en 33 pa & iacute;ses (2002-2019), los modelos multinivel revelan que la percepci & oacute;n media que tiene la poblaci & oacute;n de las dificultades econ & oacute;micas predice significativamente la disposici & oacute;n de los individuos a participar en las protestas. Esta relaci & oacute;n se mantiene cuando se controla por otros indicadores econ & oacute;micos objetivos utilizados con frecuencia en investigaciones anteriores como sustitutos de los agravios econ & oacute;micos, como el desempleo y el crecimiento del PIB. Los manifestantes tambi & eacute;n tienden a ser m & aacute;s ricos y econ & oacute;micamente acomodados cuando hay una intensa angustia econ & oacute;mica en la sociedad, mientras que las tasas de protesta disminuyen entre las personas m & aacute;s agraviadas. Los hallazgos sugieren que la importancia de los agravios econ & oacute;micos reside m & aacute;s en el nivel contextual que en el nivel individual: las personas se ven influenciadas para movilizarse en funci & oacute;n de las evaluaciones sociales del sufrimiento econ & oacute;mico de los dem & aacute;s, pero son menos receptivas a sus propios problemas econ & oacute;micos.
引用
收藏
页码:3 / 32
页数:30
相关论文
共 78 条
[1]  
Almeida P.D., 2018, The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, P43, DOI [10.1002/9781119168577.ch2, DOI 10.1002/9781119168577.CH2]
[2]  
[Anonymous], 2020, EUROPEAN SOCIAL SURV, DOI [10.21338/NSD-ESS-CUMULATIVE, DOI 10.21338/NSD-ESS-CUMULATIVE]
[3]   The conditional impact of blame attribution on the relationship between economic adversity and turnout [J].
Arceneaux, K .
POLITICAL RESEARCH QUARTERLY, 2003, 56 (01) :67-75
[4]   Assessing the Anti-Globalization Movement: Protest Against the WTO, IMF, and World Bank in Cross-National Perspective [J].
Azedi, Arman ;
Schofer, Evan .
SOCIOLOGICAL QUARTERLY, 2023, 64 (03) :445-470
[5]   Does Job Insecurity Motivate Protest Participation? A Multilevel Analysis of Working-Age People from 18 Developed Countries [J].
Azedi, Arman .
SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES, 2023, 66 (03) :476-495
[6]   Framing processes and social movements: An overview and assessment [J].
Benford, RD ;
Snow, DA .
ANNUAL REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY, 2000, 26 :611-639
[7]  
Bergstrand K, 2014, MOBILIZATION, V19, P123
[8]  
Bernburg JonGunnar., 2016, MOBIL SER SOC MOVEME
[9]   BEYOND SES - A RESOURCE MODEL OF POLITICAL-PARTICIPATION [J].
BRADY, HE ;
VERBA, S ;
SCHLOZMAN, KL .
AMERICAN POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW, 1995, 89 (02) :271-294
[10]  
Buechler StevenM., 2004, BLACKWELL COMPANION, P47, DOI DOI 10.1002/9780470999103.CH3