Trust in the healthcare system declines after exposure to information about the harms and benefits of breast cancer screening

被引：0
作者：
Parmet, Tamar [1 ,2 ]
Yoder, Grant [1 ,2 ]
Morse, Brad [1 ,3 ]
Cappella, Joseph [4 ,5 ]
Schapira, Marilyn [4 ,5 ]
Lewis, Carmen [1 ,3 ]
Mccaffery, Kirsten [6 ]
Smyth, Heather [1 ,3 ]
Hersch, Jolyn [6 ]
Scherer, Laura D. [1 ,3 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Colorado, Sch Med, Aurora, CO USA
[2] Univ Colorado Denver, Denver, CO USA
[3] Univ Colorado, Anschutz Med Campus, Aurora, CO USA
[4] Univ Penn, Philadelphia, PA USA
[5] Philadelphia VA Med Ctr, Philadelphia, PA USA
[6] Univ Sydney, Sydney, Australia
来源：
JOURNAL OF HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY | 2025年
关键词：
breast cancer; breast cancer screening; cancer; communication; health promotion; mammography; CHOICE; RISK;
D O I：
10.1177/13591053251315383
中图分类号：
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号：
040203 ;
摘要：
Conflicting health messages negatively impact trust. Breast cancer screening (BCS) is one area of healthcare where conflicting messages are common. We examined whether women's healthcare system trust was impacted after exposure to information about harms and benefits of BCS. We enrolled 497 women into this study. Participants were administered a decision aid (DA) containing information about the harms and benefits of BCS and reported their healthcare system trust pre- and post-DA exposure. We observed a significant decrease in healthcare system trust from pre- to post-DA. This decrease in trust was associated with participants' perception that the message conflicted with their previously held beliefs and not the reactions it elicited. When people receive information about BCS that conflicts with past health messages, they may lose trust in the healthcare system. This underscores the importance of adopting consistent messages about BCS.
引用
收藏
页数：7
相关论文
共 21 条
  • [1] Conflicting health information: a critical research need
    Carpenter, Delesha M.
    Geryk, Lorie L.
    Chen, Annie T.
    Nagler, Rebekah H.
    Dieckmann, Nathan F.
    Han, Paul K. J.
    [J]. HEALTH EXPECTATIONS, 2016, 19 (06) : 1173 - 1182
  • [2] Validation studies for models projecting the risk of invasive and total breast cancer incidence
    Costantino, JP
    Gail, MH
    Pee, D
    Anderson, S
    Redmond, CK
    Benichou, J
    Wieand, HS
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE, 1999, 91 (18) : 1541 - 1548
  • [3] Aspirin Use to Prevent Cardiovascular Disease US Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation Statement
    Davidson, Karina W.
    Barry, Michael J.
    Mangione, Carol M.
    Cabana, Michael
    Chelmow, David
    Coker, Tumaini Rucker
    Davis, Esa M.
    Donahue, Katrina E.
    Jaen, Carlos Roberto
    Krist, Alex H.
    Kubik, Martha
    Li, Li
    Ogedegbe, Gbenga
    Pbert, Lori
    Ruiz, John M.
    Stevermer, James
    Tseng, Chien-Wen
    Wong, John B.
    [J]. JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2022, 327 (16): : 1577 - 1584
  • [4] Overdiagnosis Due to Screening Mammography for Breast Cancer among Women Aged 40 Years and Over: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Flemban, Arwa F.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PERSONALIZED MEDICINE, 2023, 13 (03):
  • [5] Use of a decision aid including information on overdetection to support informed choice about breast cancer screening: a randomised controlled trial
    Hersch, Jolyn
    Barratt, Alexandra
    Jansen, Jesse
    Irwig, Les
    McGeechan, Kevin
    Jacklyn, Gemma
    Thornton, Hazel
    Dhillon, Haryana
    Houssami, Nehmat
    McCaffery, Kirsten
    [J]. LANCET, 2015, 385 (9978) : 1642 - 1652
  • [6] Women's views on overdiagnosis in breast cancer screening: a qualitative study
    Hersch, Jolyn
    Jansen, Jesse
    Barratt, Alexandra
    Irwig, Les
    Houssami, Nehmat
    Howard, Kirsten
    Dhillon, Haryana
    McCaffery, Kirsten
    [J]. BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2013, 346
  • [7] Perceptions of Conflicting Breast Cancer Screening Recommendations Among Racially/Ethnically Diverse Women: a Multimethod Study
    Housten, Ashley J.
    Hoover, Diana S.
    Britton, Maggie
    Bevers, Therese B.
    Street, Richard L.
    McNeill, Lorna H.
    Strong, Larkin L.
    Hersch, Jolyn
    McCaffery, Kirsten
    Volk, Robert J.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF GENERAL INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2022, 37 (05) : 1145 - 1154
  • [8] Source-specific Exposure to Contradictory Nutrition Information: Documenting Prevalence and Effects on Adverse Cognitive and Behavioral Outcomes
    Lee, Chul-joo
    Nagler, Rebekah H.
    Wang, Ningxin
    [J]. HEALTH COMMUNICATION, 2018, 33 (04) : 453 - 461
  • [9] McCaffery KJ., 2016, BMJ, V352
  • [10] Vulnerability to the Effects of Conflicting Health Information: Testing the Moderating Roles of Trust in News Media and Research Literacy
    Nagler, Rebekah H.
    Vogel, Rachel, I
    Rothman, Alexander J.
    Yzer, Marco C.
    Gollust, Sarah E.
    [J]. HEALTH EDUCATION & BEHAVIOR, 2023, 50 (02) : 224 - 233
123