Using Unannounced Standardized Patients to Assess the Quality of Tuberculosis Care and Antibiotic Prescribing: A Cross-Sectional Study on a Low/Middle-Income Country, Pakistan

被引：0
作者：
Zhao, Mingyue [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Gillani, Ali Hassan [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Hussain, Hafiz Rashid [4 ]
Arshad, Hafsa [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Arshed, Muhammad [5 ,6 ]
Fang, Yu [1 ,2 ,3 ]
机构：
[1] Xi An Jiao Tong Univ, Sch Pharm, Dept Pharm Adm & Clin Pharm, Xian 710049, Peoples R China
[2] Xi An Jiao Tong Univ, Ctr Drug Safety & Policy Res, Xian 710049, Peoples R China
[3] Shaanxi Ctr Hlth Reform & Dev Res, Xian 710061, Peoples R China
[4] Univ Sargodha, Coll Pharm, Sargodha 40100, Punjab, Pakistan
[5] Baqai Med Univ, Baqai Med Coll, Dept Community Med, Karachi 75340, Sindh, Pakistan
[6] Univ Lahore, Univ Inst Publ Hlth, Fac Allied Hlth Sci, Lahore 54590, Punjab, Pakistan
来源：
ANTIBIOTICS-BASEL | 2025年 / 14卷 / 02期
关键词：
standardized patients; antibiotic prescribing; tuberculosis; Punjab; Pakistan; COMMUNITY-ACQUIRED PNEUMONIA; MANAGEMENT; INFECTION; DIAGNOSIS; DIARRHEA; INDIA; FLUOROQUINOLONES; PHARMACIES; DELAY; TB;
D O I：
10.3390/antibiotics14020175
中图分类号：
R51 [传染病];
学科分类号：
100401 ;
摘要：
Background: Pakistan is classified as a high-burden country for tuberculosis, and the prescription of antibiotics and fluoroquinolones complicates the detection and treatment of the disease. The existing literature primarily relies on knowledge questionnaires and prescription analyses, which focus on healthcare providers' knowledge rather than their actual clinical practices. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the quality of tuberculosis care using standardized patients. Materials and Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional study, recruiting consenting private healthcare practitioners in four cities in Punjab, Pakistan. Standardized patients were engaged from the general public to simulate four cases: two suspected tuberculosis cases (Case 1 and 2), one confirmed tuberculosis case (Case 3), and one suspected multidrug-resistant tuberculosis case (Case 4). The optimal management in Cases 1 and 2 was referral for sputum testing, chest X-ray, or referral to a public facility for directly observed treatment short-courses without dispensing antibiotics, fluoroquinolones, and steroids. In Case 3, treatment with four anti-TB medications was expected, while Case 4 should have prompted a drug-susceptibility test. Descriptive statistics using SPSS version 23 were employed to analyze disparities in referrals, ideal case management, antibiotic use, steroid administration, and the number of medications prescribed. Results: From July 2022 to May 2023, 3321 standardized cases were presented to private healthcare practitioners. Overall, 39.4% of tuberculosis cases were managed optimally, with Case 3 showing the highest rate (56.7%) and Case 4 showing the lowest (19.8%). City-specific analysis revealed that Rawalpindi had the highest management rate (55.8%), while Sialkot had the lowest (30.6%). Antibiotics were most frequently prescribed in Case 1 and least prescribed in Case 4, with a similar pattern for fluoroquinolones. Anti-TB medications were also prescribed in na & iuml;ve and suspected tuberculosis cases (8.3% in Case 1 and 10.8% in Case 2). Conclusions: The quality of tuberculosis management in actual practice is suboptimal among healthcare providers in Pakistan. Furthermore, the over-prescription of antibiotics, fluoroquinolones, and anti-TB drugs presents a significant risk for the development of drug-resistant tuberculosis.
引用
收藏
页数：15
相关论文
共 57 条
  • [1] Global Tuberculosis Report 2022
  • [2] Khursheed S., Wazir S., Saleem M.K., Majeed A.I., Ahmad M., Khan Q.U., Jadoon A., Akbar A., Jadoon S.K., Tasneem S., Et al., Tuberculosis prevalence and demographic characteristics of population in Azad Jammu and Kashmir (Pakistan): A retrospective study, Medicine, 103, (2024)
  • [3] Gillani A.H., Arshad H., Mujtaba H., Umer M.F., Xu S., Ji W., Bashir K., Chang J., Yang C., Fang Y., Dispensing of antibiotics for tuberculosis patients using standardized patient approach at community pharmacies: Results from a cross-sectional study in Pakistan, Front. Public Health, 11, (2024)
  • [4] Khan F.U., Rehman A.U., Khan F.U., Hayat K., Khan A., Ahmad N., Chang J., Malik U.R., Fang Y., Assessment of Factors Associated with Unfavorable Outcomes among Drug-Resistant TB Patients: A 6-Year Retrospective Study from Pakistan, Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 19, (2022)
  • [5] Munir M.K., Rehman S., Iqbal R., Meeting the challenge, making a difference: Multidrug resistance tuberculosis in Pakistan, Pak. J. Med. Res, 57, pp. 1-2, (2018)
  • [6] Khan F.U., Khan F.U., Hayat K., Chang J., Kamran M., Khan A., Malik U.R., Khan A., Fang Y., Impact of Protracted Displacement on Delay in the Diagnosis Associated with Treatment Outcomes: A Cross-Sectional Study in Internally Displaced Tuberculosis Patients of Pakistan, Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 18, (2021)
  • [7] Das J., Kwan A., Daniels B., Satyanarayana S., Subbaraman R., Bergkvist S., Das R.K., Das V., Pai M., Use of standardised patients to assess quality of tuberculosis care: A pilot, cross-sectional study, Lancet Infect. Dis, 15, pp. 1305-1313, (2015)
  • [8] Satyanarayana S., Nair S.A., Chadha S.S., Shivashankar R., Sharma G., Yadav S., Mohanty S., Kamineni V., Wilson N.C., Harries A.D., Et al., From where are tuberculosis patients accessing treatment in India? Results from a cross-sectional community-based survey of 30 districts, PLoS ONE, 6, (2011)
  • [9] Hazarika I., Role of private sector in providing tuberculosis care: Evidence from a population-based survey in India, J. Glob. Infect. Dis, 3, pp. 19-24, (2011)
  • [10] Saqib S.E., Ahmad M.M., Amezcua-Prieto C., Virginia M.-R., Treatment Delay among Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients within the Pakistan National Tuberculosis Control Program, Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg, 99, pp. 143-149, (2018)
123456