Constituent power in political liberalism: Constraining the future?

被引:1
作者
Niesen, Peter [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
关键词
constituent power; political liberalism; Rawls; Habermas; Michelman;
D O I
10.1177/01914537241293378
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In Sovereignty across Generations, Ferrara attempts a dual feat. He demonstrates that political liberalism needs a nuanced doctrine of constituent power to be brought in line with traditional democratic concerns. At the same time, he argues that political liberalism is capable of making constituent power safe for democracy, in reining in its unruly and unbound character. By distinguishing between 'the people' and the electorate, Ferrara develops a transtemporal conception of the constituent subject, allowing moderate transformation but in effect binding all future time-slices of the people. In my comment, I address two issues with this. First, I ask how such accounts deal with the fact of immigration. It is not clear whether a historically indexed constituent subject has the normative power to bind new citizens arriving with quite distinct historical baggage. A second question is whether Ferrara's Rawlsian-Michelmanian take is different from, and superior to, the Habermasian account of constituent power, especially to Habermas's constructive views on supranational constitution-making. Both questions address whether Ferrara's historically indexed account is sufficiently open to future developments.
引用
收藏
页码:1464 / 1473
页数:10
相关论文
共 20 条
[1]   Three Paths to Constitutionalism - and the Crisis of the European Union [J].
Ackerman, Bruce .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE, 2015, 45 (04) :705-714
[2]  
Arato, 2018, ADVENTURES CONSTITUE
[3]  
Bobbio, 1997, BOBBIO DAL FASCISMO
[4]  
Brunkhorst Hauke., 2014, Critical Theory of Legal Revolution
[5]   Can the people exercise constituent power? [J].
Duke, George .
ICON-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAW, 2023, :798-825
[6]  
Ferrara, 2023, CONSTITUENT POWER PO
[7]  
Habermas Jurgen., 2012, The Crisis of the European Union
[8]  
John, 2003, 3 LETT LAW PEOPLES E
[9]  
Joseph Sieyes Emmanuel, 2003, POLITICAL WRITINGS
[10]   Rawls and the Future: On the Possibility of Cooperation across Time [J].
Karnein, Anja .
PHILOSOPHY & PUBLIC AFFAIRS, 2022, 50 (03) :271-300