Eyes or Nose: Domestic Dogs (Canis familiaris) Prefer Vision Over Olfaction When Searching for Food

In recent decades, there has been a growing interest in exploring the cognition of domestic dogs. However, the role of olfaction and vision in dogs' perception of everyday situations has been underexplored. To investigate this topic, we used a simple food-searching paradigm. A treat was hidden in one of three locations, either (a) visible from the starting point (vision condition), (b) invisible from the starting point (smell condition), or (c) invisible with an additional decoy treat presented as a distraction (fake condition). About 87 dogs of various breeds were categorized into either the olfactory-focused or the vision-focused group based on their sniffing behavior in a pretest. It was hypothesized that olfactory-focused dogs would preferentially use their sense of smell for task solving, whereas vision-focused dogs would rely more on visual information. Thus, it was expected that dogs of each group would have an advantage in the corresponding condition. However, there was no difference between groups in the duration to find the food in the three conditions. In general, food was approached faster in the vision condition, and dogs in all groups were distracted by the presence of the fake food. Thus, for all dogs, the visual sense was more dominant than the olfactory sense, and they could easily switch between using the two senses. The results are discussed in light of breed differences and general perception skills of domestic dogs.